My exact pm from Igno states "one of them"

Yours, states "2 of them"

Igno however, is prone to typos and mistakes as we have all seen, and thus, this could be the reason.

But, 1 and 2 are totally different things. I seriously doubt even though Igno makes typos here and there, he could mess up a thing that TOTALLY affects the gameplay and outcome due to its implications that one of us is lying.

Hence, the suspicion. Do you need more explanation?

In the possibility that Igno did not make a mistake, one of us is certainly lying, and both of us thinks its the other.

Which is why, I would be suspicious, cause WIFOM and all I know I'm telling the truth (or at least whats presented to me) and would wonder why the other would seek to lie. It COULD be that your a townie who is trying to seek faction victory, but that would be silly and stupid when we could all cooperate easier for the united town victory like in Rubicon.

That is why, I am suspicious of you, but I am willing to forgo it at least temporarily due to its confusion and possible mistakes from host.