Why is there an assumption that the lynch immunity works this way? Who is to say it isn't totally random, or that kage can select any living person? Why is it assumed that Kage can only use it against the number two candidate?
Furthermore, which of the dead could possibly have been one of Kagemusha's slaves? By my count, that can only be Renata, and I don't think that's enough to bother with a lynch that's probably not going to work against Kage. I'd much rather try to have a few more people who are likely to be Kagemusha's henchmen dead before we allow him to deflect the lynch against any one of us.
The neutral/other supernatural being was Kukri, right? So by your own estimate we have not killed Kagemusha's other slave.that leaves two people who aren't town (Kage + ???) with votes. Don't let those two votes make the difference!
I give up. I realize that my own opinion here is built on the assumption of Kagemusha being the Ancient One, so do as you please guys. I am just very strongly against it, and I believe the facts favor my position. I just urge you to think about it more, please.
Bookmarks