In answer to the Karthdastim question, I feel it would be too similar to the Roman PBM, which went horribly wrong. A senate based PBM requires a large and constantly changing player base, which rarely happens.

And in response to TCV:

I don't have so much against the Arverni idea as the Aedui, but it would not get my personal vote against other factions. I may be being biased as I do not play 'barbarian' factions on EB (just not my cup of tea, to be honest), and I just never did like the idea of those guys expanding across the continent.

If you say the relationship and the power distribution wouldn't be a problem, I'll believe you. I never joined WotB so I'm not one to comment.

And last the settling disputes through war is a good idea. I just think this idea works better when we use the Sweboz/KH idea.


Right, I expect to be shot at again soon. I'll just make it clear that I will happily play any faction out of the finalists in this thread, and will leave all my doubts and whatnot behind once we decide on a faction, which ever that may be.