CWC Banning

[Paolai]

Tomi,

Did you relaized that you banned a clan just for a screen shoot? Do you call it "full speed ahead!" bad bad, very bad imho. In this situation many other problems will come. Best of luck.


Sebra,

yes, when CA will fix these problems, I will be happy to join. Lets hope CA will fix MP, at least the desync controls, the possibility to have a log, and no probs with replays.

[Tomisama]

Tomi,

Did you relaized that you banned a clan just for a screen shoot? Do you call it "full speed ahead!" bad bad, very bad imho. In this situation many other problems will come. Best of luck.

No one has been banned...

http://clanwars3540.yuku.com/topic/911

[Paolai]

I assume you are saying that you never accused in CWC forum a clan to have a "dishonourable conduct" cause you watched a screen shoot?

And I assume that you are saying that you never wrote that on your forum:

So the entire Clan of "clan name" will be removed from this competition, and banned from further participation in any Empire Total War Clan Wars events.




I am sorry, I do not call it "full speed ahead". Just my opinion.

Do not joke with me Tomi, please, thank you.

[Tomisama]

I assume you are saying that you never accused in CWC forum a clan to have a "dishonourable conduct" cause you watched a screen shoot?

And I assume that you are saying that you never wrote that on your forum:

So the entire Clan of "clan name" will be removed from this competition, and banned from further participation in any Empire Total War Clan Wars events.




I am sorry, I do not call it "full speed ahead". Just my opinion.

Do not joke with me Tomi, please, thank you.

Initially I was very, very angry that this childishness was about to ruin a competition for hundreds of players (40 Teams x 6 players minimum each = 240).

There is no real doubt in my mind that this was a prime example of a modified game cheat.

It just can not be conclusively proved beyond a shadow of a doubt for all concerned, because there is no replay.

So we must give the benefit of that doubt to that player.

That is the way true justice works.

Why are you attacking me?

I am not perfect, but am doing my best…


Edit: btw the "Full Speed Ahead" clearly came after the reversal of the ban, and not before

[Paolai]

So we must give the benefit of that doubt to that player.

And we must give this benefit untill CA will not give us the opportunity to have no doubts at all. This is what I think and this is what I mean. You can have any proofs if a player cheated or not also if you have the replay. A good cheater sadly knows how to cheat, and you will never be sure if he really cheated or not imho.

I am not attacking you, I just reported an example why ETW is not ready at the moment for any kind of competition (Clan Wars, CWC, CWB...) I am sorry if I offended you in any way.