My three suspects are: Renata, Beskar, and Kagemusha.

Renata just because she seems off. Plus, every now and then she'll IM me about the game, but just enough to bring it up, yet not enough to pull me back in. It's similar to what I did to Niklas in a game where I was mafia, where I tried to get him to become active.

Beskar because he's typically always out front trying to lead the pack. Granted, that's typically in games that have more roles, but I still find his behavior odd in this game.

Kagemusha simply due to all the back and forth with ATPG, in which he brings up some interesting observations.

I'm also curious about split's PM. If that many people received it, then how come we've wasted so much time on him? Why didn't one of them speak up about the PM?

Vote: Kagemusha