Large Simpsons Mafia Game- The Treehouse of Horror [Concluded]

[Khazaar]

So Reenk I presume that you withdrew your suspicion because you found out that your character from the simpsons is a total fool and that you cannot trust his judement? Otherwise I can´t understand the withdrawal...

[LittleGrizzly]

Im going to ask one last time then if i dont have a satisfactory answer i will vote for you...

Reenk let us see your detective result on boudica...

[Reenk Roink]

I am not telling them how to asses the situation Reenk, I just think it's bad that the town is willing to follow you anywhere, like Lemmings, even off the cliffside. This is my personal opinion, and I'll stick to it. I'm not allowed to stick to my personal opinion or voice it? I did not demand the town follow my word in anyway shape or form, unlike you.

I posted that at the second, and it was supposed to be more satirical - if you ever do actually answer a question, you put them down and say how incompetent they are, how right you are, and how their conclusion drawn from what they believe are inferior to yours.

Again, I assessed the situation as I saw it, and gave my opinion - whether anyone follows it is up to them, whether they wish to believe it is up to them - I will not be making decisions for the town as if I was the town.

You seem to be accusing me of what you yourself are doing. Show me where I demanded the town to follow my reveal. I asked them. If you consider some of my asking as a demand, then I can consider this statement of yours as a demand: "We need to work as a team but asses as individuals."

So if I defend myself, and rebut suspicions and non beliefs about my detective status, I am "put[ting] them down and say how incompetent they are, how right you are, and how their conclusion drawn from what they believe are inferior to yours"

But I also don't respond to questions.

But when you do the same it's nice and just 'opinion'. You're "being objective of it." unlike the lemming town who follows me the one who doesn't answer questions so his "mightiness" is preserved but you are certainly not guilty of anything you apply to me.

After all, you are supposed to have your opinion, which is not allowed to be challenged?

Calling the town "lemmings" and calling me "mighty" caustically are examples of me putting people down eh and how right I am eh?

[Reenk Roink]

So Reenk I presume that you withdrew your suspicion because you found out that your character from the simpsons is a total fool and that you cannot trust his judement? Otherwise I can´t understand the withdrawal...

Yes, I changed my vote myself, because I cannot be sure of my result. Yeah, it basically dooms me.

P.S I am not Wiggim, but I read up on my character and he can be incompetent.

[LittleGrizzly]

okay...

Vote Reenk Roink

Until he shares his detective result...

[White_eyes:D]

Im going to ask one last time then if i dont have a satisfactory answer i will vote for you...

Reenk let us see your detective result on boudica...

He won't.... I saw this Midgard 1...It's how the Reenkster works as Mafia/SK...

Step 1: Reenk kicks up some weird fake detective reveal (or a weird version of it)....
Step 2: He gets Lynch or fools and confuses town with it, so they all jump off a cliff and die
Step 3: He then hopes for the best and well try and confuse us for the rest of the game, without really ever telling us and giving us only cryptic answers......

Talk about slim choices.....

[Sasaki Kojiro]

What's the reason for voting reenk?

[Reenk Roink]

What weird me out is how GH is right in the thick of this development, but has refused to put a vote either way....

[White_eyes:D]

Do I detect, sarcasm Sasaki?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

No...I would say, lynch GH.

[LittleGrizzly]

What's the reason for voting reenk?

I asked 3 times for his detective results and on the last time i said i would vote for him if he didn't provide it...

He could have even given some excuse off why he couldn't and i may have gone along with that, but he didn't even acknowledge my requests...

[White_eyes:D]

No...I would say, lynch GH.

uggh.....Reenk messed himself up too much to undo the damage.... but your right....GH is acting VERY indecisive, for a person who suspected Reenk right away....Unvote:Reenk Vote:GH

[Sasaki Kojiro]

What's the reason for voting reenk?

I asked 3 times for his detective results and on the last time i said i would vote for him if he didn't provide it...

He could have even given some excuse off why he couldn't and i may have gone along with that, but he didn't even acknowledge my requests...

He said he got a guilty on boudica

Here's the thing: it's possible that reenk is a "reverse cop" i.e. he gets guilty results on innocents and innocent results on mafia. So, once you know that, he's as useful as a regular cop. Pizza sort of hints at that with his post above, if he assigned a role like that he'd have known this would happen. There are many other possibilities: reenk made it up in the first place, reenk get's guilty results on everyone, etc, etc, but that isn't a reason to lynch him.

[Reenk Roink]

What's the reason for voting reenk?

I asked 3 times for his detective results and on the last time i said i would vote for him if he didn't provide it...

He could have even given some excuse off why he couldn't and i may have gone along with that, but he didn't even acknowledge my requests...

I told you here that I won't tell you.

So yes, I did acknowledge you request, I can't tell you due to my benefactor.

[White_eyes:D]

Reenk would have lived thur this round (if he had stuck to the boudica lynch)....I don't understand why he would throw himself to the wolves...

[LittleGrizzly]

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showp...&postcount=296

I investigated her and she was guilty.

Yes he said he got a guilty on Boudica

[LittleGrizzly]

My mistake Reenk

Unvote Reenk

[Reenk Roink]

Reenk would have lived thur this round (if he had stuck to the boudica lynch)....I don't understand why he would throw himself to the wolves...

Maybe I am a Joker king of Jokers...

[taka]

i want reenk to live

unvote (if i voted)
vote:Boudica

[Reenk Roink]

My mistake Reenk

Unvote Reenk

It was my bad, I tried to respond to every critique of my reveal, because I really am the detective as I understand it. However, that little (somewhat unpleasent) sidetrack with YLC jumbled things.

White eyes, I unvoted boudica because I don't want to lynch an innocent. I never wanted to also die, but hey... not that unexpected. Got kind of a useless role so it's no big deal.

[A Very Super Market]

Perhaps, as Wiggum, Reenk gets the opposite of their real alignment?

[Olavi]

Propably we are not lyching the right person after succesfull 1st round lynch.
So, I abstain.

[LittleGrizzly]

he's not wiggum... and its a funky thought but i would somehow doubt it...

Reenk could be lou or the other copper... makes sense as he discovered his character was stupid through the wiggum link where lou and the other cooper are mentioned.... of course he also could have searched for his charater after that...

[Reenk Roink]

Last question: Did some of you get the message "unless you get recruited" after your role description?

I did, and I'm not going to hide the fact that some of the things I've done was because of this. Normally I would love to be recruited into Mafia, but with my (apparent) detective role it would be serious if I was converted.

I'll leave you with that.

[Thermal]

i want reenk to live

unvote (if i voted)
vote:Boudica

MY LORD IS ANGRY!

You want reenk to live, fine, but WHY Boudica Instead, and no reasoning?

unvote
vote: Taka

Also I believe men carrying Hankerchiefs spread the word of the devil

*points at GH

[Sasaki Kojiro]

boudica: 7 (captain blackadder, lord winter,el diablo,ducky,khazaar,shlin,taka)
reenk roink: 5 (jolt, avsm,diana,boudica,YLC)

yoyo: 2 (glenn,tristan)
blackadder: 1 (GH)
White_eyes: 1 (reenk)
psycho: 1 (yoyo)
GH: 1 (White_eyes)
Warman: 1 (beefy)
avsm: 1 (khaan)
taka: 1 (thermal)


Depending on how much time is left in the day I'd advocate lynching GH over either of these two. But boudica would be better than reenk--a reverse detective can still get a guilty on a godfather type.

[A Very Super Market]

Hee, hee fabrication!

[LittleGrizzly]

Last question: Did some of you get the message "unless you get recruited" after your role description?

very honest of you, i had the same line in my pm...

[Thermal]

Last question: Did some of you get the message "unless you get recruited" after your role description?

very honest of you, i had the same line in my pm...

I did, if God abandons me I believe I will succumb to devilish acts of killing.

[LittleGrizzly]

I have decided to go with Reenks detective result, if it turns out wrong we now not to trust reenks detective results for the rest of the game...

If it turns out right we have a proven detective...

Unvote
Vote Boudica