Quote Originally Posted by Psychonaut View Post
He's never been scanned, we don't know what he is. He could quite simply be lying with a convenient cover.
That's right, autolycus has never been scanned but again, we know that General Pepper should be in the game (every other character from post #1 is). I don't see how autolycus couldn't be General Pepper.


Quote Originally Posted by Psychonaut View Post
Pinman could investigate. So what's not to say he investigated auto early on? Yes, they did do what you say there, and it makes sense turn the players the town think are innocent.
Pinman claimed investigative powers but he was very possibly lying. He knew that Beskar was Wolf because civplayah infiltrated Star Wolf from the start. He was lying about scanning Beskar, as he didn't have to scan him to know his alignment.

I think the Androssians never had a scanning ability and were relying on the results from Star Wolf.


Quote Originally Posted by Psychonaut View Post
Even 6 Mafia is too much for a game of this size. 5 on the otherhand makes sense. We have 1 Mafia left if this game is balance correctly, which knowing ATPG it is.
We've killed 5 mafiosi so far, so there's at least 6 of them anyway. 6 or even 7 mafia does not strike me as unbalanced with all the powers the townies had.