Thief II - Same. Couldn't get into it as much. Thief I was great and a classic but had little replay value for me.
Mass Effect - I'm going to see if I can't force myself to play this one again, and maybe end up liking it.
Earth 2150 - $5 budget game, just never installed it. Meh.
Ghost Recon - Huge stinker. Hated this, it paled next to Operation Flashpoint, which was a bugfest. It was installed for maybe an hour total before being promptly uninstalled, never to see the light of day again.
Call of Duty 4 - Disappointingly shallow game. Crysis blew this away hands down in every category. I made it through one playthrough, forcing myself, and that was it. The only thing that made me not regret buying it was the AC-130 mission. Sad, huh?
Star Wars Empire at War - Poster child for how NOT to make a stupid RTS. Glad I bought this as part of that budget SW game pack for $30. I tried it when it was released and said screw it after 30 minutes.
Far Cry - Doom 3 far outshadowed this. The gameplay was boring as snot. Lasted a total of 15 min on my HDD. Thank god for budget games
Splinter Cell - Horrible, awful port to the PC of what's probably a great console game. Again I forced myself to play about 2 hours and it got uninstalled. This one was free, so no regrets.
Bookmarks