Quote Originally Posted by FactionHeir View Post
Seamus, if we don't take into account the pre-day 1 posts and posts made after game conclusion, what would those numbers be?
I have not really gone to the trouble of calculating things that way, assuming that the pre/post phases are more or less a wash as they tend to be fairly similar from game to game.

This pre phase was a bit longer than usual, however, at about 150 posts.

Just checked. Reenk opened play at post 162. Tincow had 8 posts during the 161-post prequel phase. That would give hime 64 of 903 or a rate of 2.78ppp. Please note, I have NOT done a baseline comparison with other games. The only thing unusual of note was that his posts jumped on the 12th before play began. Excited by contents of his PM? Just having lots of fun with the Marxist debate at the time?


Jolt:

Word has already spread pretty broadly about those detective results -- though no one has a full quote for the rules reasons you mention. Unfortunately, while they almost certainly confirm that Tincow has a role -- possibly a major role -- they bring us no closer to knowing the role intent. Sasaki's observations about Tincow's changed style (we've seen that frequency is pretty constant) very much support the idea that Tincow is a major role. But for whose side?

We've already seen that Reenk has things nicely twisted for us to unravel, so it's making some of us reticent to just jump up and target him.

This is not to say that your implications are off-base. You may well be dead on target. I'm still cogitating it.