No dead reveal is a common enough rule, and seems sporting anyhow.
I don't really see the special role being mafia, doesn't make that much sense. That was the way in the first godfather, but the mafia walked away with that one, and in the next two godfathers it was a pro town role. Since the mafia appear to have been beefed up with Kage's lynch escape, I doubt there is a 4th.
Essentially you guys are betting against reason and the odds because you "can't be sure" but of course that works much better as an argument against your position.
Bookmarks