Org Mobile Site
Thread: Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]
Originally Posted by TinCow:
Why would you alert the target of an investigation that they were about to be investigated?
The answer to that is ALWAYS "politics."Why would you alert the target of an investigation that they were about to be investigated?
I have been shamelessly lurking all game, laddies, aye, I have. It's burnt toast I've been from writing and working to catch up on RL after living in NJ for a stretch. Think a bit on those games where I have lurked and you'll see its NOT me as mafia that my lurking signifies.....
Unvote: Lord Winter (though he's lurked as shamelessly as me).
Vote:Taka
Unvote: Lord Winter (though he's lurked as shamelessly as me).
Vote:Taka
Vote: ACIN FoS: Cent1, TinCow, CR
Unvote; vote: ACIN
no room for petty squabbles on this ship lads, resolve yer issues now
FOS: Reenk Roink
you aint 100% clear yet laddie
no room for petty squabbles on this ship lads, resolve yer issues now
FOS: Reenk Roink
you aint 100% clear yet laddie
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit:
A correction from the detective;
reenk and CDF are both not susceptible at all. That is what was found out last night, not their actions.
CDF has had one successful protection, from night one. He and two others, now dead, protected centurion1 from a single attacker.
Makes me wonder if he's the last maven and a different maven attacked cent1 on night one to provide an alibi for CDF.
CR
that is something the 2 dead people have thought about... A correction from the detective;
reenk and CDF are both not susceptible at all. That is what was found out last night, not their actions.
CDF has had one successful protection, from night one. He and two others, now dead, protected centurion1 from a single attacker.
Makes me wonder if he's the last maven and a different maven attacked cent1 on night one to provide an alibi for CDF.
CR
and when you consider the timing of the 2 deaths...hmm....
Vote:CDF
I am not sure what is going on, but I think he is the most likely suspect right now.
I am not sure what is going on, but I think he is the most likely suspect right now.
unvote vote:ACIN Sorry but I have to bandwagon so the Mutiny won't win.
Vote: Mutiny
*continues hopeless rowing / paddle / splash / movement*
*continues hopeless rowing / paddle / splash / movement*
Where in blazes did this sudden surge of votes for ACIN come from? 
Sigh, fine i won't go after Reenk anymore. geeze. the fact you are all bandwagoning on a confirmed townie because he wanted revenge on a confirmed townie has a sort of sad irony.
It's a pointless badnwaggon on an innocent member.
I don't really see how someone who was apparntly roleblocked, yet kills still occoured, is guilty.
FoS: Any ACIN votes, if you want to bandwaggon at least go for someone who's being suspected...
I don't really see how someone who was apparntly roleblocked, yet kills still occoured, is guilty.
FoS: Any ACIN votes, if you want to bandwaggon at least go for someone who's being suspected...
Originally Posted by Tratorix:
Where in blazes did this sudden surge of votes for ACIN come from?
I am being used as a scapegoat.Where in blazes did this sudden surge of votes for ACIN come from?
Originally Posted by Centurion1:
ACIN you really tried to base a kill off revenge in a game like this. Thats sort of scummy.......
Of course. I am a scummy guy in mafia in general. That's how I play. I am confirmed townie however by the officers so....ACIN you really tried to base a kill off revenge in a game like this. Thats sort of scummy.......
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit:
Supporting them? Are you not one of them?
You go to kill a likely watchstander based on a personal vendetta and you say you should not have been role blocked?
CR
No I am not one of them, I just support them for their efforts and defend them so no one attempts to pin the last mafia on them and try to kill them all off.Supporting them? Are you not one of them?
You go to kill a likely watchstander based on a personal vendetta and you say you should not have been role blocked?
CR
Yes. Obviously, I may be in the wrong here but that is my stance.
Vote: taka
I can confirm acin's statements.
I can confirm acin's statements.
Originally Posted by Centurion1:
Unvote; vote: ACIN
no room for petty squabbles on this ship lads, resolve yer issues now
FOS: Reenk Roink
you aint 100% clear yet laddie
And here.....we go.Unvote; vote: ACIN
no room for petty squabbles on this ship lads, resolve yer issues now
FOS: Reenk Roink
you aint 100% clear yet laddie
Hey Centurion I see that you are eager to jump on the bandwagon to kill me. And I see that you admit your reasoning behind the bandwagon is because I am having a squabble with another townie and not because of any actual connection or evidence that I am the last mafia (which it has been proved I am not repeatedly).
I also like how apparently right after voting for the guy attempting to kill an innocent townie for revenge you immediately call out the finger of suspicion on the townie that everyone is hassling me for attempting to kill.
unvote; vote: Centurion1
Is everyone going to ignore my rebuttal?
ACIN seems like a good choice. We can have the final results on Reenk and CDF in the next day phase.
CR
CR
eerrrr....He is a townie right?
Why lynch a townie? I think we need to cross others off the list....
Why lynch a townie? I think we need to cross others off the list....
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit:
ACIN seems like a good choice. We can have the final results on Reenk and CDF in the next day phase.
CR
lol yay. I guess CR has decided to abandon his offering of calling everyone off if I were to give him the F.H. names.ACIN seems like a good choice. We can have the final results on Reenk and CDF in the next day phase.
CR
See, if I were to be killed, I actually think this is the best way it could turn out. I wanted as much lulz as possible out of this game, and now I get to be a scapegoat even though I am confirmed townie by Louis, and the last mafia guy gets to kill for another night which is lol for me because this proves my point about why I don't think the officers should be trusted in the first place. way to follow your leaders everyone! lets go kill the innocent guy for making waves! Bandwagoners unite!
To the last remaining mafia guy out there, please contact me if I am lynched. I would really like to talk to you if I am knocked out of this game.
Originally Posted by a completely inoffensive name:
lol yay. I guess CR has decided to abandon his offering of calling everyone off if I were to give him the F.H. names.
Well since you didn't give me any names...lol yay. I guess CR has decided to abandon his offering of calling everyone off if I were to give him the F.H. names.
It's simple; the rapier killer only appeared these last two nights. ACIN isn't a member of the 'four horsemen'; as I understand it he only joined them in the attack on Reenk last night.
Now, since the 'four horsemen' weren't operating two nights ago - likely some of them went for the treasure - and if ACIN replaced one of them in the hit on Reenk, then it seems possible that the rapier killer might be the member ACIN replaced, but who's still alive.
CR
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit:
Well since you didn't give me any names...
It's simple; the rapier killer only appeared these last two nights. ACIN isn't a member of the 'four horsemen'; as I understand it he only joined them in the attack on Reenk last night.
Now, since the 'four horsemen' weren't operating two nights ago - likely some of them went for the treasure - and if ACIN replaced one of them in the hit on Reenk, then it seems possible that the rapier killer might be the member ACIN replaced, but who's still alive.
CR
Like i said in my message to you. They didn't want to accidentally kill an innocent and get a lynch going on them.Well since you didn't give me any names...
It's simple; the rapier killer only appeared these last two nights. ACIN isn't a member of the 'four horsemen'; as I understand it he only joined them in the attack on Reenk last night.
Now, since the 'four horsemen' weren't operating two nights ago - likely some of them went for the treasure - and if ACIN replaced one of them in the hit on Reenk, then it seems possible that the rapier killer might be the member ACIN replaced, but who's still alive.
CR
Originally Posted by a completely inoffensive name:
And here.....we go.
Hey Centurion I see that you are eager to jump on the bandwagon to kill me. And I see that you admit your reasoning behind the bandwagon is because I am having a squabble with another townie and not because of any actual connection or evidence that I am the last mafia (which it has been proved I am not repeatedly).
I also like how apparently right after voting for the guy attempting to kill an innocent townie for revenge you immediately call out the finger of suspicion on the townie that everyone is hassling me for attempting to kill.
unvote; vote: Centurion1
This makes so much sense to me for some reason. And here.....we go.
Hey Centurion I see that you are eager to jump on the bandwagon to kill me. And I see that you admit your reasoning behind the bandwagon is because I am having a squabble with another townie and not because of any actual connection or evidence that I am the last mafia (which it has been proved I am not repeatedly).
I also like how apparently right after voting for the guy attempting to kill an innocent townie for revenge you immediately call out the finger of suspicion on the townie that everyone is hassling me for attempting to kill.
unvote; vote: Centurion1
I feel like I am being used in a game between all these different people with power. I feel that ACIN and the 4 horseman are also using me but the fact is they might also be being used and might want to break that. Had CR not saved me I'd have voted mutiny by now but he said to "give him some time" and it seems like people are opening their eyes which is all I want, not to go and kill the captain if he's legit.unvote, vote Centurion1 Caught investigating by me, OK, but also saved... seems like a ploy...
I organized the protection on Centurion1, because he's a watchstander, which is why he was, you know, investigating.
You know that, and you also know that he can't be either of the killers left.
CR
So when I pm'd 4 people at the start of the game, trying to form a group, they turned out to be:
A watchstander (cent)
A mafioso (scottish)
2 accidental masons (LG and woad)
No wonder I had trouble getting something started
A watchstander (cent)
A mafioso (scottish)
2 accidental masons (LG and woad)
No wonder I had trouble getting something started
I am very confused at this point.
vote: Centurion1
vote: Centurion1
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro:
So when I pm'd 4 people at the start of the game, trying to form a group, they turned out to be:
A watchstander (cent)
A mafioso (scottish)
2 accidental masons (LG and woad)
No wonder I had trouble getting something started
Combine that with your abbreviated Pentangeli reclamation effort from Capo III and you may just be the unluckiest organizer ever. So when I pm'd 4 people at the start of the game, trying to form a group, they turned out to be:
A watchstander (cent)
A mafioso (scottish)
2 accidental masons (LG and woad)
No wonder I had trouble getting something started
Originally Posted by miotas:
I am very confused at this point.
Let me unconfuse you:I am very confused at this point.
Do not vote for centurion1.
CR
Once people stop voting for my mate, who I know is a townie, then I will remove my vote from the person with the second highest number of votes.
Vote: Mutiny
Clearly this current administration has been a disaster for the crew of this fine vessel.
Clearly this current administration has been a disaster for the crew of this fine vessel.
So you're voting for a known watchstander? Are you trying to hold the town hostage or something?
EDIT: Sheesh, why don't all you dead british and maven just go and try to take over the Flying Dutchman?
CR
EDIT: Sheesh, why don't all you dead british and maven just go and try to take over the Flying Dutchman?
CR
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO