StarWars: Return of the Sith [Concluded]

[Ibn-Khaldun]

All those names in that list were mentioned in the thread and in the write-up. Psycho just collected them. So, that list shows only that he checks the write-ups and thread very closely! Like Subotan in Mafia X perhaps? Can Chaotix confirm that you are Obi-Wan? Can anyone do that?

Edit: Reply to Psychonaut Niklas.

[Renata]

Not all of the names have been posted in the thread, just the majority. A half dozen or so have not been posted and also aren't the sorts of names that you'd go "oh, this guy must be in the game". Psychonaut obviously has access to some sort of out-of-thread information.

[Subotan]

Wookiepedia?

[Choxorn]

My role isn't on that list.

So... why is White Eyes mafia, exactly?

[Beskar]

My 7001st post!

[naut]

Ok we have White_eyes:D with a soft claim. ATPG, your response is reasonable, but you are playing agreeable and with enough initiative to hide but appear active. Diamondeye with some faulty reasoning. And Niklas constantly jumping on the easy target.

[Diamondeye]

Renata, I thought an OMGUS vote required that I voted for you first? I do not recall doing such a thing. I only commented that you and Niklas had grown quiet...

But actually, your post made me realize I had forgotten about TinCow, whom I still feel suspicious about.
I might change my vote to him later if WE:D would find a leg to stand on concerning his supersoft claim.

[Joooray]

So I'm dead? That sucks, but well no big loss for the town. I had hoped to remain uninteresting for the Sith until I maybe was promoted to something to be more helpful, but well there goes that.
But apparently I was quite a ladies man.

Good luck to the town. Hope you'll be more successful with the lynches in the future.
BTW: I'm not sure Palatine was actually a Sith, I know 'khaan never claimed he was innocent, but with the way that, it at least seems that, everything is announced in the write-ups and there being no mention of a recruitment, I could imagine we are still facing the two original Siths.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ok we have White_eyes:D with a soft claim. ATPG, your response is reasonable, but you are playing agreeable and with enough initiative to hide but appear active. Diamondeye with some faulty reasoning. And Niklas constantly jumping on the easy target.

Oh dear.

Psychonaut, I could be crawling all over you for still being alive after having all this information. You're obviously capable of gathering information somehow and that makes you a danger to the Sith, yet you're still alive. Why are you still alive, I wonder? Should I hop on board your wagon and eliminate someone who's been hounding me for a while? If I were a Sith I'd have two reasons to eliminate you, to get you off my back and to silence you. But we both know how pointless that is, because if your claims are fake they involve telling lots of lies which will eventually hang you, so I'm not going to bother.

I also can't explain how you have all that information without it being part of your role, so I won't take the risk.

The fact is I am Nomi Sunrider, have claimed so since about round 2, and I can even point you to the writeup where I gained information from the Jedi Holocron, now that I know that's what the writeup was referring to. I was also investigated, unlike some here. The fact is that if I were a Sith I could only be a recruit. The one you want is the Sith Lord, or one of the original Sith at the very least. Since you know I am not the Sith Lord, and that's one of the few tangible clues you have, and I'll be dead in due time, why don't you focus on getting the Sith Lord, then?

For the record I still haven't been recruited, that's one of the reasons why I am inviting Qui-Gon to drain my powers. I have a power which may or may not be useful, a speed boost, so take that if you will. I believe it adds to your defense. I have one other power which is laughably worthless, the ability to hide from alignment scans, which I didn't get until after I had already been scanned as a potential Sith recruit.

May the force be with you, because at least then it will be with one of us.

I also cannot fathom why you'd think I am a Sith after I volunteered to be lynched to protect Chaotix' identity and rid yourself of a suspect at the same time. But then again, none of you truly understand me, so why should I be surprised.

[Greyblades]

Vote:Psychonaut

[naut]

Oh dear.

Psychonaut, I could be crawling all over you for still being alive after having all this information. You're obviously capable of gathering information somehow and that makes you a danger to the Sith, yet you're still alive. Why are you still alive, I wonder? Should I hop on board your wagon and eliminate someone who's been hounding me for a while? If I were a Sith I'd have two reasons to eliminate you, to get you off my back and to silence you. But we both know how pointless that is, because if your claims are fake they involve telling lots of lies which will eventually hang you, so I'm not going to bother.

I also can't explain how you have all that information without it being part of your role, so I won't take the risk.

The fact is I am Nomi Sunrider, have claimed so since about round 2, and I can even point you to the writeup where I gained information from the Jedi Holocron, now that I know that's what the writeup was referring to. I was also investigated, unlike some here. The fact is that if I were a Sith I could only be a recruit. The one you want is the Sith Lord, or one of the original Sith at the very least. Since you know I am not the Sith Lord, and that's one of the few tangible clues you have, and I'll be dead in due time, why don't you focus on getting the Sith Lord, then?

For the record I still haven't been recruited, that's one of the reasons why I am inviting Qui-Gon to drain my powers. I have a power which may or may not be useful, a speed boost, so take that if you will. I believe it adds to your defense. I have one other power which is laughably worthless, the ability to hide from alignment scans, which I didn't get until after I had already been scanned as a potential Sith recruit.

May the force be with you, because at least then it will be with one of us.

I also cannot fathom why you'd think I am a Sith after I volunteered to be lynched to protect Chaotix' identity and rid yourself of a suspect at the same time. But then again, none of you truly understand me, so why should I be surprised.

----------

Greyblades want to expand on that. Or are you just jumping on the wagon?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Psychonaut is a poor lynch candidate for today. If he's an important role, then we are not being wise or patient by lynching him now. If he's Sith, he's a roleblock/drain candidate, then we lynch him. He's not going anywhere, gentlemen.

If we're going to blind lynch someone, why are we doing it on someone whose claims can be confirmed within a round or two? Better is to lynch someone we can see is acting self-conscious and nervous, like White_Eyes. Remember, if he's calm, cool, and collected, he can only be mafia scum.

[naut]

AH HA! It makes sense. Greyblades. Every single post you have made is pure, pure scum.

I should probably apologise for missing the first two turns I was kinda distracted.
Anyway, I dont think beskar is a good lynch, mainly because I dont like the idea of wasting another day on a guy who can survive being in a vaccum.

Contrived.

I'm here I guess.

Appearing to be somewhat active.

Gah! I'm gone for half a day and the threads jumped four 90 post pages.
Any chance someone could explain whats happened?

Fluff.

Holy inpenitrable walls of text!

Fluff.

You do know there is an edit button right?

Fluff.

Dang, I feel like a right fool now.

Contrived.

Hmm I dont like it. But, I guess if I dont vote this turn I could be wogged, so Vote: Belisarius

Voting just avoid WoG.

So why are we lynching him again?

Scummy.

What did belisarius do?

Scummy, you just voted for him... you should know.

Could someone put up a tally or some sort of summary of whats been going on?

Ugh. I had forgotten how hard it was keeping up with big games that have a post per 5 minutes.

Fluff.

Oh what a happy, friendly, not-getting-irritable game this is turning into.
Gh doesnt particualy come off as scummy to me and I dont think diana's inactivity is a good reason. Vote:Thermal Mercury.

Trite.

I would have been more decisive if I wasn't about to go to a maths lesson and had to leg it immediately afterwards.



You didnt? Let me check... wrong game and a different guy sorry.

Excuses.

Hmm, who should I vote for? Lord winter who has been absent but hasnt been wogged indicating a role with night actions? Atheotes who is acting fidgety and inconsistent or GH who voted for me afew turns ago and andres thinks is scummy.

Classic Mafia tell.

When is this game taking place anyway?

Fluff.

Hey, I can't help it if the thread jumps mulitple pages when I'm asleep/at college.

Excuses.

Vote: AVSM

Jumping on the Wagon.

...I'm gone for half a day and you lot expose the two characters who are most likely to be powerful town roles... Dear god, which blooming genius thought that one up?

So contrived it isn't funny. Wow.

What can I say? Most of the time this game moves too fast for me to keep up.

Excuses.

Vote:Psychonaut

Jump on the wagon AGAIN.

You haven't contributed anything over 20ish posts, but you've been here enough to semi-follow the game and to avoid post a WoG avoidance vote twice. If you aren't scum then my force ghost is an amoeba with syphilis.

Unvote: White_eyes:D Vote: Greyblades

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Psycho is scummy, but that's no reason to lynch him right now.

[naut]

Every vote Greyblades has cast is an easy target who already had many votes on them. He's contributed nothing but excuses and fluff. He's passed under the radar. But, the vote on me is too obvious. Sorry buddy, but you have been active on the forums and your excuses ring hollow. You are trying to lurk to victory. You tick all the Sith boxes, you are scum, scum, scum.

This post alone is enough to lynch you a hundred times over.

Hmm, who should I vote for? Lord winter who has been absent but hasnt been wogged indicating a role with night actions? Atheotes who is acting fidgety and inconsistent or GH who voted for me afew turns ago and andres thinks is scummy.

Why do I think this is so damning? Well I've made this very style of post before, as anti-town. It's a classic tell. You add a disclaimer to try to appear conscious and sincere, when in fact your nonchalance about who to actually vote comes through inadvertently. It's the type of post a townie never makes. It is a scum post. You sir are our Sith, and you should hang be cast into space today.

[johnhughthom]

Vote: Greyblades

Pretty convincing argument from Psycho.

[TinCow]

Every vote Greyblades has cast is an easy target who already had many votes on them. He's contributed nothing but excuses and fluff. He's passed under the radar. But, the vote on me is too obvious. Sorry buddy, but you have been active on the forums and your excuses ring hollow. You are trying to lurk to victory. You tick all the Sith boxes, you are scum, scum, scum.

Vote: Greyblades

[Subotan]

Vote:Greyblades
Speak now, or forever hold your peace

[Yaropolk]

unvote; vote: niklas

[Greyblades]

Hmph so much for waiting until the game slows down...
The truth is that I cant keep up. The pages and pages full of people talking themselves into a circle generated every time I stop paying attention for a second is realy confusing me and to be frank deciding who to vote means trawling through 20 pages of rubbish that quite frankly I dont want to bother with. Thats it.
Oh and that whole who should I vote for bit? Yeah I know its damning, thats why I wouldnt say it if I was actually trying.

[Diamondeye]

I agree with Psychonaut's reasoning but I really wouldn't like WE:D to slip by another round in silence... Greyblades at least answered the accusation.

[Chaotix]

Greyblades, white_eyes, and Niklas are all good choices for today. Psychonaut, for rather obvious reasons, is a terrible choice.

I'll lend my support to the Niklas lynch for now.

Vote: Niklas

EDIT AFTER VOTE:

If you guys really need proof that Psychonaut is innocent, then I will say that the "real" Obi-Wan should reveal to me at any time. And if nobody makes the counterclaim... we have nothing to fear.

[naut]

Just wondering. What is the major reasoning behind the choice of Niklas? I mean, he's been inconsistent, but not particularily scummy.

Greyblades has been consistently scummy, and responded just as scumily... he's the best shot we have today to lynch a Sith. His offhand dismissal of my accusations is too casual, too neutral to be a town response. He's Sith, dead on, with bells-on and force-lightning in this palms and yellow eyes under his hood.

[Secura]

Yes, Diamondeye, we're both mafia. We've been making it blatantly obvious we're working together and won't support each others' lynch for the last few days just so we can laugh at all of you afterwards. Also, we killed Csargo and Methos on perfect information and then pointed out to everybody how small a pool we were swimming in, likewise just for giggles.

Renata... if you never make a single post in the Gameroom again, let this be your epitaph. <3

The fact is I am Nomi Sunrider, have claimed so since about round 2.

I can vouch for this as Beskar informed me Pizza had claimed this role way back at the start of the game. :3

Before I forget to vote again, vote: Greyblades. Throughly convincing argument, Psycho.

[Greyblades]

I'm guessing that I should sign up for replacements seeing as I'm going to die. I'm feeling depressed enough heres my role.:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

"I'm not comfortable with Jedi being seen as weapons. The Yuuzhan Vong are already attempting to turn public sentiment against us. Do we really want to be perceived as an aggressor in this war?"
―Lar Le'Ung, to Kyp Durron and Luke Skywalker

Trivia about this character in the StarWars universe:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Jedi Master Lar Le'Ung, a male Pau'an, was a member of the New Jedi Order at the start of the Yuuzhan Vong War. In 25 ABY, he was stationed at the Jedi Praxeum on Yavin 4 when Prince Finn Galfridian was rescued from the subjugation of his homeworld of Artorias at the hands of the Yuuzhan Vong by Jedi Master Luke Skywalker and brought to the Praxeum for Jedi training. When the Jedi were requested to aid in the evacuation of the planet Rychel, which was under attack from the intergalactic invaders, Le'Ung was tasked with leading the New Republic troops against the Yuuzhan Vong.
The Yuuzhan Vong had deployed two siege creatures—Tu-Scart and Sgauru—and with Galfridian at his side, Le'Ung led the troops in an attempt to distract the creatures long enough for Skywalker to rescue the refugees. As the battle wore on, the Republic troops lost hope and began to run back to their ships. Le'Ung realized that Tu-Scart was emanating fear, and, knowing the refugees needed more time, he raised his lightsaber and called for his troops to hold. As he did so, the Pau'an was attacked from behind by a Yuuzhan Vong warrior who stabbed Le'Ung through the chest and hurled the Jedi Master into the open mouth of Tu-Scart.

Initiate

You are an Initiate and among the best of those that shows potential to grow and gain a great and long career as a member of the Jedi order.
You have been chosen to come on this expedition to recover what seems to be an ancient Imperial Star Destroyer. You are here mainly to observe and learn from those above you in rank. Be not mistaken, you are here because this might advance the timeline in which you learn to become a Padawan.

Not much has been revealed to you at this time, but instructions will presented to you in due time.

Good Luck!!!

[Renata]

If you guys really need proof that Psychonaut is innocent, then I will say that the "real" Obi-Wan should reveal to me at any time. And if nobody makes the counterclaim... we have nothing to fear.

Chaotix, you have a MAJOR unsupported assumption there that you should not be making. We do not know that none of the Sith are running around with perfectly legitimate cover roles -- in fact, the write-ups suggest that they are. There's nothing to say that Psychonaut could not be the only Obi-wan running around the game and still be Sith. Please don't make that assumption, about him or anybody.

[Renata]

Grayblades should be unvoted. Based on that role claim, there is exculpatory evidence out there about him.

I suggest Diamondeye as a replacement.

[naut]

Grayblades should be unvoted. Based on that role claim, there is exculpatory evidence out there about him.

To an extent. It somewhat pokes a hole in my logic. But, on other hand his in-thread behaviour is incredibly scummy. (Plus the fact Sith probably have cover roles) Gah. Need to think about this.

The problem is basically the fact we have ended up with quite a few players who are lurking/semi-lurking and they're all messing with my gut instinct.

[Greyblades]

Oh and uh sorry about lurking like that but earlier in the game choxorn said:

Just wait for some people to die, the posts will die down a bit.

I did wait and well it has yet to die down.

[naut]

Unvote for now. Gah, gah, gah, gah, gah. Square one. Be back in 12 hours.