Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

[Quintus.JC]

So the killers were bold enough to kill the Pevers, most of whom were in the spotlight, and would probably be lynched and killed off soon.

The killers can't be newbies, I just don't think they would kill people who are must likely to get the attention and help other people to hide themselves.
FoS: The people who publicly made threats to the Pevers.

[woad&fangs]

So the killers were bold enough to kill the Pevers, most of whom were in the spotlight, and would probably be lynched and killed off soon.

However, killing off the pevers gives the town little to analyze. It was a sound strategy by the mafioso.

[El Diablo]

Vote YLC
Challange YLC

First time fight for me....

...sharpening my katana as we speak.....

[Quintus.JC]

However, killing off the pevers gives the town little to analyze. It was a sound strategy by the mafioso.

True, but my thoughts is that most of them were threatened to be WoGed and lynched, so killing them seemed a waste of kills for the mafia team.

Also both Geishas are killed now, it appears both are killed by samurai and not ninja. It also seems odd and unlikely that two of the same powered role were killed off so early, maybe the traitor can investigate? Or maybe it's someone that Greg had interracted with outside the thread.

[woad&fangs]

True, but my thoughts is that most of them were threatened to be WoGed and lynched, so killing them seemed a waste of kills for the mafia team.

Also both Geishas are killed now, it appears both are killed by samurai and not ninja. It also seems odd and unlikely that two of the same powered role were killed off so early, maybe the traitor can investigate? Or maybe it's someone that Greg had interracted with outside the thread.

Considering that there are supposed to be two samurai but there has been only one samurai kill each night, I think it is very likely that one or both of the samurai can investigate.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Considering that there are supposed to be two samurai but there has been only one samurai kill each night, I think it is very likely that one or both of the samurai can investigate.

Olavi may have been one of them...the beginning of his kill sounds a lot like the beginning of Gregoshi's (returning from some night action).

We have "hour of the rat" and "hour of the ox" and rabbit as well though it's not clear what these mean.

[Chimpyang]

AFAIK

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_clock

[Chimpyang]

My take is :

Ninjas kill during midnight - Rat hour, traitors kill before dawn but after midnight - so if a traitor is killed during midnight, he wont get a chance to do his night action?

Challenge : Louis VI the Fat
Vote : Louis VI the Fat

[CountArach]

Vote: shlin28

My reasoning will follow when I put it all together. I'm pretty damn sure about this one though.

EDIT: Also, YLC could you send me your battle rating (As well as those of you who haven't sent it)?

[TinCow]

I don't have time for a full kill analysis at the moment, but one thing does jump out at me: three of the deaths were pevers. I have a hunch that if two killers overlapped on a kill, we would see them both in the write-up; thus I assume there were no overlaps. The odds of multiple mafia groups deciding independently to attack the pevers and then not overlapping on any kills seem low. Since the ninjas get 3 kills per night, this indicates to me that all three of the pever killers were ninjas. This may help properly sort the kills from the previous nights into the correct categories.

[seireikhaan]

Everyone should vote for TinCow.

[TinCow]

Everyone should vote for TinCow.

Care to explain why?

[ULC]

I agree with Khaan, TC is tripping my mafia sense hard.

Challenge: TinCow
Vote: TinCow

Your just oh so helpful...

[Husar]

I don't have time for a full kill analysis at the moment, but one thing does jump out at me: three of the deaths were pevers.

Oh really? It's good that you noticed.
I'd find it quite fitting that you first complained about the pevers, then killed them, perhaps you even coordinated it somehow, then said something intelligent about how there is no overlapping.
For now I'll

Vote: TinCow

[White_eyes:D]

Vote YLC
Challenge YLC I owe you for joining that weird 'pever cult'

[ULC]

Vote YLC
Challenge YLC I owe you for joining that weird 'pever cult'

*sighs* Foolish one, I am Sanada Yukimura. I am the Crimson Demon of War!

[woad&fangs]

So the killers were bold enough to kill the Pevers, most of whom were in the spotlight, and would probably be lynched and killed off soon.

The killers can't be newbies, I just don't think they would kill people who are must likely to get the attention and help other people to hide themselves.
FoS: The people who publicly made threats to the Pevers.

red coloring is mine.

FoS: All the newbies

[White_eyes:D]

Unvote:woad&fangs Vote:Quintus I warn you guys.....we have no way of telling if BQ is telling the truth..... and the mafia will likely drop to two kills tonight....(In Godfather three....me and beefy agreed it was a good idea early on) If BQ survives tonight....we need to lynch him....or otherwise he might just have been protecting GH....

[Prince Cobra]

Unvote:woad&fangs Vote:Quintus I warn you guys.....we have no way of telling if BQ is telling the truth..... and the mafia will likely drop to two kills tonight....(In Godfather three....me and beefy agreed it was a good idea early on) If BQ survives tonight....we need to lynch him....or otherwise he might just have been protecting GH....

If he is right about the Quintius name there is high chance of telling the truth, I think.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Vote: Quintus

Time will tell if Banquo has been leading us in the right direction or not.

thanks for saving my behind though.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Oh, and Challenge: Beskar.

[Banquo's Ghost]

Oh, and Challenge: Beskar.

Why would you do that?

If you believe me, both Beskar and you are innocent. To challenge him means that there is a chance you will duel, and we will lose another loyal samurai for no reason.

Pride can be satisfied after we find the traitors.

[Dutch_guy]

Oh, and Challenge: Beskar.

So you're doing this even after Banquo named him as an innocent ?

[atheotes]

If he is right about the Quintius name there is high chance of telling the truth, I think.

Yes... the name claim has given us the possibility of more evidence... if Quintus hadnt claimed a different name we might be unsure about BG's claim even after the lynch writeup...

[White_eyes:D]

Yes... the name claim has given us the possibility of more evidence... if Quintus hadnt claimed a different name we might be unsure about BG's claim even after the lynch writeup...

*note to self....atheotes is trying VERY hard to drum up BG's claim*