Asterix and the Gauls [Concluded]

[atheotes]

I was under the impression that investigations only yielded factional information, such as in rubicon. If it does that I believe we should REFRAIN from investigating, so we don't have a faction victory attempt again.

If they do more than that, then by all means do it.

investigation results just state the faction and if there was some activity (ex: there was some unusual activity)

p.s. i can quote a result i got from investigation... but dont want it to be used to forge results...even though the chances of something like that is very very low.

[Caius]

FoS: Caius, CountArach, splitpersonality.

Edit: additionally, it seems the protection group on Phog of War failed, and the vigilantes were allowed to kill him.

Then it was CA. Because I sent the mail, and I wrote you one hour after you sent the last PM.

[Chaotix]

It was splitpersonality, Caius. He's already admitted to not sending in the action. My results imply that both you and CA were there, though, because only one person was missing from the action.

[Beskar]

Unless Choatix is actually the Mafia and Splitpersonality is his partner or some one he convinced to send in result as he went on his killing spree.

Who would expect the leader of the townie group to be the true Mafia. He would know who gets protected, thus know who to kill and influence who to lynch.

[Chaotix]

Unless Choatix is actually the Mafia and Splitpersonality is his partner or some one he convinced to send in result as he went on his killing spree.

Who would expect the leader of the townie group to be the true Mafia. He would know who gets protected, thus know who to kill and influence who to lynch.

That is some tasty WIFOM indeed. If you guys find me suspicious, please show it with your votes. There is a role investigator in the game, so I can be cleared as a townie if you deem it's worth more than finding a potential mafioso.

[atheotes]

Unless Choatix is actually the Mafia and Splitpersonality is his partner or some one he convinced to send in result as he went on his killing spree.

Who would expect the leader of the townie group to be the true Mafia. He would know who gets protected, thus know who to kill and influence who to lynch.

One way to avoid that is have atleast one more person working with Chaotix to organize things... that when chaotix gets targeted we will have someone with knowledge of whats happening.

Also, we have to ensure that all active people are part of protection/kill groups - ensuring no kills from the active players. the inactive players can be lynched. if we have them in townie groups it will only result in more confusion when they dont act.

All the people who dont want to be part of Vigilante groups, please tell us why.

[Tratorix]

Well,this makes me feel a lot better about not being able to organize one of these groups the first night. Good luck guys, your gonna need it.

Also, QuintusJC status: Still alive, Still guilty.

[Iskander 3.1]

All the people who dont want to be part of Vigilante groups, please tell us why.

Good idea. I'd still like to know why Pever doesn't want to take part in kills...

[El Diablo]

I have not recieved a night action result.

Does this mean that our host did njot get mine?

[Beskar]

Also, we have to ensure that all active people are part of protection/kill groups - ensuring no kills from the active players. the inactive players can be lynched. if we have them in townie groups it will only result in more confusion when they dont act.

All the people who dont want to be part of Vigilante groups, please tell us why.

Your first point make sense, I will join vigilante kill groups if that is the case then. That I can accept.

However, you can kill innocents if you do it to just anyone, which makes it easier for the Mafia to win. Do you want to assist the Mafia in winning?

[atheotes]

Your first point make sense, I will join vigilante kill groups if that is the case then. That I can accept.

However, you can kill innocents if you do it to just anyone, which makes it easier for the Mafia to win. Do you want to assist the Mafia in winning?

for this strategy to work, we need all the players to be active. inactive players are a real hindrance. so we should have inactive players as targets... we might lose the odd player at the cost of finding the mafia
if the groups contain active players, the chances of the protection group failing without revealing mafia is very slim.

[johnhughthom]

All the people who dont want to be part of Vigilante groups, please tell us why.

Perhaps the fact it has been quite pathetic so far and caused more confusion than anything...

Just to be clear, I will take part but it seems shambolic so far compared to the devilishly well organised group I went up against in Rubicon. I would be happier if LG was in charge. No, I'm not sure of his innocence, then again I'm not sure of Chaotix'.

[Tratorix]

Perhaps the fact it has been quite pathetic so far and caused more confusion than anything...

Just to be clear, I will take part but it seems shambolic so far compared to the devilishly well organised group I went up against in Rubicon. I would be happier if LG was in charge. No, I'm not sure of his innocence, then again I'm not sure of Chaotix'.

You also have to remember the group in Rubicon was backed by two power town roles who could investigate, switch votes and convert townies into confirmed innocents. It's ridiculous to think just setting up conflicting Kill/ Protect groups would be just as effective. Hopefully it will help reveal some mafia, but not if people all drop out because of a few bumps in the road. Besides, it's not like you have anything better to do in the night phase... right?

[Beskar]

If you are desperate, make me. All I can be accused of is game negligence and paying attention to my mini-mafia games.

Though, you are all missing a big problem. What happens if the Mafia just complies? It will stalemate the game for good and the Mafia just win because people gave up.

[atheotes]

Perhaps the fact it has been quite pathetic so far and caused more confusion than anything...

Just to be clear, I will take part but it seems shambolic so far compared to the devilishly well organised group I went up against in Rubicon. I would be happier if LG was in charge. No, I'm not sure of his innocence, then again I'm not sure of Chaotix'.

i disagree - it was only in the end game in Rubicon (after the elimination of the Pompeians iirc) did it become well organized. Sasaki twice failed to give me night actions after getting my consent and let me go about my business as mafia. all the information was not out in the thread for everyone to know (no offense to Sasaki or anyone - the mafia lost because of the coordination )
it is just that it is difficult to organize such a large number of players including inactive ones. we did not get it right the first time we tried it....so what? the strategy won the game for the town in Rubicon and i do not see why it should not work.

[Caius]

It was splitpersonality, Caius. He's already admitted to not sending in the action. My results imply that both you and CA were there, though, because only one person was missing from the action.

Now that I see the new page... you are right. Sorry CA.