The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

That won't be an actual brass pair until after midnight when the lynch is nearly at hand. I remember when I was mafia in Prometheus, I left the vote looking rather uncomfortable for myself for quite some time.

The end tally, and the behavior between now and then, is most interesting to see.

[Greyblades]

The end tally, and the behavior between now and then, is most interesting to see.

Great, now you've scared everyone away. :P

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Let's talk about your guilt, greyblades.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Names revealed don't necessarily equate to roles. Aside from Oswald, every named role has been Irish and indistinguishable aside from a few little clues given by pever. And these clues will probably be a lot less in lynch scenes than they will in kill scenes (although this is speculation because we haven't had this scenario come up yet).

[Askthepizzaguy]

I believe that all named characters have roles. Can anyone give evidence refuting that? I believe it's actually in one of pever's posts. Let me check.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I meant that if a person has a name it doesn't say what kind of role they have. Yes, there's been hints, but we can't be certain by any means.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Townies do not receive PMs, however, not all roles have been assigned. I am still waiting on the Godfathers choices. After that, I still have to assign the remaining roles, then I can begin.

Every person with a role has a name. In any kill writeups or lynches, if a player with a name features in them, their in game name will be used. (eg, If my name is Bob and I kill Beefy, the write up would say that Bob stalked beefy and killed him.)

Just saw your post, GH. I think it is still fair to say that everyone with a name should be dead before the end of the game, to be on the safe side, yes?

[A Very Super Market]

He mentioned that townies don't get role PMs. That means that all roles HAVE to have names, probably limited by the play.

Oswald is clearly English, and he killed me. If pevergreen WOG'd a mafia, he would tell us, right?

[Greyblades]

Let's talk about your guilt, greyblades.

Sasaki stop bothering me unless you have actual evidence or at least valid suspicions. Something that is actually defendable from instead of "Intuition".

[GeneralHankerchief]

Sasaki stop bothering me unless you have actual evidence or at least valid suspicions.

That sounds a lot like me in Capo II. I was guilty.

[Greyblades]

I am a little peeved at all the "hunches", "intuition" and "spidey sensing"(Thank you El Diablo) that I have been receiving over my last 4 games. I think Psychonaut did it to me twice for pete's sake.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I attempt to always have valid reasons for voting for someone, as a sign of respect. If I don't have a case to make, then the lynch is random. IRL, If the police had a vague intuition that someone were guilty, but no evidence, I think they wouldn't be able to arrest them. I get voted all the time on little or no evidence, and I shrug it off. However, I've seen right here in this thread, reasonless voting seems to be an effective pressure tactic. And mafia games aren't meant to have due process and fair trials for the scum. And since there is little evidence to go on, this is what we have to do to win.

[LittleGrizzly]

It maybethe things you say... i remember a few players earlier weren't sure about you because of some throw away comment, its best to keep them to a minimum, silly throwaway comments that is.... ive been lynched for a few myself...

If you do keep getting in these situations then the name will echo through some people's minds as someone behaving scummy... without a better option these people will then vote for you...

Also this being the 2nd incident now in this game people will start thinking its too much of a coincidence... im starting to think this...

Also angry defense makes some people suspicious...

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Sasaki stop bothering me unless you have actual evidence or at least valid suspicions.

If you had to pick two people as your henchmen who would you pick? And would you be Irish or British?