The Council of Villains- Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Splitpersonality]

Did I not advise the arbiter before? >_>

Though it seems odd he'd be immune to night kills...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Might as well take things public since most of you know already.

Sasaki Kojiro- Ganondorf (unknown)
Askthepizzaguy- Bowser (asleep)
Shinseikhaan- Sephiroth (too busy not killing navarro)
Olavi- Mewtwo (blocked?)
Khazaar- Eggman (investigating?)
navarro951- Arbiter (looks like a prime suspect)
Ichigo- Vaati (second prime suspect unless cleared by Khazaar)
Yaropolk- Meta-Ridley (blocking?)
Beefy187- Black Knight (busy defending)

Investigate: Ichigo
Defend: Khazaar
Block: Olavi

This is the suspect list, and this is what happened last night.


My guess is Ichigo or Navarro. The writeup explicitly says Navarro is on our side, but that was his own words, I'm not sure I trust them. I also don't trust Vaati. But who am I overlooking? Olavi should have been blocked but there was nothing in the writeup about it.

I'd consider Sasaki but I supposedly have assurances that he's on our side. I'll recheck the revived people to see if they didn't kill on that certain night they were dead.

I'd like to say though, navarro never mentioned anything involving any abilities. That means, in my view, just like Kefka... he's hiding something. Like being a traitor.


Vote: navarro951

-Bowser

[seireikhaan]

I must insist upon lynching Sasaki.

1) Never investigated. Not once.

2) We cannot take any of these villain names for face value, in my opinion. We've already seen Luigi was disguised as a villain.

3) Looking back at his behavior, its been quite... how should I say... lackadaisical? Essentially giving the town minor reprimands for not proper discussion or for forming a pro-town group, yet never really bothering to actually after the debate. Or else just simply tossing jokes. Sasaki's most recent games as a scum have seen him taking a more proactive role, and I have the gut feeling that he took a change of pace to try and keep under the radar.

And lastly, the most suspicious thing of all...

Well I'm generally in favor of keeping khaan alive.

Vote:Shlin

This after telling us how pizza was being mind controlled/mafia and that I was being his lackey. Plus, he of all people should know I'm a terrible townsperson(heck, look at my success rates in this game). I'm not sure why on earth he would want me to be kept alive....

[Diana Abnoba]

I'm dead, that's a bummer.

You big meanies, picking on a kid... Ohh what big villains you are.


Well carry on villains (town) an win, and avenge my death, dad.


Good work and many thanks to the Koopa Troops.

[Beefy187]

I would be voting Navarro, but a quick comment.

Wasn't most of the kills done by the true hero form?

Like if Arbiter was the hero, wouldn't he be killing as the hero inside him instead of Arbiter?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I must insist upon lynching Sasaki.

1) Never investigated. Not once.

2) We cannot take any of these villain names for face value, in my opinion. We've already seen Luigi was disguised as a villain.

3) Looking back at his behavior, its been quite... how should I say... lackadaisical? Essentially giving the town minor reprimands for not proper discussion or for forming a pro-town group, yet never really bothering to actually after the debate. Or else just simply tossing jokes. Sasaki's most recent games as a villain have seen him taking a more proactive role, and I have the gut feeling that he took a change of pace to try and keep under the radar.

And lastly, the most suspicious thing of all...

This after telling us how pizza was being mind controlled/mafia and that I was being his lackey. Plus, he of all people should know I'm a terrible townsperson(heck, look at my success rates in this game). I'm not sure why on earth he would want me to be kept alive....

My role Pm indicates Sasaki is basically a mason. It says, point blank, there is zero chance that he or Eggman are traitors to the council.

If you must, I'll block him and see what happens, and defend the blocker. No need to waste a kill on a supposedly confirmed villain.

ROAR!

[seireikhaan]

My role Pm indicates Sasaki is basically a mason. It says, point blank, there is zero chance that he or Eggman are traitors to the council.

If you must, I'll block him and see what happens, and defend the blocker. No need to waste a kill on a supposedly confirmed villain.

ROAR!

Why did your Bowser PM tell you about Ganandorf?
edit: And if he's a Mason, what's he been up to this whole game?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I would be voting Navarro, but a quick comment.

Wasn't most of the kills done by the true hero form?

Like if Arbiter was the hero, wouldn't he be killing as the hero inside him instead of Arbiter?

Kefka killed, as himself.

Kirby's kills included abilities that his victims had (stolen powers).

The plumber was a mario-related character.

Dimentio was Dimentio and killed as Dimentio would have.

Frankly, all the evidence points towards the Arbiter who NEVER told me he was indestructible.

Vote for Navarro?


ROAR

[Splitpersonality]

I've said it before.

In halo 3 the arbiter is good.

The arbiter is not one person, but rather a title

It signifies something to do with the leader of the Elites from the halo universe, they are sort of like suicide bombers and they are remembered and honored like samurai.

THE HALO 3 ARBITER, WAS A GOOD GUY, OR AT THE VERY LEAST A ROGUE HERO.

Hence, voting navarro will save trouble either way.

Also, kirby didn't absorb people, did he?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Why did your Bowser PM tell you about Ganandorf?
edit: And if he's a Mason, what's he been up to this whole game?

Primarily? opposing me and being a pain in my big green scaly butt. But lately he's been more cooperative. He mentioned a lousy ability that made my eyebrows raise, but, the role PM is clear.

My role PM told me the two top members of the council were trustworthy veteran villains, basically. In so many words. I just needed to find out who they were.


Edit: Yes, Kirby absorbed the dead and stole their abilities. That's why he was able to kill "as a hedgehog".

[Askthepizzaguy]

Oh, my bad... we investigated Khaan last night, not Ichigo.

He should be clean, I'm sure.

Roar

[seireikhaan]

mmmm....

Unvote: Sasaki
Vote: Navarro

I still want to kill Sasaki. However, since apparently Navarro cannot be killed by night...

[navarro951]

I dont have any abilities yet so what do you want me to tell you?

I can fly, i have a nice shiny sword aaaand, Im leading a revolution against the covenant their happy? lol

Vote: Abstain

[seireikhaan]

I dont have any abilities yet so what do you want me to tell you?

Well that's just patently false. If you had no abilities, you should not survive kill attempts.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Recap, so people aren't scratching their heads:

1. Killer of Bowser Jr. used fists, energy blasts, and a blade. Arbiter uses those weapons
2. "Later that night" Sephiroth fought The Arbiter. That means the Arbiter could have killed. In fact, it explains why Eggman would not have seen the Arbiter murder anyone, because it was at different times.
3. Navarro claimed no pro-town abilities nor any others. He was found to have abilities. That means... he's lying by omission at the very least. Sephiroth should have been able to kill him if he were a normal townie. he's not a normal townie.
4. All our other pro-villain roles are accounted for. I don't buy that he's had a pro-town ability all this time and didn't tell us.

That tells me one thing: Navarro is the remaining traitor. And if he was the one who killed my son, I promise him this: A brutal, agonizing death.

-Bowser

[Diana Abnoba]

And I think you killed me last night, you puny loser, or should I say "hero".

[Beefy187]

Vote Navarro

[Sasaki Kojiro]

vote:navarro

khaan, I generally don't like townie groups as they aren't as much fun. I made up that stuff about mind control for the heck of it, and because it's not a good idea for masons to be real buddy buddy. A vig role should generally be left alive, I voted you for other reasons.

Didn't I ask if the arbiter was a good guy sometimes a couple rounds ago?

[Askthepizzaguy]

vote:navarro

khaan, I generally don't like townie groups as they aren't as much fun. I made up that stuff about mind control for the heck of it, and because it's not a good idea for masons to be real buddy buddy. A vig role should generally be left alive, I voted you for other reasons.

Didn't I ask if the arbiter was a good guy sometimes a couple rounds ago?

If you're right, you were ahead of the curve yet again.

They should have given you the Bowser role so I could just sit back and slack off for once. I admit it's pretty fun but I just did this in the Settlement game with far worse results.

Roar.

[Csargo]

Vote:navarro

I'm innocent.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Okay. Here's my theory:

The entire game is actually a big practical joke on me for all the times I tried to be a supertownie. Everyone is anti-pizzaguy aligned and you're all against me and laughing it up and having a good time. There is no actual way to solve the case, no one has a role except for me. And, for good measure, you've infiltrated my brain with nano-robots and are reading my mind as we speak, stealing all my secrets and selling them off to the dreaded Commie-Nazis who are also working for Al-Qaeda. And you're also causing me to become so paranoid that I come up with this theory, knowing full well I would realize I was being paranoid and probably dismiss those feelings, thinking I would fall for the WIFOM but it won't work I tells ya! I am on to you! The jig is up! You might as well just admit it! You can't fool me I'm un-foolable.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Roar I am Bowser.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And I am COMPLETELY INSANE!!!

Roar.

[Beefy187]

Okay. Here's my theory:

The entire game is actually a big practical joke on me for all the times I tried to be a supertownie. Everyone is anti-pizzaguy aligned and you're all against me and laughing it up and having a good time. There is no actual way to solve the case, no one has a role except for me. And, for good measure, you've infiltrated my brain with nano-robots and are reading my mind as we speak, stealing all my secrets and selling them off to the dreaded Commie-Nazis who are also working for Al-Qaeda. And you're also causing me to become so paranoid that I come up with this theory, knowing full well I would realize I was being paranoid and probably dismiss those feelings, thinking I would fall for the WIFOM but it won't work I tells ya! I am on to you! The jig is up! You might as well just admit it! You can't fool me I'm un-foolable.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Roar I am Bowser.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And I am COMPLETELY INSANE!!!

Roar.

You've seen "The Trueman show" bit too many times.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Your almost there though

[Askthepizzaguy]

Your almost there though

ORLY?

Do tell.

-Bowser.

[Csargo]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I am here to annoy you. Also, I hate multiple spoilers.

[navarro951]

i suppose my own defense dont matter now as everyone's mind seems to be made.

[Diana Abnoba]

Okay. Here's my theory:

The entire game is actually a big practical joke on me for all the times I tried to be a supertownie. Everyone is anti-pizzaguy aligned and you're all against me and laughing it up and having a good time. There is no actual way to solve the case, no one has a role except for me. And, for good measure, you've infiltrated my brain with nano-robots and are reading my mind as we speak, stealing all my secrets and selling them off to the dreaded Commie-Nazis who are also working for Al-Qaeda. And you're also causing me to become so paranoid that I come up with this theory, knowing full well I would realize I was being paranoid and probably dismiss those feelings, thinking I would fall for the WIFOM but it won't work I tells ya! I am on to you! The jig is up! You might as well just admit it! You can't fool me I'm un-foolable.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Roar I am Bowser.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And I am COMPLETELY INSANE!!!

Roar.

Okay honey, it will be okay. Did you forget you medicine again?

[Beefy187]

i suppose my own defense dont matter now as everyone's mind seems to be made.

Say it anyway just to make sure we aren't on the completely wrong track

[Khazaar]

I investigated our esteemed Viligrante, and he´s a pissed Villlain. Especcially after the last fight. Another thing, every player has some sort of ability. So everyone who doesn´t claim one is immediately suspicious.

[Askthepizzaguy]

ROOOOAAAARRRRRR!!!!

WELL IF YOU'RE A VILLAIN, TELL US YOUR DEFENSE, DON'T JUST SIT THERE LIKE A FAT LAZY PLUMBER!!! WHY DID YOU NOT COME FORWARD WITH YOUR ABILITY BEFORE, AND WHY DON'T YOU TELL US NOW???

Sincerely,

Bowser "Muffin" Koopa




ROOOOAAAARRRRRR!!!!

Anyone else with an ability tells us NOW, or I will personally rip off your head and feed it to a Cheep Cheep!!!

[navarro951]

After asking, it appears I have a 50% defense from being murdered in the night. Not sure how that works, but ya.