Quote Originally Posted by Niklas View Post
That's exactly why I voted Market. But there was no way I would vote Thermal, since him not voting for me meant I was sure he was innocent.
A fair and correct judgment, but impossible for a townie to know. A mafioso would be dead certain that voting for his ally was suicide there. That certainty when you couldn't have been certain is what made me almost totally convinced you had to be mafia. It is rare that a townie with no information is sure of anything.

And since I thought there were two mafia, lynching an innocent would mean loss. Didn't really matter if that innocent was me or Thermal.
I just wanted to see if you would actually put some distance between you, and you were refusing. In that scenario, all you needed to do if the two of you were mafia was convince any one townie to think me scummy or switch votes. The closeness between you and dead certainty I was mafia when I wasn't made you seem scummy as hell, or simply townies who were going to lose the game and I had no way of convincing you otherwise.

But I tried to explain that to you, that voting Market would have exactly the same outcome from your point of view, but vastly different from mine. You just didn't see it though.
I still don't, frankly. 3 townies must vote as one in a 5 player, 2 mafia setup. Stabbing AVSM in the back was impossible from my perspective.