Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

Vote: Jolt

Originally Posted by Diana Abnoba

Vote: Jolt

Ah, but of course. Somehow I can sense what ATPG's arguments might be.

Originally Posted by Jolt

I dislike pirates from Tortuga.

Unvote, Vote: Louis IV

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

unvote, vote: Jolt

Originally Posted by Jolt

EDIT: At 8/9 PM, I had dinner and left with some friends to go to Bairro Alto, how the heck could I have been here to write any of that??? Its irrelevant, in any case.

And you're in Portugal, yes... so when you were voting in the top quoted post, it was 5:27PM my time, as reflected in the quoted conversation. Not to mention the fact that you were here to, you know, vote, precisely 3 minutes before I voted for you. So everything you're saying is a lie. Which, if you're a townie, means you want to confuse and spread misinformation even in death.

Have a balloon.

Hmm, it's possible that Jolt told pizza that so that he could claim in the thread that pizza was lying. I don't think he would confess that if he was really going all out anti-town (it's moot anyway). And that's not really any more lynch worthy than claiming you should be lynched to get yourself promoted to officer...

There isn't any point in lynching townies who want to become mafia. It's not something you can choose. You're basically just lynching a townie...

Good point Sasaki, but trusting a proven (by investigation) townie, over one whom has stated that he wants to become mafia, and refuses to do protections, is better in my book. Unless anyone has a better lynch suspect in mind, with more proof, my vote stands. Although I will admit, none of the lynch possibilities have been without some question. We have no REAL proof of a mafia this round.

Originally Posted by Diana Abnoba

Good point Sasaki, but trusting a proven (by investigation) townie, over one whom has stated that he wants to become mafia, and refuses to do protections, is better in my book. Unless anyone has a better lynch suspect in mind, with more proof, my vote stands. Although I will admit, none of the lynch possibilities have been without some question. We have no REAL proof of a mafia this round.

It's not logical though. A proven townie you can perhaps trust not to lie, but that in no way means that who he says should be lynched should actually be lynched. In this case, he's saying "lynch this guy, he's a townie. The only evidence against jolt also includes him being a townie.

So shlin is more likely to be mafia than jolt

What is the evidence on Shlin, why do you think he is mafia?

Originally Posted by Diana Abnoba

What is the evidence on Shlin, why do you think he is mafia?

My gut instinct, based on his response to being called out for having a low post count. His posts show a desire to not be suspected based on being a lurker. That's good townie play, but something mafia do a higher percentage of the time than townies do.

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

My gut instinct, based on his response to being called out for having a low post count. His posts show a desire to not be suspected based on being a lurker. That's good townie play, but something mafia do a higher percentage of the time than townies do.

Well based on that, we have several suspects (see my post from last lynch phase).

Ahoy!

I'm sorry that due to events that were very briefly in my control and are now far beyond it, I had to skim read today. But discussion is good, so keep that up. I'll be able to read and communicate more soon, though. First thing will be communications with my officers and various roles who've contacted me.

Also, to those who requested avatars, I must contritely say I can't fulfill the orders until Monday.

Thanks,
CR

I trust pizzaguy! As for the people who just lurk, they're probably going to end up as targets for night actions sooner or later.

Vote: Jolt