Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

[ULC]

Read few paragraphs down. It says something about "10 legendary ninjas"

Plus I wasn't going to vote for you, as I thought the names was spilled out by name generators and you getting Sanada Yukimura was a pure coincidents

Then if I am mafia, which would make me the ninja "godfather", just look for the names of those ten to crop up in the duels. Which would be a bad thing to do - or are you implying I am stupid?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Toldja.

[ULC]

Toldja.

[Beskar]

The correct tally list and in the right order (might double check, but it should be correct).

I am putting a small ban on other people doing their own tallies, as there were so many errors, missed votes, missed challenges and in the wrong order, it was amazingly bad.


Fatality: [The one who is going to get lynched.]

shlin28 7 CountArach, LittleGrizzly,Beskar,GeneralHankerchief, YLC, Sasaki Kojiro, Seamus Fermanagh

YLC 4 El Diablo, White eyes, Reenk Roink, Ichigo

TinCow 2 Chimpyang, Husar
Stephen Asen 2 ajaxfetish, woad&fangs
Taka 2 Seamus Fermanagh, Captain Blackadder

Haudegen 1 Wishazu
LittleGrizzly 1 Rhyfelwyr


Abstain 2 Caius, taka



Mortal Kombat: [Duels.]

GeneralHankerchief Vs Rhyfelwyr
Stephen Asen Vs ajaxfetish
El Diablo Vs YLC
YLC Vs TinCow
Chimpyang Vs Louis VI the Fat
White_eyes:D Vs YLC
Beefy182 Vs GeneralHankerchief


The Usual Suspects: [A section for those who keep cropping up from previous rounds.]

shlin28 A
Stephen Asen C
Beskar C
Sasaki Kojiro D
YLC D
Haudegen D
LittleGrizzly D

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

The rank system for the Usual Suspects:
Rank S Special Recommend Lynch ASAP.
Rank A Strong High Possibility Mafia-role.
Rank B Popular Popular on the list.
Rank C Mild Common name on the list.
Rank D Weak Just cropped up once or twice.
Rank E Not Listed Not worth listing.

Ranks are decided upon position on the table and how many weeks. This is a trial of last two weeks and current scoring.

[Beefy187]

Really now

Beefy quality. Get one details right and get three wrong

Then if I am mafia, which would make me the ninja "godfather", just look for the names of those ten to crop up in the duels. Which would be a bad thing to do - or are you implying I am stupid?

Not at all. I just thought I might say what I thought.

[ULC]

The correct tally list and in the right order (might double check, but it should be correct):


Fatality:

YLC 5 El Diablo, White eyes, Reenk Roink, LittleGrizzly, Ichigo

TinCow 4 Sasaki, YLC, Chimpyang, Husar

Stephen Asen 3 ajaxfetish, woad&fangs, Beskar

Haudegen 1 Wishazu
LittleGrizzly 1 Rhyfelwyr
Beefy187 1 GeneralHankerchief

Abstain 1 Caius, taka



Mortal Kombat:

GeneralHankerchief Vs Rhyfelwyr
Stephen Asen Vs ajaxfetish
El Diablo Vs YLC
YLC Vs TinCow
Chimpyang Vs Louis VI the Fat
White_eyes:D Vs YLC
Beefy182 Vs GeneralHankerchief

Hmmm...LG supposedly Unvoted me before running off

Nice, well, whatever, I am sure the mafia want me dead, so let it be so. I was only a veteran Samurai with a ridiculously high battle rating, essentially a low chance daykill vigilante.

I am glad I was able to so much to help the town, and get it repaid - oh, before I die, I had privately asked Andres for a suicide and replacement. I wish I had done it, because then Sanada Yukimura would have lived a tad longer

[CountArach]

Vote: shlin28

My reasoning will follow when I put it all together. I'm pretty damn sure about this one though.

EDIT: Also, YLC could you send me your battle rating (As well as those of you who haven't sent it)?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

YLC does not seem like a good lynch to me.

[Beskar]

I will to keep the lists up to date on each page, until the list gets replaced on the other page, is when I copy and paste the old one there then make the amendments for that page.

As for the unvote, I would prefer it if people stuck to the rules on it, it makes it easier to organise. Probably why Andres requested it that way too.

As for CountArach, feel free to list it. My apologises, I only change when I think it is suitable to do it.

[ULC]

YLC does not seem like a good lynch to me.

Why not? I mean, there is such astounding reasoning to do so! Look at the irrefutable logic! LOOK AT IT!!!

[Seamus Fermanagh]

YLC, your long posts against Tincow seem well thought out and have a mafia-hunter quality to them. It should be noted, however, that none of the points raised are "smoking gun" caliber.

However, Ichigo is correct as to the mafia-esque tone of your duel post.


For the moment, I will Vote: taka


Come out and play taka, I don't like you lurking along.

[Captain Blackadder]

VOTE TAKA

Gut instinct

[ULC]

YLC, your long posts against Tincow seem well thought out and have a mafia-hunter quality to them. It should be noted, however, that none of the points raised are "smoking gun" caliber.

However, Ichigo is correct as to the mafia-esque tone of your duel post.


For the moment, I will Vote: taka


Come out and play taka, I don't like you lurking along.

Double post or Duel post (as in challenge?) - or just point out which post?

[LittleGrizzly]

I am putting a small ban on other people doing their own tallies

I just updated someone else's and put in the challenges YLC mentioned.... I am perfect and beyond reproach... ask my loyal samurai!

So errm.. there was some voting problem ?

Unvote YLC
Vote Shlin28

Our Lord seems convinced and thus so am I, If the warriors are uncooperative with your requests name them and shall remove thier heads!

Updated tally (wish me luck)

Fatality:

YLC 4 El Diablo, White eyes, Reenk Roink, Ichigo

TinCow 4 Sasaki, YLC, Chimpyang, Husar

Stephen Asen 3 ajaxfetish, woad&fangs, Beskar

Taka 2 CaptainBlackadder, Seamus

Shlin28: 2 LittleGrizzly, CountArach
Haudegen 1 Wishazu
LittleGrizzly 1 Rhyfelwyr
Beefy187 1 GeneralHankerchief

Abstain 2 Caius, taka



Mortal Kombat:

GeneralHankerchief Vs Rhyfelwyr
Stephen Asen Vs ajaxfetish
El Diablo Vs YLC
YLC Vs TinCow
Chimpyang Vs Louis VI the Fat
White_eyes:D Vs YLC
Beefy182 Vs GeneralHankerchief

[CountArach]

Why shlin probably isn't town and should be lynched

Got your attention? Brilliant.

The primary reason for shlin to be lynched rests on something you are all just simply going to have to trust me with - he lied about his duel ratings. I have reason to suspect that the level he sent me exceeded the maximum available score. No one else claimed anything at his level or above, including those who hinted at similar character backgrounds. So for that reason alone he should be lynched.

Further, shlin cast the deciding vote on Sigurd... whether this may point to something or not is largely irrelevant, but I don't think Sigurd was a good lynch at all in retrospect.

[Beskar]

Unvote: Stephen Asen
Vote: CountArach ((Edit: This was actually meant to be shlin28 based on CountArach's post, but I made a stupid blunder))


If you got any questions, inregards to the scale I am trying out, feel free to message, but in short, D at the moment = been listed in two lynch inquests. C= a popular and a shallow, or popular in two. I am testing around with the sensitivity.


p.s. You never responded to my PM CountArach, or wasn't you allowed?

[ULC]

Although I do agree that Sigurd was a terrible lynch choice, I don't think we will be able to lynch shlin this round - Sasaki, I, and one more person will have to change their vote.

And Beskar, are you alright in the head?

[GeneralHankerchief]

I'll give CA the benefit of the doubt... this time. I do have some questions about this line of logic, but I'll put them off until more is revealed.

Unvote: Beefy
Vote: shlin

[CountArach]

Unvote: Stephen Asen
Vote: CountArach


p.s. You never responded to my PM CountArach, or wasn't you allowed?
(to others, I asked if my duel rating was actually high or low, in a sense, I asked what the scale was like)

Lol... I am Lord Takeda Shingen... and any votes against me as discarded. I am confirmed pro-town... yet you want to lynch me?

I didn't answer anyone's question about the duel rating scale for the reason that I didn't want that information to get in the wrong hands. The fact you are fishing for that information means that you deserve HoS: Beskar. Also GH, what part of my line of logic don't you like?

[ULC]

Okay, scratch what I said earlier, I will follow up more closely with TC tomorrow.

Unvote: Tincow
Vote: Shlin28

One more please! Sasaki?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

unvote:TinCow,Vote:Shlin

Been fos'd, been hos'd...let's here you say yay now.

Hopefully ylc vs tincow duel comes up.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Unvote: taka

Vote: Shlin28

Hai, tono. Wakirimasen, keredomo hai.


Lurker List (dead and non-players dropped): Name postcount out of 912 -- notes


Haudegen 5 -- voted both d1 and d2, comments short and inquisitive, hard to assess
taka 5 -- 2 pre-play posts, abstained d1 and d3, voted for Asen d2, total word count contributed is 21, subtracting the 7 that were bolded votes that's 14 words. This is the I totally lurk so that nobody notices me and I don't get the chop approach. I loathe this as its hugely beneficial to mafiosi, even if taka san is not a ninja here.
Yoyoma1910 4 -- voted d1, not since
El Diablo 4 -- missed d1, voted d2 & d3 (with challenge)
Beaver 3 -- abstained d1, nothing since
Dutch_guy 3 -- no votes so far, possible WOG in waiting
Psychonaut 3 -- signup, voted shlin d1, abstained d2: VERY productive voting record for 3 posts
A Very Super Market 3 -- voted d1, not since
Jolt 3 -- abstained d1, nothing since
Crazed Rabbit 3 -- voted d1, not since
Banquo's Ghost 2 -- voted d1, not since, less active then usual in BR
Tristan de Castelreng 2
Peasant Phill 2 -- only post laments his being too late to vote both times
Xehh II 2
Wishazu 1 -- recent replacement, first post was a vote for Haudegen

Bolded names indicate dangerous lurker

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Holy @#$@%. Was there a hard deadline? Because that is awesome if so--had no idea.

[Beskar]

Lol... I am Lord Takeda Shingen... and any votes against me as discarded. I am confirmed pro-town... yet you want to lynch me?

I didn't answer anyone's question about the duel rating scale for the reason that I didn't want that information to get in the wrong hands. The fact you are fishing for that information means that you deserve HoS: Beskar. Also GH, what part of my line of logic don't you like?

It was a typo, I meant shlin28 to copy you, but for some reason, I typed your name by accident. After I edited the scoring, I looked down and thought "Who is that idiot who voted for CountArach... oh beepers!"

And it I told you the reason in my PM, it wasn't suspicious at all.

[LittleGrizzly]

If its a 5am GMT cut off then that would be some damn good timing...

Beskar don't go back and edit votes!

You have to make a new post and unvote if you accidently vote for someone wrong... or just in general don't edit a vote into a post...

[GeneralHankerchief]

CA, check your inbox in a bit. I'm doing about 4 things at once so it may take a minute.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Actually it's an extended day phase so we have plenty of time. Although andres's listed times make zero sense to me. I thought we had like 5 hours left when he closed voting yesterday, and now he says 36 hours but voting lasts till saturday???

[Beskar]

You have to make a new post and unvote if you accidently vote for someone wrong... or just in general don't edit a vote into a post...

No one replied and I thought I fixed it. Everytime I change my vote, I post saying unvote then vote. However, I just wrote the wrong name down when I meant another. >_> Its the 5am bug where you read "CountArach seems to have a good case" and accidently put his name down...

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Holy @#$@%. Was there a hard deadline? Because that is awesome if so--had no idea.

Random chance is amazing. I hadn't even read Arach's reasoning (hence the wakirimasen comment) while putting together my lurker list, but I had no better line of attack and he IS the only known innocent. So the timing just...happened.

GH: If he did lie about his duel score to CA, that was a dumb move. I think CA is making a legit judgement call based on this.

CA: The lynch of Sigurd was probably not the best, but using rounds 2-5 to take out lurkers (absent a better line of attack such as you provided or YLC attempted on Tincow) is not bad play. Known players who are lurking must be prodded or removed.

CA: I would also like to know which lurkers on my list supplied you with duel scores, and who did not. Might help us sort the wogs from those who should be pressured to join in.

Beskar: Please don't edit a vote, many hosts will wog you for it immediately.

[Beskar]

Beskar: Please don't edit a vote, many hosts will wog you for it immediately.

It was a blunder and trying to cover up my blunder, I did another one, apologies to everyone in the game and the host.

Let me stress, this is 100% legitimate intended vote in that particular post. I half-doozely just typed the person who brought the point up which made me want to change my vote, instead of the person they said. Yes, it was a silly stupid mistake.

I will edit back the other vote to the original and restate it here. Please be forgiving.

Unvote: CountArach
Vote: shlin28