1.4 Siege Battles?

[al Roumi]

It seems like musket range is still the same, though. Units have to be RIGHT at the foot of the wall for regular line infantry to fire at them.

Can anyone else confirm this? I had hoped they would have fixed musket fire as well as cannons...

[Fisherking]

I can not really confirm that. I saw my guys firing before they were under the walls. I think it is working though they will shoot when the enemy is in places they can not hit them. Artillery will still try to shoot through the walls of you fort to engage the enemy also, so fire at will needs to be turned off for anything inside the fort.

[Sheogorath]

It's a little exaggeration, but being on walls definitely cuts your guy's musket range. Or appears to, anyway.

[Zenicetus]

It's a little exaggeration, but being on walls definitely cuts your guy's musket range. Or appears to, anyway.

I just had a big siege defense last night and it seemed that way to me too. If the game is calculating vertical as well as horizontal distance to target, without also factoring in gravity and flatter trajectory from firing from the walls, then that could explain it. Muskets have a pretty short range even when both units are at ground level. They should be getting a slight boost over the standard range when firing from the walls. Maybe this can be modded?

On the positive side, the enemy AI did try to climb the walls at three different sides of the fort instead of just a frontal assault. My units' cannon fire from the walls seemed fairly effective. It fired often and at good range, not causing any major damage, but the goal was to suppress morale so they'd break faster after they climb the walls.

On the negative side, the AI attack on my fort was poorly coordinated. The enemy infantry that reached the front of the fort first, started climbing right away, while their companion units were still slowly marching towards the back side of the fort. The multi-angle attack was good, but the timing of it was terrible. I was able to keep most of my forces at the front walls, long enough to start breaking the initial climbers. Then I diverted part of that force to the rear of the fort when the enemy finally showed up there. By the time the last group of climbers arrived, I had plenty of reserve strength to repel them. I was vastly outnumbered at the start of the battle, and the AI would have won, if all its troops had arrived at the top of the walls at the same time.

Maybe it's expecting too much for game AI to handle this kind of thing in real time, but poor coordination lost the battle. They had the numbers and unit quality to win. And that's the case for many different types of battles in the TW series.

Another AI problem: after the main force had been repelled, two infantry units recovered from the rout and decided to attack again, while the rest of their army was retreating off the map. Strategically, it would have been better to have them retreat with their companions to fight again another day. But these clowns tried climbing the walls again, at half unit strength all by themselves, and were left at the end with just a handful of shattered guys running off the field.

This is just one more example of how the AI still has trouble achieving a good balance between allowing individual initiative for a unit, which is sometimes important for units like cavalry, and controlling the army as a cohesive whole. It's been a problem ever since Rome:TW. The AI in ETW is better in maintaining cohesion at the start of a battle than it used to be. But once the situation gets chaotic, it goes into this "every unit for itself" mode instead of pulling the army back together for a second attack, or an organized retreat.

[al Roumi]

Yeah, musket fore from the top of walls still is definitley not quite as you would expect it to be.

Last night I assaulted a militia held fort with militia and grenadiers (revoltionary army).

Firstly, there is still a massive blind spot on the corner of every fort which allows you to walk up to the wall completely un-threatened by defenders & cannons on the walls.

By performing a synchonised assault of the walls from opposite sides of the fort, i forced the defenders to retreat to the centre in defense of the flag while i claimed the walls.

My Militia stationed on the wall section near the gates were then able to fire down into the fort at defenders in between the walls and flag, but their range was not noticeably greater than that of the defenders who were on the ground. I'm not clear on how deadly my Militia's fire into the fort was as I also garrisoned the small tower building in the courtyard with grenadiers -so it's likely they did more killing (closer range, better accuracy).