Quote Originally Posted by TinCow View Post
1) Do you know of a dead pro-town role to use it on? If not, what's even the point of him proving it if it's just exchanging one dead townie for another?
Because he is a potential pro town role and we have other pro town roles who might potentially die.

2) I do not believe GH was a mafioso, it was just a typical erroneous early game lynch.
You can at least admit to being fallible...now which killer do you believe me to be? Either the naga or the corpse killer? I want you to be specific, so that either the mafia prove me innocent or have to make sacrifices not too.


TinCow, you have to admit that your case on Chaotix is simply bad. There are 5 points you laid out.

1) & 2) can be disproven easily, if given a chance.

3) is guilt by association

4) is a coincidence that you find suspicious. You, a claimed pro town role were attacked...there is nothing odd about that. Early on when you claimed you hedged about and it was not clear if you were truly claiming.

5) is the same faulty reasoning you used to get me lynched, which you admitted was mostly gut, and as we know your gut said GH was guilty.


Now, I'm all for granting that Chaotix might be a mafioso with a resurrection ability. If you think so, you are welcome to keep blocking him.