This seems akin to the Thomosian Ontological proof, though it isn't actually.

Anyway.

1. If a material thing exists, and was created it must have had it's creation either:
A. From another material thing
B: From nothing

This, however, assumes that material "things" are created. Given that all matter and energy merely change states, disperse, or congregate, we have no proof of some "thing" being created.

In other words, there is not point at which energy can create more energy, without sacrificing matter, or vice versa.

This raises the question of whether anything has ever been created.

The Big Bang theory states that our universe, as we experience it, has a single temporal point of generation.

However, we do not know if this a point at which nothing became something, or if something completely alien simply became something similar.

That's about as far as my understanding will go.

So basically, jury is out for the forseeable.