Capo di Tutti Capi III [Concluded]

[LittleGrizzly]

Get the new guy!!



If this is his first mafia game he's probably a little lost... that doesn't mean he should get away with abstaining though!

[Splitpersonality]

Hey, it was done to me in SoTM it will be done to him :P

[Lord Winter]

FoS: Beskar, Chaotix and Little Grizzly For jumping on a bandwagon which has no evidence behind it. That's as useless to the town as abstaining. If you're going to bandwagon at least jump on one with some facts supporting it.

I see ricera10 's comments more as a newbies cluelessness then an attempt to avoid the limelight. If you want to lynch someone with similar tells I would suggest DjGingivitis instead. His post is much more characteristic of a lurker mafia IMHO.

Also Welcome to mafia and the .org ricera

[Askthepizzaguy]

FactionHeir: 5 (YLC, Askthepizzaguy, Beskar, Chaotix, LittleGrizzly)
Reenk Roink: 3 (GeneralHankerchief, El Diablo, Shinseikhaan)
Askthepizzaguy: 2 (Centurion1, Sasaki)
Beskar: 2 (Iskander, Tratorix)
Beefy: 2 (FactionHeir, Gaius Scribonius Curio)
ricera10: 2 (Kommodus, spL1tp3r50naL1ty)
Dutchguy: 1 (woad&fangs)
Scottishranger: 1 (Yaropolk)
Myrddraal: 1 (Andres)
AVSM: 1 (Myrddraal)
Sigurd: 1 (Pevergreen)
DJGingivtis: 1 (Lord Winter)
Andres: 1 (gibsonsg91921)
Sasaki: 1 (Ichigo)

No Lynch: 1 (SSNeoperestroika)

Abstain: 11 (atheotes, Jolt, Diana Abnoba, slashandburn, DJGingivitis, Moros, Twilightblade, DisgruntledGoat, Caius, Beefy, ricera10)

Please recheck the tally.






Also, I didn't find ricera's comments to stink of newbishness at all. In fact, if these are the level of posts that we get from a new player, we should consider ourselves lucky. That was a heck of a lot better than some that I've seen. Way to squash enthusiasm, fellows.

[gibsonsg91921]

Ricera10's insights kick my first mafia post's butt.

[johnhughthom]

Vote:Beskar

Two votes with absolutely no effort made to explain them.

Oh and welcome Ricera10. That was a brave post for your first mafia game.

[naut]

Vote: DisgruntledGoat

Funny name. Hehe.

[Chaotix]

FoS: Beskar, Chaotix and Little Grizzly For jumping on a bandwagon which has no evidence behind it. That's as useless to the town as abstaining. If you're going to bandwagon at least jump on one with some facts supporting it.

I see ricera10 's comments more as a newbies cluelessness then an attempt to avoid the limelight. If you want to lynch someone with similar tells I would suggest DjGingivitis instead. His post is much more characteristic of a lurker mafia IMHO.

Also Welcome to mafia and the .org ricera

For the record, I jumped on the bandwagon because ATPG told me he had evidence and a hunch. It's better than anything else on a first round lynch, so I'm gonna roll with it.

[Kommodus]

I see ricera10 's comments more as a newbies cluelessness then an attempt to avoid the limelight. If you want to lynch someone with similar tells I would suggest DjGingivitis instead. His post is much more characteristic of a lurker mafia IMHO.

Cluelessness? Nah. He seems to have done enough reading to be innocent on that count. DjGumDisease claims to be working on something and I'd like to at least see what it is. Ricera10, OTOH, seems like the case of the rookie player making predictably rookie mistakes.

Also Welcome to mafia and the .org ricera

Seconded. Now DIE!!!

[slashandburn]

Unvote:, Vote FactionHeir If ATPG is wrong we can lynch him next time.

[a completely inoffensive name]

I am not going to vote for a random person. I am just going to say this right here, if you want me to vote for someone message me with your suggestion a hypothesis why and reasoning to back it up and I will think about it. Likewise if you are worried you will be voted off, do the same in defense of yourself and I will consider it. ACIN demands proof not wild accusations.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

*privately tells people to vote for pizza instead of accusing him in thread*

[A Very Super Market]

*Privately votes for AtPG

[Jolt]

As I said, Unvote, Vote: FactionHeir

[a completely inoffensive name]

I like FactionHeir, I seem to remember him helping me with modding M2TW back on an earlier account. Why is everyone going after him?

[White_eyes:D]

Ok I didn't exactly expect the flurry of votes to ATPG... suspicious but perhaps not worth the lynch...

Ill go with ATPG and unvote vote factionheir mainly to keep the votes spread out....

What the??? Do you guys know something about Faction Heir?? because that a pretty crappy reason when he already had 3 votes on him Vote:LG

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

I like FactionHeir, I seem to remember him helping me with modding M2TW back on an earlier account. Why is everyone going after him?

Because its the first lynch round, and people are taking the easy option of bandwagoning and thus contributing nothing to the thread.

I feel a response of this magnitude to one accusation is a little excessive. He's not even been afforded an oppurtunity to respond...

[Askthepizzaguy]

@ACIN-

As mentioned by certain folks, I've asked for his head. And now I'm really in trouble regardless, but especially if he turns up innocent, which I doubt.

By the way, as my possibly last act as a living player, I am still requesting folks for protection groups. Please contact me if you're available. Last night, there were far too many last-minute changes and half of the groups did not even function. Let's make sure we have a game plan ahead of time.

[a completely inoffensive name]

@ATPG Why are you asking for his head? (You can reply in a PM if you want.)

[pevergreen]

Unvote: Sigurd, Vote: acin

Sig too big.

[a completely inoffensive name]

Unvote: Sigurd, Vote: acin

Sig too big.

Vote: pevergreen

Reason: Sig not big enough.

[LittleGrizzly]

What the??? Do you guys know something about Faction Heir?? because that a pretty crappy reason when he already had 3 votes on him Vote:LG

ATPG told me he had good reason to suspect him, so i Followed. Look at the times on my two votes before me, they were posted after i began writing my post and not long after ATPG told me...

Im not blindly following i have been told there is good reason, that is better than suspecting ATPG for pm'ing imo.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Host's Tally (through post 293 inc):

FactionHeir: 7 (Askthepizzaguy, Beskar, Chaotix, Jolt, LittleGrizzly, slashandburn, YLC)

Reenk Roink: 3 (El Diablo, GeneralHankerchief, Shinseikhaan)
Beskar: 3 (Iskander, johnhughthom, Tratorix)

Askthepizzaguy: 2 (Centurion1*, Sasaki)
Beefy187: 2 (FactionHeir, Gaius Scribonius Curio)
ricera10: 2 (Kommodus, spL1tp3r50naL1ty)

AVSM: 1 (Myrddraal)
Andres: 1 (gibsonsg91921)
DisgruntledGoat: 1 (psychonaut)
DJGingivtis: 1 (Lord Winter)
Dutchguy: 1 (woad&fangs)
LittleGrizzly: 1 (White_eyes:D)
Myrddraal: 1 (Andres)
Sasaki: 1 (Ichigo)
Scottishranger: 1 (Yaropolk)
Sigurd: 1 (Pevergreen)

No Lynch: 1 (SSNeoperestroika)

Abstain: 10 (atheotes, Beefy187, Caius, Jolt, Diana Abnoba, DisgruntledGoat, DJGingivtis, Moros, ricera10, Twilightblade)

*Centurion1's vote is not formatted correctly; though a quick check by all is not a bad idea.

[glyphz]

I'll go w/ my Day1 bread&butter 'vote on the chap who happens to post just before I did', so

Vote: Seamus Fermanagh
Done.


...
...

Unvote: Seamus

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

edit: dangit... Denied

[Double A]

Some more thoughts:

There's a large number of people abstaining. Worse yet, there are people abstaining without giving any other comment (I'm looking at you Jolt). Sounds like intentional lurking to me. A vote by the uninformed masses is random at worst. A vote by the informed minority always suits them.

The trenchcoat kill bears the hallmarks of a vigilante kill attempt, but perhaps that vigilante kill attempt failed but was quickly followed by a mafia kill which succeeded (the bomb in the car).

"Three point two seconds after turning the key, Quintus.JC was nearly half a block away and rapidly accelerating when the blast"

3.2 seconds makes it sound like a separate attempt to the tommy guns. What do we gain from knowing that there are vigilantes afoot? It invalidates group alibis, such as Andres' "Dutch_guy was protected last night by me, The Stranger and Moros." since that group could just as easily be the vigilantes/wise guys, hoping to gain innocent status.

Whatever the case, Andres claims a night action, which shows that none of those eating out last night are excluded from carrying out other actions that night.

My final point is more of a gut feeling really, but I couldn't help but notice the two votes for AVSM during chairman selection. If I remember correctly AVSM self voted, which was followed by a vote for him by ACIN.

If both AVSM and ACIN are mafia in the same family, maybe with AVSM as don, it might seem an easy mistake to make for ACIN to vote for his boss without thinking that it would identify him. This would seem particularly likely since AVSM seemed like an unpopular option.

I've got nothing better to go with for now, so I will Vote: AVSM

That seems somewhat probable. Because I see no clearer choice Vote: AVSM

Im inclined to believe that Strangers death might have been a serial killing. The diary makes it seem like that to me.

My thoughts exactly... wow that really sucks for the stranger and QTC...

[a completely inoffensive name]

I just want to say, AVSM might be a cool guy to talk to, but I would go crazy if he was my boss. 25 min lunch breaks!?!? Good job killing my internet social life AVSM.

[A Very Super Market]

You are just bandwagoning on Myrddraal's reasoning. Either vote for the man badwagonee, vote with a clear-cut case, or stick to making silly comments, scum!

Vote: Double A

Mafia stooge acin, join me!

[a completely inoffensive name]

Mafia stooge acin, join me!
And we can rule the galaxy together?

[Lord Winter]

@ATPG Why are you asking for his head? (You can reply in a PM if you want.)

No he can't, if he has a case he should reveal it in public.

unvote: DJGingivtis
Vote: Beskar

I'm tired of this bandwaggoning for no reason.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You know, Lord Winter, this is the most active, talkative, and the most assertive with your opinion as I've ever seen you in a mafia game.