Results 1 to 30 of 95

Thread: Report!

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    You are doing very well, Crowley!

    Have you decided where you should next look for enemies?
    Will the Germans or Aragonese become more ambitious when France is eliminated?

    By the appearance of your coffers I would suggest you recruit either a new army or a strong navy from the homeland.
    Your British kingdom will never succeed without a good naval force, and you must start the training of this very early.
    I believe you are a competent strategist, but for the purpose of this thread topic I will relate what I would do in your position;

    One of the two allies you have, Aragon or the Romans, must become your enemy - and if you are unlucky - both shall.
    If I wished to fight Aragon, and begin a conquest of Iberia, (Be nice to Portugal), I would be creating as much shipping as possible before the end of the war with France.
    Then you must have a third army levied and placed in Flanders, a perfect place to oversee the German movements, your first and second armies must hold Aquitania and Tolosa.
    By this time you should be occupying the coasts of Northern Iberia with strong fleets, and levying a fourth army, which may put you in deficit.
    Nonetheless, ensure they are prepared for combat and take Navarre from whichever Iberian Faction, and move the army from Aquitania into Aragon.

    At that stage, you can ask yourself; shall I continue past these mountainous fortifications?

    For then you will hold the plug on whichever Iberian faction plotting to move north, and you can focus on the East.

    ----

    I have tried a new mod!

    Having witnessed despair and dread in my Portuguese campaign, and being afraid to press, "End Year", I downloaded Hellenic: Total War!
    I read of a few faults which I was prepared to ignore.. I found them, but I shall persevere!

    I am working on a translation of Kurou Anabaseos currently, so it is very fitting!

    I tried to play a campaign as the Argoi, in the Pro-Classical era, before Persia came to power.
    Lakedaimon and her allies to the south declared war very quickly, but not before I made safe the Twelve Islands and Mitulene, and supported Samothraki with a navy.

    I begged the Koinon Achaian for alliance, which they accepted, and a tight bond between Korinthos kai Athenai te kai Argos formed.
    The three good states, fighting righteously against evil Thebai kai Lakedaimon te kai Ambrakia.

    But it was not to last!

    Not even ten years did the state of Argos last!

    For the Basileus had set the difficulty to hard, which is rather silly in pushy phalagks warfare!

    The first wave of Spartans and Neodamoi attacked Argos, and were with great difficulty defeated.
    Then many mercenaries and new 'Oplitai were ordered for in the state, whilst Elis and Plataia sent hundreds of men to their deaths in Messenia, and much naval strife occurred around Pulos.

    Eventually, ten years after the start date, 1700 men of Argos and 2100 men of Korinthos marched against 1900 men of Lakedaimon.

    The scene was set in Messenia.

    (Perfect I thought! Nearly 6000 men were about to meet, I was having so much fun! Sparta was going to lose!)

    But ... Hooo Bacchos! Hoooo! Harees!

    Here were the gathered allies, and there were the Lakedaimonioi - 500 feet up on an impossible plateau!

    Yes, they had predicted well, the Fates, that some maps gave the horrid advantage of a barely-scalable cliff-face to the defender.

    No matter, there were several ways up, and we had cavalry!
    So off we go to flank the enemy, but of a sudden; the allies of Korinthos decide to scale the most vertical face available to them - and what is more; here come the Spartans scaling down the face to meet them!

    If they don't plunge to their deaths, I believe they shall win!

    So the 500 cavalry from Ludia are sent off into the north to find a way up, whilst the Argan King leads the 'Oplitai to assist his hapless, 'aplos allies!
    Indeed, they scale up just beyond the Spartans and grab at their flank - but the phalagks can not form on a cliff-face - so the melee becomes very scattered.
    And for this reason, the AI Bonus on Hard became unbearable.

    The ally, under the weight, (Literally), of so many troops decides to flee, and Argos alone is left to fight on.
    Everyone is tiring and preparing to rout; when the cavalry, having circumvented over the plateau, charge down the cliff-face and into the backs of the Spartans!

    Ha ha ha, not so impossible after all!

    And indeed, it should not have been - were this Normal.

    But it was not Normal.

    The Spartans kept on, aided by their stat bonuses, who frequently gave them everything they required for battle as they fought on two fronts.


    And hereafter the battle was kept up for an hour, the Achaiai coming back with reinforcements and attacking the backs of the enemy.. but it was futile.
    At the end of this battle, no single Argos remained alive, all Achaiai were fled, and 100 Lakonioi stood their ground.

    ---

    I am not disappointed. I lost. It seemed unfair, but I liked it!

    In fact, the situation turned out completely realistically, unfortunately!
    Just as in those times, these ambitious Hellenic states warred with each other and in each battle completely destroyed the manpower of all countries, "Both sides claiming the victory, yet neither reaping any benefit"*.

    On Normal however, it may be more beneficial.. I must see!

    I will be updating the Portuguese campaign shortly enough.

    *Xenophon, Hellenica.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Report!

    Slightly off-topic, but I do love it around here. It's got to be the most well-read computer games forum on t'internet. I have never read an AAR for any computer game that had a quote from Xenophon.

    Thanks Glenn.

  3. #3

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    Well Glenn mate i *was* doing well lol, not so sure now.

    Please bare in mind this is really my first ever proper go at a campaign.

    My problem is i play a lot (too much really) Crusader Kings and this i feel is definately impacting on how i play MTW, for instance in Crusader Kings Excommunication is something to be avoided at all costs, consequently im terrified to start wars in this game lol, another thing is in CK you have to be patient...very patient and i feel this is another thing holding me back as i dont think ive yet learnt when to press onwards. im happy just sitting back building my economy and not really challenging the status quo at all, i guess im still adjusting to the way this game is meant to be played, enough of this on with the game session!

    Ok i left Frances king cowering in brittany, he was completely cut off from the rest of his country and had no way to get to any other provinces, i sent assasins in to finnsih the job and succeded but only after his heir came of age!!! this was a mistake that would bite me hard later on.

    Now forced into a peace with them i turned my attention to building my empire andbrining my various armies up to scratch and reinforcing all provinces, also beginning to build a fleet of ships, this takes a while with not much happening to be honest HRE mullered the remaining french provinces and then were excommed, i nabbed some rebel french lands and began raking in some serious cash.

    Some years later it very much starts going a bit wrong, The aragonese pitch up and want aquataine i defend my land fairly easily, but the french reckon they can have Normandy back, i put them strait quickly forcing the king back to brittany, by this point im fed up of these one province wonders and invade them with everything i can spare.......dear god that was a big big mistake, i end up routing my entire army off the field sharpish with their cavalry running me down as i go..no doubt they will dine out on that for years convieniently forgetting about the many defeats i inflicted on them. Back to the Aragonese and i take toulouse off of them and press on to their homeland, i dish out an almighty defeat and come back to the map screen only to see the ope give me my two year warning and see that the siege will take 3 years.

    Option 1: Carry on the siege get excommed and then make sure the pope has a convienient accident (some ally he is anyway!!!!)
    Option 2: Abandon the siege and let the spanish take whats left of the argonese defend the border and try once more to wipe out France.

    Not sure yet, but this war with the argonese sure did wipe out most of my Alliances.

    Just one question how do you build Longbowmen? im certain i have created the buildings i need acording to the printed pull out poster tech tree that came with the game, this is with M:TW and VI vanilla early.

  4. #4

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    Quote Originally Posted by CrowleyHammer View Post
    Just one question how do you build Longbowmen? im certain i have created the buildings i need acording to the printed pull out poster tech tree that came with the game, this is with M:TW and VI vanilla early.
    Longbows are available from the High era (1205 onwards).

    “The majestic equality of the laws prohibits the rich and the poor alike from sleeping under bridges, begging in the streets and stealing bread.” - Anatole France

    "The law is like a spider’s web. The small are caught, and the great tear it up.” - Anacharsis

  5. #5

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    oh nuts, well..thats been a complete waste of my time then lol, and that makes my loss against the French even more devastating..sigh.

  6. #6

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    You should remember that when you receive a papal warning, it is not so much an immediate order to stop your aggression so much as a casual notice of, "I will look the other way for two years, just make sure you are done by then!".

    Simple enough! You could have taken the Pyrenees in two years!

    A cornered faction with a large army simply cannot be trusted.
    If you want to spare the life of an enemy, make sure you have him besieged in his last province with <300 men, and then retreat away.
    Otherwise your heirs shall inherit the Hundred Years War.

    Also, there is one thing which held me back for a very long time in RTW and MTW;
    Being afraid to lose provinces to siege.

    Surely, it is different in RTW, but in this game having a province besieged is damaging, but it sometimes is crucial to a better success.
    If leaving one province unprotected whilst you send an army deep into the heart of the enemy land means that it will be besieged on the next turn, it is well worth the victory.
    This may not be problematic for you, but I know that I still despise seeing someone else colour my lands!

    Simply create good fortifications, garrison them weakly, and try always to have one army available to all provinces.
    For example, in the event of war with the Romans, you could fend them off decisively with one army in flanders, because that province has such fine access to others.

    Of course, this is only a strategy for Europe. Naval steps should be taken to ensure that the homeland is never touched.

    Hmmm! I should get back to my Portuguese game!
    You should try your hand at that, Crowley, the Byzantines control everything east of Venice excepting the far north, and they have also taken a great slew of land which borders on the baltic sea. (Prussia, Pomerania, Lithuania).
    Worst of all, they have a navy surrounding mine, armies ready to strike anywhere, and when I recently retreated from an italian province, they took it 'from my faction' and now we are at war.

    I wish I could convince the computer that I did not want the province! It is ok! I forgive the Eastern Emperor!

  7. #7

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    This is my current campaign. Hopefully some crusades, Mongols, Hungarians or others will soon be heading my way. But first I have to deal with the Byzantine.
    Last edited by caravel; 03-23-2009 at 02:01.
    “The majestic equality of the laws prohibits the rich and the poor alike from sleeping under bridges, begging in the streets and stealing bread.” - Anatole France

    "The law is like a spider’s web. The small are caught, and the great tear it up.” - Anacharsis

  8. #8

    Default Re: Sv: Report!

    Is that a mod of your own, Nagamasa?

    Or what mod is it that gives so many provinces in the east?

    You must also tell how one deals with both Egyptians and Byzantines at once, for I failed at that trial.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO