Blackadder Mafia [Concluded]

[Diamondeye]

So, who is your top suspect, DiamondEye?

I liked Winston's reasoning for blaming vote:Centurion1 if I had to throw in a first vote, really.

Is that sound reasoning?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I plan on using my extra life, and I'll come back and personally consume the Blackadders with fire from my eyes, and bolts of lightning from my

And here I am. Prepare to die.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

CDF 4 double a, Beskar, johnhughthom, ATPG
ATPG 4 Atheotes, WinstonHughes, Beefy Jooray
DiamondEye 1 AVSM
Centurion1, Sprig,
AVSM 1 DiamondEye

Conclusions to be drawn:

Double A is not mafia with CDF.
Beskar, JHT, and ATPG all died shortly thereafter.

I don't know whats happened but I'll

vote: atpg

wig slides a little*


Wow, is it my mind or does my eyes see apple pie over there!

runs off into the hills*

are we still doing stuff? well i'll

vote: atpg

if we are

Conclusions to be drawn:

Thermal Mercury voted for me TWICE after the deadline. Once after I was already dead and obviously innocent. That's either the worst mafia play I've ever seen, or he's innocent.

CDF voted Centurion, Sprig voted Centurion1, Winston voted Centurion, Beefy voted Centurion

Conclusions to be drawn:

Sprig is not mafia with Centurion1
Beefy is not mafia with Centurion1

CCRunner is absent, on a ski trip

Conclusions to be drawn:

He can't help spare any mafia from the lynch right now if he were mafia, and given how Centurion1 second voted him, CCRunner is not mafia with Centurion1.

Unvote: Centurion, Vote: Pizza

My friends! I see through his ways!
This man here is a cunning tactician! Not only does he like pizza which we all love, his saying alot of things! This is a act to seduce Lord Blackadder, and my self!

This is a popularity contest and you sir wins my vote

Don't you know, wicked child, that changing your vote all the time is not how the great one has intended this world to work. If he wanted to he would have attached a turn around head when creating us. You should much rather Vote: Atpg and stay with it as the prophets have foretold and stay with it. Here we have someone who is clearly on the edge, maybe because of playing with the dark ones undead creation too much, and is loosing his cool when defending his scummy ways. Let's put him to a well deserved rest.

So I take it the serial killer isn't experienced, because they're not me!

Also because they killed a guy we were probably gonna lynch.

But everyone here is experienced...

Interesting how you focused on this one murderer instead of the other.

Darling? That's a funny name for a guy. The last person I called darling was pregnant 20 seconds later! WOOF!

And can we stop killing off ATPG for presenting a WIFOM at the beginning of the game for no reason other than to screw with us? Do what I do, don't take him seriously till day 2...

So do we know who this darling fellow was, chaps? I hope by him almighty we have not killed a power role here. Whatsoever I will now go into my retreat and beg him for giving me absolutions for my sin of killing an innocent one. This was truly the devils work.

This sounds absolutely fake.

Captain..... I'm the only captain here......

Some laddy best be investigatin' atheotes, he don't sit right with me

Wicked child, don't you know the dead are not supposed to speak, worst laughing was never intended by the great one at any time. You should much rather stay in silence and wait for your turn in the purgatory where you will most likely will end up, sinner.
I'm sorry for being absent during the last voting phase, He himself called me to spend a day in my retreat to think about my sins in the first round, so I had no chance to participate in such worldly actions as voting.

Who are you to tell me to shush, you scummy, scummy, scummy scum???

Focus your efforts on these scummy candidates. I am rather interested to see how you gentlemen vote. I accuse the following people of being scummy Blackadders:

Joooray
Beefy187
Sprig

I liked Winston's reasoning for blaming vote:Centurion1 if I had to throw in a first vote, really.

Is that sound reasoning?

I am strongly considering adding you to that Blackadder list.

You voted for AVSM, Beskar, and Centurion1. I'm not a fan of any of those choices, my friend. But a lot of people are a fan of voting for Centurion1. More people than I'd expect, were he guilty.

Just a Couple of quick Bullets:
-Beefy is listed after the "Rules" Bullet in the OP.
-Apologies for not withdrawing my Vote against AVSM, I simply wasn't online since He woke up and posted in the Thread. I might have been able to save Pizza, whose Style I like so much that He should be kept alive even if He's Scum.

Oh, and the deliberate Lack of Punctuation in the Writeup really threw me off. What happened, exactly?

This is similar to the same nervous tick I've observed in mafia over the years. You speak to basically no one in particular and ask questions no one answers.

This may be your style, because I'm not as familiar with yours as I am with most, but you are triggering my unconscious alarms. If you're innocent, this is just how I roll. I'd be a bad player if I didn't put pressure on you.

Out of Joooray, Beefy, and Sprig, who is your top suspect?

[Askthepizzaguy]

He who posts, and runs away, lives to get lynched that very same day.



Posted at: 13:02
Left at: 13:02

Asked a question in his post, didn't stick around for a response.

[Diamondeye]

I had to leave, I live in Scandinavia and timezones are obviously not the same as yours. I'm not blaming you for suspecting me, I know that's how you roll. And I'm glad you've shortened the list down to three members.

Concerning the bulletpoints, I like to point out mistakes to clear communications and eliminate any sources of misinformation. Apart from that, the reason I didn't do a tally myself was because I had to leave, which explains why I logged off shortly thereafter. I'm having two friends over for LAN, so actually I don't have much time for this even now. I'll congratulate you on your observations and tell that of the three people you lined out, I don't have clear preference. I would say unvote:Centurion, vote: Joooray on a whim, but I still do suspect Centurion...

[Askthepizzaguy]

Then I shall ask, for what reason? How many in the game have voted for him, bandwagonned him?

• I doubt that all of the people who voted for Centurion1 were innocent.
• Bandwagonning Centurion1, one's own guilty partner, is not the act of a mafia so early in a game.

Conversely, look at who Centurion1 has voted for. Would he, as mafia, vote for his partner in a bandwagon, so early? I doubt it.

I have severe doubts as to Centurion1's guilt. He's been voted for by, and he's voted for, too many people in my opinion, for him to be a likely candidate as mafia. Observing others' voting patterns, I see some rather bad, thoughtless votes on people now proven innocent, and I see certain people not voting for each other. My pizza senses are tingling...

You may have real life reasons for doing what you do, Diamondeye, and if I am wrong I'll with you at the end of the game, but for now I am not sure I accept your explanations at face value. I don't trust you at the moment. But your vote on Joooray at least reveals something: you're willing to vote for Joooray.


More discussion from the living would be helpful.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Well..... That is very well thought out analysis. I am somewhat surprised I am not on the list though, considering I scummily tried to save myself by lynching you pizza.

Vote: sprig


Diamondeye is starting to sound like a better and better choice however.

[Diamondeye]

ATPG, I base my suspicion of Centurion mainly on his day 1 actions. Winston almost invited him to join in on bandwagoning CCRunner, then turned around and exposed Centurion when he did. It might have been a clever ploy by Winston and if he hadn't been killed by the Blackadders shortly after I might have suspected him instead, but that's not what happened. That makes Cent look suspicious to me.

Is that too basic for you or is my logic simply faulty, ATPG?

[Thermal]

vote: sprig

He has Sexuality issues with leeches. I'm not even kidding.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well..... That is very well thought out analysis. I am somewhat surprised I am not on the list though, considering I scummily tried to save myself by lynching you pizza.

Askthepizzaguy says:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I "scummily" tried to save myself by voting you, too, CDF. A townie knows he's innocent and will vote for a suspect rather than allow himself to die needlessly. There are some things that place you on my radar, CDF, but I need more data.

ATPG, I base my suspicion of Centurion mainly on his day 1 actions. Winston almost invited him to join in on bandwagoning CCRunner, then turned around and exposed Centurion when he did. It might have been a clever ploy by Winston and if he hadn't been killed by the Blackadders shortly after I might have suspected him instead, but that's not what happened. That makes Cent look suspicious to me.

Is that too basic for you or is my logic simply faulty, ATPG?

Askthepizzaguy says:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Our logic could be impeccable and we can still be wrong. I am not 100% sure on anyone I accuse here. You could have little or no reasoning to vote for someone, lynch them, and they turn out guilty. You could have oodles of reasons to vote for someone and they turn out innocent. What I am suggesting, is more of... an odds game. What are the odds, for example, that a Blackadder with 2 or 3 votes on him would be voted by another Blackadder, to make it 3 or 4 votes... especially on an early round where there's no detective result proving him guilty and there are other plausible suspects?

Sure, IT CAN HAPPEN, but I'd rather scumbags win games with impressive ballsy ploys like that than the more sensible/cowardly way. I'll give a benefit of the doubt to people to destroyed a Blackadder when they didn't need to. That smells credible to me. That means I can be fooled, but it also means they've got to kill one of their own to do it, giving the detective another round to find them. It's just a bad gambit, most of the time. In my analysis, I factor in rules... or should I say, guidelines, such as that. Certain people won't be on the same team if they do such-and-such. Certain people are likely to be scumbags if they do so-and-so.

You could be 100% right, and I could be 100% wrong. I just am trying to play the odds in our favor, and (from MY perspective) the odds do not favor Blackadders bandwagonning Centurion1 with him being a Blackadder, not in this scenario. Which means if Centurion1 is guilty, then those voting for him are likely very innocent. But I tried that scenario, and it puts a lot of people in the guilty camp who have ALSO been voting for one another.

It doesn't add up, in my analysis. It's probably the ONLY thing I am good for around here, is being a fairly decent analyst. I've been wrong, and I've been wrong maybe 50% of the time, but in a mafia game, those are much better odds than random guessing.


I hope. *fingers crossed*

[Sprig]

Certainly an interesting analysis not sure why you randomly introduced my name into it there atpg. Perhaps trying to flush some blackadders out?

But anyways more importantly: Vote:Joooray would have been my vote in any circumstance.

Now onto other important things, which character is the ‘strangely handsome man’?

Edit: Oh and who ever is playing that character is a silly silly man!

[Captain Blackadder]

Quick Note to everyone this round will be longer then previous rounds last nights night write up was very late at night for me and I don't want to stay up till that time again so there will be aproximarily an 8 hour extension to this round. So this round will end at 10.00 am GMT +11 time

[Sprig]

Ahhh thats interesting. Google gives me the 'The second blackadder' who can role block. how sweet.

[Joooray]

More discussion from the living would be helpful.

*hit Atpg* Wicked child don't you know that God never intended any discussion, you are supposed to listen to him and do as he wants.
I always do as HE intends it, for example he told me to take the role I have right now and so I bear with his choice to the best of my abilities without being knowledgeable of this tv series and English not being my native tongue. But do you hear me complain? No! Because I know that HE has a plan for me and so I do as I'm told, though maybe a bit constructed so.

But fine, kill me, if it's your choice than it must be HIS choice as well and I'm gladly give into my fate. Just let me tell you that I'm not one of the Blackadder lot and far from being a danger for the town. Anybody that identifies my role can tell you that. BTW, if I have to die I want turnips for my last meal.

Myself I had my suspicions on a lot of people at this point: Centurion, Beefy, Sprig and the more I think about it and from your discussion I'll keep my eye on Diamondeye.

Anyway as I prefer to live to serve HIM almighty I'll Vote: Sprig.

[Sprig]

if your trying to defend yourself, don't vote like scum. :(

[Askthepizzaguy]

Certainly an interesting analysis not sure why you randomly introduced my name into it there atpg.

It wasn't random. I was placing people in order of seemingly most guilty to seemingly least guilty, and there were a lot of people seemingly less guilty than you, and I checked the votes you've made and who has voted for you, and your contribution to the discussion, and I simply felt you warranted a finger of suspicion placed on you.

It's hard to "show my work" on that, so I didn't. It would have been distracting.

And there's also the chance that I might have just thrown your name up there to see how people would react.

[Joooray]

if your trying to defend yourself, don't vote like scum. :(

God says there is no harm in trying to survive by voting for the one your competing with about getting killed.

[Sprig]

if someone disputes your role then my vote will come back to you Unvote: joooray
But I didn't go through life milking pigs and mucking out lepers just to be brought to the sword by someone like Vote:Thermal Mecury

[Thermal]

Sprig has ants in his pants, he wanted to move last night! But he couldn't! The sexuality took over!

[Beefy187]

Out of Joooray, Beefy, and Sprig, who is your top suspect?

Hi there! Good morning!
Firstly, I thank you for picking me as the one of the three. That totally kicks my day off

Secondly.. I suspect...that there is at least one lady in the room and I demand to be introduced to her!

[Sprig]

Really? Seems a strange move to claim a blackadder role TM. But at least you have proclaimed your guilt to everyone.

[Joooray]

So, one last thing before I go to bed: I won't be able to access the web until Monday. Sorry.

[Centurion1]

sprig votes jooray in an obvious ploy to save himself.

jooray votes sprig, obviously to keep it close.

sprig is now trying to deflect attention off of himself by voting for thermal.


or maybe they are both mafia and figure since one of them will likely be trying to protect the other, allows them to vote for him. maybe sprig is posing as the sacrificial lamb

Vote: sprig

For next round: probably jooray or diamond eye. what was so stupendous about winstons logic, hmm?

and then you try to throw the scent off yourself by unvoting rather quickly and switching?

atpg has once again done a rather well done analysis of the situation.

[Beskar]

It was a bad idea for the Mafia to kill me. It would have been tactically better to have lynched a different townie for reasons I won't and can't disclosed.

I took one for the team.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I do want to remind peeps that this is just my take on the situation, and I'm dead/can't vote. So it's up to you to decide if my analysis is worth any salt.

[Sprig]

omg.... perhaps it needs to be in a bigger font.

Thermal Mercury posts reveal himself as the second blackadder

Cent1, you guys deliberately missing this on purpose?

Furthermore it would take any of you just a few clicks to find out who joooray claims to be and just a few to find out who I am. To not bother to do so reeks...

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

omg.... perhaps it needs to be in a bigger font.

Thermal Mercury posts reveal himself as the second blackadder

Cent1, you guys deliberately missing this on purpose?

Furthermore it would take any of you just a few clicks to find out who joooray claims to be and just a few to find out who I am. To not bother to do so reeks...

Sorry I admit I have not been paying much attention to this. What should I be clicking about exactly?

[Diamondeye]

I don't see what you mean Sprig, care to cut it out in paper? Perhaps it's because it's 3:30 AM over here, but I really can't read anything out of Thermal's posts.

[Cultured Drizzt fan]

Alright a few internet searches latter and I am back.

Unvote: Sprig, Vote: Thermal Mercury.

[Thermal]

Oh look, an echo, on paper!

Sprig has ants in his pants, he wanted to move last night! But he couldn't! The sexuality took over!

[Sprig]

Oh look, an echo, on paper!

Which confirms your one of the blackadders and to be specific the 2nd one.
I can see that you are subtly hinting at your result pm, which does you no good but confirm your guilt.

For those that want to know...

I was paid a visit by the handsome blackadder last night, afterwards I spent the night attempt to cure myself of a sexuality problem by using leeches.
TM knows this and hinted about it twice specifically mentioning leeches and sexuality. Which can only confirm that it was him that paid me a visit or it was his mafia buddies.