PC Mode
Org Mobile Site
Forum > Discussion > Backroom (Political) >
Thread: For what it's worth: cancer cure announced
Page 1 of 2 1 2 Last
Adrian II 23:06 06-29-2009
MELBOURNE: Specially designed 'minicells' successfully target and kill cancer cells – the new technology has the "potential to deliver drugs that were considered undeliverable," scientists say.

In mice seeded with human tumours, then treated with this new technique, the recovery rate was 100%. In the next few months, EnGeneIc will recruit 20 long-term cancer patients for a phase one safety trial at three Melbourne hospitals.

The study, by Jennifer MacDiarmid and Himanshu Brahmbhatt of EnGeneIC, a privately held Australian bioscience company founded in 2001, is the cover story of the July issue of Nature Biotechnology.

Source

Rejoice? Grain of salt? Booh?

Discuss.

Reply
Adrian II 23:11 06-29-2009
Originally Posted by Gelatinous Cube:
Wow. If true, this could be the best thing to happen in our generation. And that's no understatement.
Aye! But... where's the catch?

Reply
Proletariat 23:14 06-29-2009
Catch? What possible catch? This is cause for a celebratory smoke.



Reply
Adrian II 23:16 06-29-2009
Originally Posted by Proletariat:
Catch? What possible catch? This is cause for a celebratory smoke.

Lol!

Hold your Camels though, there must be a catch somewhere. This is far too good to be true.

Reply
Papewaio 23:16 06-29-2009
Economy Growing, Check.
Socceroos through to the World Cup, Check.
Another Australian Cancer Cure, Check.

The catch is we get to die of something else.

Reply
Adrian II 23:18 06-29-2009
Originally Posted by Papewaio:
Economy Growing, Check.
Socceroos through to the World Cup, Check.
Another Australian Cancer Cure, Check.

The catch is we get to die of something else.
I want to die in bed, and I don't mean in my sleep if I may be so blunt.

Reply
Papewaio 23:25 06-29-2009
I saw heaven in her eyes as my body left the mortal coil.

Petite and large death in one.

Reply
Hosakawa Tito 23:25 06-29-2009
Sounds promising. I hope this works in humans too, guess time will tell.

Originally Posted by :
I want to die in bed, and I don't mean in my sleep if I may be so blunt.
Heck, be adventurous. Have her tie you up in a chair while you call her dirty names and....oops, already been done.

Reply
Rhyfelwyr 23:29 06-29-2009
Shouldn't this be around the news a bit more if it is as big as it sounds?

Reply
Hooahguy 23:36 06-29-2009
maybe theres hope for my friends brother after all...


Reply
Louis VI the Fat 23:37 06-29-2009
*Laughs at all the silly folk who've given up smoking*



Reply
Samurai Waki 23:48 06-29-2009
So should I start packing up my supplies, and hide somewhere that is light all the time, to avoid the Zombie attacks, and be rescued by a handsome black man?

Reply
Xiahou 23:48 06-29-2009
Originally Posted by Hosakawa Tito:
Sounds promising. I hope this works in humans too, guess time will tell.
That's the catch of course. A treatment working on mice is far from a guarantee that it will work the same in humans.

It sounds promising- but let's see what happens in the human trials.

Reply
Lord Winter 23:53 06-29-2009
If it's just entering trails it may still be 5-10 years before major use.


The journal it was published in seems fairly prestigous so it looks like the science behind it is well supported. Still puzzled by the lack of media around it.

Reply
Lemur 23:57 06-29-2009
Originally Posted by Louis VI the Fat:
*Laughs at all the silly folk who've given up smoking*
Now I feel really, really stupid for quitting. Well, except for the fact that the taxes on ciggies have made them a deluxe luxury item anyway.

So I guess my budget can rejoice, even if my body didn't need the break. And it doesn't sound like they've got a cure for emphysema.

Reply
Alexander the Pretty Good 00:02 06-30-2009
If this works, I think I'm going to have to get in the black market for ciggies and sell to all you dependents. :D

Reply
Papewaio 00:05 06-30-2009
Well maybe adult stem cells derived from fat can cure that one.

Reply
Husar 00:49 06-30-2009
Hmm, at the end they say the big issue is safety, but personally I'd say why worry about that if I had terminal cancer anyway?

Reply
Sarmatian 01:00 06-30-2009
Oh my beautiful tobacco, have you missed me? I have missed you very very much...

If this turns out to be true, I'll start each day with a "Hail Australia and Australians".

Reply
Sarmatian 01:14 06-30-2009
Even with cancer taken out of the equation, cigarettes would still be a serious risk to your health.

They don't do anything good for you, that's for sure. Tax away the idiots (myself included) who buy them. Better to tax cigarettes than something actually useful...

Reply
woad&fangs 01:31 06-30-2009
Interesting. The "minicells" are just transports for treatments that have already been developed, but were too dangerous or unstable to deliver before. I think that the "catch" is going to be that the minicells will turn out to not be as stable as the researchers hope. However, the improved ability to transport that siRNA stuff will be a HUGE help in treating cancer patients.

So this is either awsome news or super extra awsome news. Either way, kudos to the Aussies

Reply
Sarmatian 01:47 06-30-2009
Originally Posted by Gelatinous Cube:
I paid seven dollars for a pack of Kools today.
Do you need a better incentive to quit smoking?

Reply
FactionHeir 02:00 06-30-2009
They also only used small doses of the transporter bacterium.

Problems that I can envision with it:
- Bacterium mutates
- Comes into contact with wild S. typhimurium resulting in some funky combinations, none of which would be pleasant
- High toxicity in larger doses, which would be required for humans, either from drug overdose or transporter leak, resulting in drug floating free in the body
- Targeting may be a bit off - results in hitting other fast growing cells or cells with that particular receptor
- Patient with auto immune disease
- Questionable how to get the bacterium out again once you pump someone up with it
- Bacterium gets infected by one of many virii, altering its function

Reply
LittleGrizzly 02:03 06-30-2009
I can smoke to that!

*quickly finishes rolling*

Reply
Fragony 02:05 06-30-2009
Years and years and yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaars of testing to avoid lawsuits, that would be the catch the risky aged won't benefit from it.

Reply
LittleGrizzly 02:53 06-30-2009
I think anyone over 40 still needs to put the cigerette out but as someone in thier twenties I can still look forward to years of smoking ahead...

Reply
KukriKhan 03:16 06-30-2009
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9Rumfb5kyU

"I smoke 'em. HE smokes 'em..."

If you ever saw TV ciggie ads (before they were banned), this is a hoot.

On-topic: God bless Australia and all her people. Carry on mates. Please. The maybe I can die of terminal happiness. :)

Reply
Adrian II 08:11 06-30-2009
Originally Posted by FactionHeir:
They also only used small doses of the transporter bacterium.

Problems that I can envision with it:
- Bacterium mutates
- Comes into contact with wild S. typhimurium resulting in some funky combinations, none of which would be pleasant
- High toxicity in larger doses, which would be required for humans, either from drug overdose or transporter leak, resulting in drug floating free in the body
- Targeting may be a bit off - results in hitting other fast growing cells or cells with that particular receptor
- Patient with auto immune disease
- Questionable how to get the bacterium out again once you pump someone up with it
- Bacterium gets infected by one of many virii, altering its function
On the upside, the result is said to be 100% in mice which they seeded with humane carcinoma. One hundred percent, now that is promising as animal trials go. Of course they didn't mention the size of N in this trial or the results of other trials that may have been less than perfect. And for all we know it make take another 25 years to fine-tune the targeting of the drug.

And blah blah, who are we to know anyway? I just hope this isn't some stupid hoax to begin with.

Reply
a completely inoffensive name 08:39 06-30-2009
On news aggregation sites like Digg and Reddit, there a cure for cancer story once a week. It's become some what of a running joke at this point. So forgive me if I am skeptical of this.

Reply
Beskar 08:46 06-30-2009
There are already cure for cancers, such as cutting it out, chemotherapy and radiotherapy.

Reply
Page 1 of 2 1 2 Last
Up
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO