The Revenge of Inishmore! [Concluded]

**Thermal** · 04-21-2010, 01:59

Originally Posted by Renata

Okay, so that's votes from Csargo, Secura, Zack, Methos, Seamus and Subotan; and FOS'es from Diamondeye, Thermal Mercury and Captain Blackadder.

I'm curious why Reenk is voting for TM, because I find his post the most suspicious of the lot. Not only was it a FOS and not a vote (serving to help the bandwagon along while keeping his hands clean(er) in the even that Chaotix wound up lynched, while voting for a random lurker), but it's internally contradictory:

If you don't expect mafia to pull the stunt, then you don't FOS him as being Mafia. You might *vote* him for anti-town behavior (given the number of people voting for Chaotix and the reasons given, it's a sure thing at least one townie did just that), but you don't say you're *suspicious* of him.

vote: Thermal Mercury

You begin saying those who voted for Chaotix are the most suspicious, then you pick me out for FoS'ing him, even after his lynch I expressed my dislike of it for reasons already mentioned. I'll remind you that FoS = Finger of suspicion, Because he did a suspicious thing, but as I already said, not a mafia thing. I think your reasoning is fairly vague at best.

**Renata** · 04-21-2010, 08:55

Originally Posted by Thermal Mercury

You begin saying those who voted for Chaotix are the most suspicious, then you pick me out for FoS'ing him, even after his lynch I expressed my dislike of it for reasons already mentioned. I'll remind you that FoS = Finger of suspicion, Because he did a suspicious thing, but as I already said, not a mafia thing. I think your reasoning is fairly vague at best.

You can think that all you like. Tell me what "suspicious" is supposed to mean in the context of a game like this, if not that you think that Chaotix might be mafia (or other anti-town role).

Pointing out that you turned around and criticized a lynch you'd been a part of doesn't exactly help your case.

**Niklas** · 04-21-2010, 11:30

This game is totally making my head spin. Take that as a compliment, pevergreen.

I will vote: AVSM. His out-of-context "Wait, we got PMs?" just screams WIFOM.

**A Very Super Market** · 04-21-2010, 16:23

Originally Posted by Niklas

This game is totally making my head spin. Take that as a compliment, pevergreen.

I will vote: AVSM. His out-of-context "Wait, we got PMs?" just screams WIFOM.

That was White Eyes.

**Subotan** · 04-21-2010, 17:25

That was in fact me.

**Niklas** · 04-21-2010, 17:37

That should teach me.

**Methos** · 04-21-2010, 17:56

@pevergreen: It was actually a three-way tie, as you missed my vote against GH.

**Thermal** · 04-21-2010, 14:35

Originally Posted by Renata

Pointing out that you turned around and criticized a lynch you'd been a part of doesn't exactly help your case.

I wasn't part of it, by the time I made my comments he already received a runaway bandwagon and I was no part of that, I simply acknowledged his 'unusual' behavior (another way of putting it) with a FoS, as a few others did, to show I didn't approve of his posts, more or less.

How you come to the conclusion that I wanted him lynched when even in the post I FoS'd him I said it was a bad idea, is beyond me.

-----

In other news, GH looked to be at the bane of a mafia target, I think hes innocent.

**Renata** · 04-21-2010, 14:48

That's OK, Thermal, it looks like nobody else sees it my way anyway.

**Thermal** · 04-21-2010, 15:06

Sorry if I seem to be a bit aggressive in my posts, after reading them they may come off like that.

Ooh and thanks for the sig quote

**Joooray** · 04-21-2010, 15:21

Edit:
Forget it.

I was late after all. Thought the day went till 5 pm GMT+1.

**Thermal** · 04-21-2010, 15:22

Originally Posted by Joooray

I think it's still day, right?

If so, Vote: White_Eyes:D. The case on him seems to be alright and he is definitely not making a good case for himself.

Its clearly stated as night in the write up...