Quote Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy View Post
Does no one even care that Sasaki pulled a fast one and lied to me about his duel strength?

I care!


Because, as an innocent mason about to DIE, my partner has asked for as much info as I can get.
1) I don't like when townies form private groups where they gather information. For one thing it takes a lot of the fun out of the game (it was the reason I switched sides in capo II for example) and for another...

2) "private" townie groups usually end up being infiltrated. The risk is 10x as much in a game with this many roles. Can the mafia infiltrate the group? Is their a role whose sole purpose is to create mischief? Can the mafia recruit from the previously innocent? Is there a role that can switch sides?

3) I don't trust your judgement on what to do with said information. You tend to blow things out of proportion.

Quote Originally Posted by TinCow
This is important to remember in future rounds. I can't come up with an explanation for Ares' reveals which don't make him a likely threat to the town and worthwhile lynch. However, we should not automatically assume that he is either a serial killer or a mafioso at this point. He could be either, or he could be some other role of which we are unaware. Picking a specific role and calling him that for the rest of the game risks cementing potentially faulty assumptions.
You would be the one at risk if we assumed Ares had a partner at some point...I can see why you wouldn't want to much weight to be placed on that. You didn't seem like your usual self in your defense of ares.