The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Not giving up, just pretending to give up to push some emotional buttons and get some unvotes.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Out of curiosity, who told you to get over here and vote?

I'll field that one. I prodded Polemists, because everyone was all up in arms about how we shouldn't lynch a guy on the first turn of a mafia game he might not even be aware had started. And, by the way Andres, I even said I was going to do so in the thread, which you would know if you were reading it.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Once again I see very little of worth to go on. Reenk is being Reenk, as usual. This behavior reminds me a lot of Ephesus in which he would have been lynched for his actions had he not been offed at night first.

Yoyoma, Reenk's current target, also played Ephesus so he should know better. I'm willing to give the players I don't know as much a free pass, at least for this round. While it's tempting to vote Yoyoma, it's more likely that the bad guys are just sitting back and laughing, as usual.

Vote: Ares

Usually louder than this.

[White_eyes:D]

I am going to Vote:Yoyoma Why are you picking on poor Reenk???

[Askthepizzaguy]

I wonder about this bandwagon on Reenk. It is his style to play the WIFOM card a lot, and in unnecessary situations. This seems par for the course for him. I think he's just trying to be entertaining. But at the same time, given how awesome Reenk is, I can't say he didn't get selected as a Godfather or chosen as a henchman, so I will abstain for now and analyze what we have so far.

We need not do a single-minded bandwagon; I think we can pressure vote people into talking at the very least. If Reenk dies, he will still help out, but no reason to waste a round of questioning.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

I'm not a townie! And again, killing is only bad if a bad guy does it.

I see a career for you as a public defender......

Vote: taka

Yes, you normally lurk. Yes, this means I shouldn't find it more threatening this time. However, I didn't like it last time either and I still don't. The more lurkers, the more mafiosi can skate rather than answer questions. This is a hunting principle that has proven valuable in EVERY game I have played, so I will not discard it.

[GeneralHankerchief]

So again, is this vote more out of the fact that you want to change taka's playstyle overall?

[Reenk Roink]

Once again I see very little of worth to go on. Reenk is being Reenk, as usual. This behavior reminds me a lot of Ephesus in which he would have been lynched for his actions had he not been offed at night first.

Yoyoma, Reenk's current target, also played Ephesus so he should know better. I'm willing to give the players I don't know as much a free pass, at least for this round. While it's tempting to vote Yoyoma, it's more likely that the bad guys are just sitting back and laughing, as usual.

Vote: Ares

Usually louder than this.

And this concludes this lesson of how to fool a townie 101.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Unvote:Abstain,Vote:taka

Lynch the lurkers early and the mafia won't lurk...at least in theory.

[Reenk Roink]

nvm

[Askthepizzaguy]

Oh, Seamus, you're practically a lurker in the Settlement game, and I'm not impressed by your contributions here so far. Pot calling the kettle...

You have 12 posts in Settlement, which is lower than your normal activity, and 6 posts here. Now you're voting Taka for "lurking" here when he has 5 more posts than YOU. He has ONE less post than you in Settlement.



Settlement:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Askthepizzaguy 173
777Ares777 63
White_eyes:D 59
Sasaki Kojiro 56
Yoyoma1910 55
TinCow 50
Reenk Roink 42
Andres 32
GeneralHankerchief 30
Jolt 29
seireikhaan 25
CountArach 23
pevergreen 22
boudica 22
shlin28 21
LittleGrizzly 19
Beefy187 18
Captain Blackadder 14
FactionHeir 14
Seamus Fermanagh 12
taka 11
Lord Winter 10
Psychonaut 10
TheFlax 10
Tristan de Castelreng 9
Gaius Scribonius Curio 9
Sigurd 6
Ichigo 3

Inishmore:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Askthepizzaguy 66
Beefy187 38
pevergreen 34
Greyblades 24
Sasaki Kojiro 20
A Very Super Market 19
Reenk Roink 17
777Ares777 14
Andres 11
taka 11
Yoyoma1910 9
YLC 9
F.C is the bees knees 8
White_eyes:D 8
El Diablo 7
FactionHeir 7
LittleGrizzly 7
boudica 6
Seamus Fermanagh 6
GeneralHankerchief 6
gaelic cowboy 5
Jolt 5
Lord Winter 4
Ituralde 4
Captain Blackadder 4
seireikhaan 3
Diana Abnoba 3
CountArach 3
shlin28 2
Sigurd 2
Psychonaut 2
Polemists 2
Alexander the Pretty Good 1

So what's your response to that, mister noble non-lurker?

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Sasaki

[Andres]

Vote: Sasaki

Sound reasoning, solid case. Brilliant stuff.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Oh, Seamus, you're practically a lurker in the Settlement game, and I'm not impressed by your contributions here so far. Pot calling the kettle...

You have 12 posts in Settlement, which is lower than your normal activity, and 6 posts here. Now you're voting Taka for "lurking" here when he has 5 more posts than YOU. He has ONE less post than you in Settlement.

Going by post count alone isn't always possible...Seamus's posts are usually substantial.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ok, fair enough... let's see how substantial they are in this game. Be right back.


edit: completely un-substantial, and mildly hypocritical.

see below.

[GeneralHankerchief]

And this concludes this lesson of how to fool a townie 101.

Eh, feel free to make fun of my play as a townie as usual. But I'll bet you anything I'm right.

[White_eyes:D]

Vote: Sasaki

Nice

[Askthepizzaguy]

post 19- "in" post. Pre-game.
post 160- simply agrees with GH that there is no pattern to the game so far.
post 178- "watch out for the quiet ones".... mmmm.... should we, seamus?
post 182- "I tried" to get the lurkers lynched in Godfather. How did that work out for us?
post 245- vote Taka, lurker....
post 366- vote Taka, lurker.


Seamus' quality posting this game has been limited to a basic lynch the lurker's strategy. Well, Seamus, you've lurked more than Taka.

vote: Seamus. Your much-vaunted "quality" posts are lacking.

[Ituralde]

I think Reenk Roinks random voting is a bit shifty, but he has enough votes already, may even lead to a tie with Yoyoma or Taka, but I'm a bit lazy to make a tally right now.

Vote: Abstain


And also with the weekend coming up I probably won't be able to check this thread regularly. Please don't kill/lynch me.

[A Very Super Market]

What? Oh bugger...

I even had a fake role planned out... bah!

Anyways, I can guarantee you guys that no one knew who I was, since I didn't tell anyone. I do know that I aggravated Ptolemists, Yoyoma, and Lordwinter

[ULC]

Hmmm...

Unvote:Yoyoma
Vote:Seamus

I want more from Seamus too, and am willing to let Yoyoma go for a little bit until more comes up. Plus, just going with User Names...I mean, come on...he HAS to be guilty.

[shlin28]

Vote: Khaan

Because of your sheer awsomeness, I feel I have to vote you. Townies could never be that awsome...

[Andres]

What? Oh bugger...

I even had a fake role planned out... bah!

Anyways, I can guarantee you guys that no one knew who I was, since I didn't tell anyone. I do know that I aggravated Ptolemists, Yoyoma, and Lordwinter

That's a weird post.

[ULC]

That's a weird post.

How so?

[A Very Super Market]

Yeah, I died. Nothing can be weird for me.

[Askthepizzaguy]

AVSM had a name, did he not? I can check the play to see if he would be more pro-town or anti-town.

He was Padraic, and he was killed by Oswald. Either a mafia capped another mafia, or we just lost a pro-town role.

[Andres]

Yeah, I died. Nothing can be weird for me.

I really should pay more attention

I blame The Settlement.

[Askthepizzaguy]

yeah, all that serial killing must get very distracting, Andres

[A Very Super Market]

Nothing left to do but reveal and save you some time.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Hello AVSM.

You have been randomly selected as Padraic, son of Donney. For more character information, check out the story that is going to be put up soon, as a prelude to the game starting.

As for in game functions, you are the Serial Killer. Starting from Night 3, you may kill one person per night. You must write up the kill and send it to me. You will be named in this kill as Padraic, your character. Your name will also be revealed if you are killed or lynched.

To win, simply be the last one left alive, or one of two with Mairead. You receive no bonus for finding out who Mairead is, its just someone you know to be innocent and one you do not have to kill.

If you have any questions on strategies or how to play, feel free to ask.

Good luck.

pevergreen

[Askthepizzaguy]

3 Mafia (IRA)
3 Mafia (English)
3 Pro Town
2 other roles.

I entirely forgot about the neutral roles.
Thanks for saving me some reading, AVSM.