Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

Originally Posted by shlin28

Blah, this is too big and complicated for a sober pirate's brain...

*downs some rum*

Now, we have several suspects:

DG - "suspicious" behavior in posts according to Sasaki - I don't see it myself...
ATPG - He is gonna get lynched, and 3 votes should be enough?
WE:D - I really don't see why he is getting accused, he backed out of a group, so what? I do it all the time
Andres - I do not get the case against him. X number of people killed on Night Y, therefore he must be guilty?

Am I correct in thinking that those 4 are the only suspects?

For now, Vote: Abstain

CDF was fingered by Tratorix from beyond the grave.

Unvote ATPG Vote CDF

YARRR!!! Now that's more like it. It be a pleasure t' be servin' you Captain Rabbit. And to this fine crew; if'n ye all do yer duties, we will all share many a pint of the finest brew. Look sharp!

Originally Posted by Yaropolk

CDF was fingered by Tratorix from beyond the grave.

Unvote ATPG Vote CDF

How likely do you think it is that CDF is guilty? What do you imagine Tratorix had on him?

Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit

I'm going to install ATPG as Quartermaster. No offense Seamus, but with that both officers will be cleared as townies.

So kindly do not lynch him today.

CR

Very well. I take it this is confirmation that Louis has been investigated fully?

Unvote; Vote: CDF

Returning my vote to where it was before ATPG tried to get himself killed.

Originally Posted by Louis VI the Fat

Andres...Andres, I don't get any of this.

Does your role oblige you to kill officers? Must you call for mutiny?

I refused to vote you in round one. And in round two. I tried to establish your innocence today. Yet again. I've offered you protection roles on two nights.


Sasaki had you kill an innocent. Sasaki, what's more, got four lads together and tried to kill you last night.

And now, again, you call for mutiny and want to have Sasaki as captain?
I don't get it. I just don't get it.

You rely too much on logic.

Uh, just a clarification, "the second man" in Tratorix's kill refers to his attacker. "The first man" in this case is Tratorix himself.

It has been pointed out to me that I cannot add properly. pevergreen did properly pay me for my vote, I simply failed to notice the addition. I retract my previous statements about pevergreen; he is indeed a trustworthy briber. You can sell your vote to him without worry of being ripped off.

So, there were kills by a solo killer, a vig group, a two person group, and an attempt by another vig group. Which leads us back to Andres not being confirmed innocent. Pizza, do you intend to block him until sigurd's role is revealed?

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

So, there were kills by a solo killer, a vig group, a two person group, and an attempt by another vig group. Which leads us back to Andres not being confirmed innocent. Pizza, do you intend to block him until sigurd's role is revealed?

How about the other 39 not confirmed innocents? Shouldn't they be blocked too? Or are you happy to keep the focus on an innocent townie?

I told you why you know I'm not guilty in my pm.

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

Pizza, do you intend to block him until sigurd's role is revealed?

I intend not to telegraph my movements to the traitors among us. I will ponder my moves and consult with the captain. Yarrr.

Originally Posted by Andres

How about the other 39 not confirmed innocents? Shouldn't they be blocked too? Or are you happy to keep the focus on an innocent townie?

I told you why you know I'm not guilty in my pm.

I don't think you're guilty now. Given an unbiased reading it does seem like you're just trying to have fun in this game, similar to how pizza looks innocent because he genuinely wants to relax. If sigurd turns up guilty I'll have to reconsider, but that's a question of risk vs reward not of how suspicious you look. CR didn't make a strong case but you found it frustrating, that's where the suspicion came from.

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

I don't think you're guilty now. Given an unbiased reading it does seem like you're just trying to have fun in this game, similar to how pizza looks innocent because he genuinely wants to relax. If sigurd turns up guilty I'll have to reconsider, but that's a question of risk vs reward not of how suspicious you look. CR didn't make a strong case but you found it frustrating, that's where the suspicion came from.

Of course Sigurd will turn out guilty. CR told that there were detective results telling as much, after I said his initial case was rubbish (which it was).

My frustration was that I feared this game would turn into a "follow orders without asking questions" game; as in town organising itself, putting data in an excel sheet and lynching the factors that seem off.

vote: abstain

just incase i don't get time to come back and read up the thread later

Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit

I'm going to install ATPG as Quartermaster. No offense Seamus, but with that both officers will be cleared as townies.

So kindly do not lynch him today.

CR

When are you going to install him as Quartermaster? I assume you already sent the pm and ATPG will be Quatermaster at the end of this day phase?

Originally Posted by Andres

When are you going to install him as Quartermaster? I assume you already sent the pm and ATPG will be Quatermaster at the end of this day phase?

Rabbit may not be online at the moment so I'll field that. It's already a done deal, I have the PM and everything. I'll be QM as soon as the day phase is over, which means zero chance of me being converted.

Unvote:DG Vote: CDF And ATPG comes out more powerful then ever because of this....ever get the feeling this was all planned?

I still need to think on, why Tratovix thinks CDF is scum....but with no person showing up to claim he was the third member of the group....he warrants some pressure..(I am afraid it well be a runaway bandwagon.....but I have nothing other then DG acting weird, which is not weird apparently)

I bet most of the scum are staying toally silent.

Also, @CR, where's my pirate sketch?

Originally Posted by Death is yonder

Vote: Cultured Drizzt Fan

He seems to have a penchant for revealing himself to be scum when under overwhelming pressure..

I will give 10 gold to whoever can guess what game it's from...

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

I will give 10 gold to whoever can guess what game it's from...

I wanna say Fillet Royale II...

That was fast.... ok, I will send a PM to GH....I did say after all

I remember it because it was one of the few things I was there for that game...think I got killed night one and then replaced back in the round he cracked.

I felt bad for CDF but it was so funny....

He was saying he was not part of that family...but part of this one....which made almost no difference(because that still made him mafia)

We still lost though....hoping he will let something slip....errrr..I mean "I hope he is Mafia or I well feel REALLY bad"

Avast there Sasaki!

Answer me this -- and remember I'm serving as the quartermaster for a mite longer you dog -- are you after thinkin' DG is posting far too much compared to other recent efforts he's made?

Vote: slashandburn

For 5 gold, I'll switch my vote off'n you...

Originally Posted by Seamus Fermanagh

Avast there Sasaki!

Answer me this -- and remember I'm serving as the quartermaster for a mite longer you dog -- are you after thinkin' DG is posting far too much compared to other recent efforts he's made?

I was, but pizza says he goes into that mode sometimes on another site.

Vote: Seamus Fermanagh I refuse to be extorted.

Any suspicions I have against CDF can really not be properly explained without revealing material I am not permitted to reveal. Of course, I can always point out how he only shows up to vote abstain once per round and claims to be too busy. You know, the typical behaviour of someone trying to avoid attention.

Honestly it is probably best if you just lynch me now. Close up some loose ends and probably help the town overall. Not to be a deafest and all, but my use has pretty much dried up with Tratorix's death. Would be best for someone else to take over my job.


Plus I really do not have enough time to do as many posts as some people would like me to make.

Vote: CDF I guess it is a bit defeatist, but it is still probably for the best. Tratorix and Atheotes I am sorry if you think I led to your death, But I am innocent for now.

Vote: Scottishranger

So far, I haven't found anyone who can tell me where you've been. And you seem deadly quiet... making subtle comments here and there, but not voting.

So Tratorix does know something specific regarding his accusation against CDF, I thought it was just a random revenge thing

my use has pretty much dried up with Tratorix's death.

This, and the other comments you made, make you sound terribly suspicious... Of course, it also appealed to the part of the mind that likes conspiracy theories - perhaps Tratorix is pro-town role and you "failed" to protect him?

Either way...

Vote: Abstain, Vote: Cultured Drizzt Fan