Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

[DisgruntledGoat]

Is there anyway to prevent a player from being recruited other than role blocking the recruiters? If there is then I think it would make sense to do that instead of losing a townie vote.

[Yaropolk]

Is there anyway to prevent a player from being recruited other than role blocking the recruiters? If there is then I think it would make sense to do that instead of losing a townie vote.

Officers are unrecruitable.

[DisgruntledGoat]

Then what are we wasting time voting ATPG off the ship for! Make him first mate already.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Not a single one of these posts is incriminating:

Pizza, if White_Eyes was with you on N2 we already have 2 attacks of 2 on night 2 which means he couldn't have participated. So He couldn't have been part of that. That would leave him being another role.... possibly a lone killer. Interestingly enough, a lone killer shows up on N3 the very night White_Eyes doesn't join your group and doesn't abandon ship.

Vote: White_Eyes:D

Thats a good point. Although, the circumstances of White_Eyes not wanting to be apart of your group N3 seems AWFULLY
suspicious.

Why not just abandon ship like you said you would do? Hmmm, could it be because you want to ensure your gold gets left to someone?

So pizza guy who would you suggest be the double lynch victim along with you?

No I'm not too sure what to do with this situation at this point. I'm just trying to figure things out. To me it looks like two townies that are suspicious of each other. I wanted to know who ATPG would suggest for his co-lynchee.

o_O that last statement seems awfully atypical for ATPG.

You are twisting my words. ATPG has suggested HIMSELF to be lynched. I said I want to know who he wants to go with him. I.E. to see if there were any motives that might surface, not that ATPG would do anything that silly and reveal himself through that but I thought it worth the try. Obviously he was smart enough to suggest Sasaki for his co-lynchee and basically revealed nothing. No where did I say I would go along with the double lynch, in fact in that post you quoted I clearly show my opposition for a double lynch and in fact lynching ATPG at all. This sort of thing doesn't seem above board at all. ATPG schemes, it's what he does best and I'm trying to understand this scheme he's got going now.

Is there anyway to prevent a player from being recruited other than role blocking the recruiters? If there is then I think it would make sense to do that instead of losing a townie vote.

Then what are we wasting time voting ATPG off the ship for! Make him first mate already.

But taken TOGETHER...

I didn't quote the ones from page 32. But if you read over DG's posts this day it looks like he considers a variety of suspects (andres, white eyes, pizza) but abandons them when it appears they won't be lynched. I also don't by that his first post about the double lynch was intended to get information from pizza, it seems more like a mafioso who was happy enough with a double lynch to not stop and consider whether it was a good idea. Now he seems to be making a show of "we can't lynch a townie! Make him first mate!" even though louis has presumable been investigated as well...

I don't find this to be typical of DG.

[DisgruntledGoat]

Then by all means Sasaki, lynch me. I'm bouncing all over the place because there isn't really anything to go on at all. Things are very fluid right now and new information is coming forward with each post. The only way you get answers is by asking questions. I do wonder what you would consider typical of me. I don't think I have played enough games here to establish my usual play. In fact, my usual play is quite different from anything I've done on the ORG. Ask Pizza. I'm usually FAR FAR FAR more aggressive.

[Askthepizzaguy]

DisgruntledGoat is terrifying when he's in full-on townie mode.

[DisgruntledGoat]

DisgruntledGoat is terrifying when he's in full-on townie mode.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Then by all means Sasaki, lynch me. I'm bouncing all over the place because there isn't really anything to go on at all. Things are very fluid right now and new information is coming forward with each post. The only way you get answers is by asking questions. I do wonder what you would consider typical of me. I don't think I have played enough games here to establish my usual play. In fact, my usual play is quite different from anything I've done on the ORG. Ask Pizza. I'm usually FAR FAR FAR more aggressive.

DisgruntledGoat is terrifying when he's in full-on townie mode.

I've never seen you go full on townie mode. Usually when I'm in townie mode I bounce around looking for the most suspicious person

unvote:DG, vote:shlin

Try and find a suspect...

[shlin28]

Blah, this is too big and complicated for a sober pirate's brain...

*downs some rum*

Now, we have several suspects:

DG - "suspicious" behavior in posts according to Sasaki - I don't see it myself...
ATPG - He is gonna get lynched, and 3 votes should be enough?
WE:D - I really don't see why he is getting accused, he backed out of a group, so what? I do it all the time
Andres - I do not get the case against him. X number of people killed on Night Y, therefore he must be guilty?

Am I correct in thinking that those 4 are the only suspects?

For now, Vote: Abstain

[Yaropolk]

Blah, this is too big and complicated for a sober pirate's brain...

*downs some rum*

Now, we have several suspects:

DG - "suspicious" behavior in posts according to Sasaki - I don't see it myself...
ATPG - He is gonna get lynched, and 3 votes should be enough?
WE:D - I really don't see why he is getting accused, he backed out of a group, so what? I do it all the time
Andres - I do not get the case against him. X number of people killed on Night Y, therefore he must be guilty?

Am I correct in thinking that those 4 are the only suspects?

For now, Vote: Abstain

CDF was fingered by Tratorix from beyond the grave.

Unvote ATPG Vote CDF