Mafia IX: Triumph of the Mafia [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

What it means kage, is that pever will never post enough for us to even guess at whether he is mafia. TinCow will. So the math is simple.

Having lurkers alive in endgame is terrible.

It seems that a lot of people are playing risky OMG HE CANNOT BE MAFIA strategies, well I think that's nonsense, he knows he can pull it off, and would you look, all the controversial players are still alive, risky strategies are by no means exclusive to town.

Controversial players don't get killed by the mafia.

[Kagemusha]

What it means kage, is that pever will never post enough for us to even guess at whether he is mafia. TinCow will. So the math is simple.

Having lurkers alive in endgame is terrible.

Well having people alive just because who they are is just as bad. In matter of fact im quite sure pevergreen has talked more in this thread today compared to Tincow. So your point is simply put shallow.

[Thermal]

Controversial players don't get killed by the mafia.

I'm well aware of this because town is more likely to lynch them, which is why a controversial player being a mafia aligned player is the most dangerous. Mafia aren't going to kill players such as ATPG, yet there continual scummy behavior will lead to a wasted lynch if hes innocent.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I'm well aware of this because town is more likely to lynch them, which is why a controversial player being a mafia aligned player is the most dangerous. Mafia aren't going to kill players such as ATPG, yet there continual scummy behavior will lead to a wasted lynch if hes innocent.

Oh, I though you were suggesting we lynch Tincow. But yes, I agree, controversial play needs to stop at some point.

[Thermal]

Oh, I though you were suggesting we lynch Tincow. But yes, I agree, controversial play needs to stop at some point.

Well out of two, I do choose Tincow

vote: Tincow

The cases on Pevergreen are lousy. And its 3-2 to tincow, So I'll even it out.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

But you just said that "the town is more likely to lynch [the controversial players]...will lead to a wasted lynch if he's innocent".

[Thermal]

But you just said that "the town is more likely to lynch [the controversial players]...will lead to a wasted lynch if he's innocent".

Yes, if hes innocent, I was assuming intially that mafia wouldn't be beyond this tactic either and still maintain that thought.

@ ATPG

Ok then, what case on Pevergreen is so great? So original? So much more compelling than the bandwagoning tortoise flipping motherly thought provoking Tincow?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yes, if hes innocent, I was assuming intially that mafia wouldn't be beyond this tactic either and still maintain that thought.

@ ATPG

Ok then, what case on Pevergreen is so great? So original? So much more compelling than the bandwagoning tortoise flipping motherly thought provoking Tincow?

1. pevergreen will lurk and lurk and lurk. This style is terrible for catching mafia, but excellent for surviving as one.
2. The sadistic and intentional wifom I've had to deal with for three rounds is characteristic of pevergreen's true feelings for me. I suspect he'd be cruel enough to inflict it on me.
3. If I were mafia I'd just kill pevergreen without making an elaborate wifom about it. He on the other hand would, for shiggles.
4. He's voted for me, and I know I'm innocent. Thus, removing a bad vote from the game is good. Reenk Roink taught me that.
5. As Sasaki said, he won't put any analysis into the game at the end of it, whereas TinCow will.
6. Simply put, you've got to kill the lurkers before the endgame, or town loses.

[Askthepizzaguy]

The cases on Pevergreen are lousy.

You, Thermal, are a total scumbag in this game. I cast my vote against pevergreen, with great malice.

Vote: pevergreen

And you're next, buddy.