The Settlement [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

Pizza: I still havent' forgiven you for going Gotterdamerung on your sheep. Baaaaaad Shepherd, baaaaaaaad! But a pretty decent Mason. ;-)

She was askin' for it. She was wearin' that sexy wool number I always liked.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And I've identified several areas of my Mason play that can be improved upon, should i ever be a mason again. I actually think I made too many mistakes. Good info does not always a good mason make.

[Andres]

Alright, that's a reasonable explanation and I'll accept it. However, I do feel the need to point out that GH just got us to lynch a killer while dead and without any PMs or evidence of any kind.

Yeah, tell me about it

[GeneralHankerchief]

[Askthepizzaguy]

That's the same look that Fluffy gave me.

[White_eyes:D]

What, was it a lucky guess? or did you have a role investigation-type???

[Reenk Roink]

The man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty returned to his tent much after the sun had retired to her resting place. He was incredibly disappointed as he tossed a short blade on the ground. Taking a drink from his canteen, he caught a glimpse of a grim faced, red robed man staring at him.

Spinning around, the man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty quickly dodged a fireball hurled at him. The sorcerer of Vode was unfazed by the miss and prepared another fireball, but the man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty was extremely agile and dodged everything thrown at him. He laughed and taunted the red robed sorcerer: "Hahaha! I am one of the best men of Carn, do you really think you can hit me?"

The man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty then pulled out two daggers and threw them at the sorcerer of Vode, who simply waved his hand causing them to sway well off their mark. He then cast a spell which cause the man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty to be surrounded by a circular wall of fire.

Seeing his doom, the man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty pleaded with the sorcerer of Vode: "Please! I have nothing against you. I just want to kill The Watcher for what he has done to me and my friends. I know! I can help you. The Watcher is a formidable opponent, but I am a master assassin. We can work together, for I am sure The Watcher plots against you!

The red robed man's only reply was to grimly stare at the man of a faction which wished to become heirs by marrying daughters of royalty. He then brought his hands together and the wall of fire that surrounded the doomed assassin converged and burned him to a crisp.

As the sun rose from her slumber, all the settlers once again were called to the gathering hall by the priest king to discuss the most recent murder, although Reenk Roink was much less saddened by the death of this man whom he referred to as a criminal. All settlers were present on time to begin the discussion.

Challenge List:


Alive:

taka
White_eyes:D
seireikhaan
Lord Winter
Captain Blackadder
Psychonaut
CountArach
boudica
Jolt
TinCow
Ichigo
Yoyoma1910
Tristan de Castelrang
Sigurd
LittleGrizzly
Seamus Fermanagh

Executed:

777Ares777
Askthepizzaguy
Andres

Fallen in battle:


Killed:

TheFlax
pevergreen
Gaius Scribonius Curio
Sasaki Kojiro
Beefy187
shlin28
GeneralHankerchief
FactionHeir

Day ends on Saturday, March 21 at 20:00 Eastern

[GeneralHankerchief]

Well good, that saved some time.

[Captain Blackadder]

Hmm it looks like the townie infomation has a leak in it since I guess we all know who Anonymous Too Living Player was.

[Jolt]

bleh. It appears the doom & gloom were right as the network may well be infiltrated by what we just saw.

[TinCow]

The choice of FactionHeir is... interesting. It is indeed obvious that FH was the Thief whose role PM Seamus revealed. I'm not quite sure what to make of this. FH was clearly the leading contender for today's lynch, which makes his elimination odd, since he would have been an easy meat shield for the mafia. The mafioso must have thought he would get something out of this kill that would be worth sacrificing the meat shield. There are two possibilities that spring immediately to mind: (1) discrediting GH by proving that his second suspect was wrong, (2) making it look like ATPG's network had a leak.

However, both of these have problems as well. (1) is essentially pointless, since GH has already proven that he has at least some credible evidence because of Andres' reveal and the absense of the knife-killer last night. (2) could only be possible if the mafioso knew that ATPG's Network itself knew FH's identity. While this is certainly possible, it is very risky for the mafioso, as it would instantly point suspicion at anyone in the ATPG Network who knew this information. The mafioso would have to be either extremely ballsy or think that such an analysis would not point to him.

There is also a third possibility: the mafioso wanted to disrail the town's conversation and cause a bit of chaos. While I suspect this is more the case, we can't ignore (2) and so we should go through the motions on this one. ATPG/Seamus: do you have any reason to suspect anyone else who knew FH's identity?

[LittleGrizzly]

Alternatively they could have figured it out from the pm's like WE's claimed ?


Edit
This post was begun before tincows it was directed at leak in ATPG group that people were saying about...

Could it be a vigilante killer ?

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Sasaki, Pizza, and myself were certainly aware. I will check things out a bit.....

EDIT:

And congrats to herr Reenk on the 1k mark!

[Jolt]

Alternatively they could have figured it out from the pm's like WE's claimed ?


Edit
This post was begun before tincows it was directed at leak in ATPG group that people were saying about...

Could it be a vigilante killer ?

Unless the sorcerer immediatly turned from a Mafioso into a town-loving Vigilante, I doubt it was a kill intended to spare the town a day's worth of lynch.

EDIT: So far, it seems the sorcerer day in and day out kills someone directly related with the network's knowledge. First it was beefy which was known by the Network trio (Not sure if Sasaki did know it though), now its FH.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Only Seamus and only Sasaki were privy to that information, unless FH revealed to someone else.

[Jolt]

Also, from the previous role blockings, we DO know for certain that Yoyoma is not the sorcerer. I don't think its worth lynching Yoyoma just yet.

And why didn't the roleblocker block someone?

[White_eyes:D]

GH....anymore suspects???? and Yoyoma is not guilty....or innocent...I see no reason why he would not be the neutral killer who killed Sasaki...

[Jolt]

GH....anymore suspects???? and Yoyoma is not guilty....or innocent...I see no reason why he would not be the neutral killer who killed Sasaki...

That may be, the fact is that we don't know. I'd rather lynch some lurker who aren't getting any attention and if we continue going at it, they'll reach the end of the game before any of us (Most of the active people here have made suspicious commentaries or have been suspected by someone, while people like Ichigo, taka or Sigurd sail safe winds without opening their mouths. The fact that they pass round after round without uttering one word (Helpful or otherwise) so we know whether they can be suspicious or not, is troubling.

Vote: Sigurd

[LittleGrizzly]

Unless someone's knows something useful or has a good suspect im happy to go with lynching a lurker...

[Captain Blackadder]

So was FH the one who killed Saskai? If so that means we are down to what looks like one night kill which is good and now we can focus on the lurkers does anyone have any preference on which one goes first.

[Jolt]

As far as I'm aware we don't know who killed Sasaki. FH was a thief with investigative abilities, but he didn't kill anyone (I think). I voted for Sigurd since his inactiveness is very unusual.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I believe Sigurd is extremely busy with work.

Lord Winter...boudica...taka, these are people I would be concerned about over sigurd. Dropping to one kill a night should be a huge help.

[TheFlax]

FH is not Pisuf and Pisuf Killed Sasaki. FH's abilities were revealed to the townie network I believe. The only person he could kill was The Watcher, one of the Bronze Companions.

[Jolt]

I believe Sigurd is extremely busy with work.

Lord Winter...boudica...taka, these are people I would be concerned about over sigurd. Dropping to one kill a night should be a huge help.

Hm. I see. No reason to suspect him then, I suppose.

Unvote: Sigurd
Vote: taka

Also extremely inactive.

[Captain Blackadder]

VOTE ICHIGO

3 posts for the entire game now that is just poor.

[TinCow]

I believe Sigurd is extremely busy with work.

I can confirm that Sigurd does indeed have legitimate time issues due to RL work. Given his history, I would not consider him 'cleared' in any way, but I don't think his activity level should be used to judge him.

[taka]

didnt he use some kinda excuse like that in chicago and won his way thru to the end with no suspicions?

[GeneralHankerchief]

If he's lying, this is an across-the-board lie that will damage his reputation forever. I now count four separate mods vouching for him, plus it being stated in the Sasaki thread. If Sigurd wants to win like this, let him.

[LittleGrizzly]

I think your thinking of Seamus...

If were going for the lynch the lurker strategy who better than Ichigo ?

Vote Ichigo

[taka]

o yea, i think it was seamus, not sigurd

[White_eyes:D]

Vote:Ichigo......it would help if he posted more.....