Pick your power [Concluded]

[Beskar]

I still think Johnhughtom and Pinman especially are being overlooked, since they tried to last minute save Khaan.

vote: Pinman

[Beskar]

Scrap that vote, John is a better choice.

Unvote; Vote: Johnhughthom

John claimed to me being a Universal Back-Up. When he said this, I confronted about him being a back-up of Khaan, however, he told me he only back-up'd abilities, not roles and that he was an investigator.

I was just rechecking the powers list when I noticed what it said.

Universal Backup
You will be given a copy of the first power role eliminated (lynch or night action) in this game. If multiple are killed simultaneously random.org will be used to decide your role.

Therefore, John is a back-up of 'Khaan, therefore, he is a mafia.

There is alternative scenario too. Johnhughthom was a mafia anyway, when 'khaan got killed and he was a mafia, there wasn't any changes. Therefore, when ArgTHIS died, he became a mafia with investigation.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yes, that tantalizing bit of fruit is on my radar. But I'd rather squeeze more results out of him so that if he is indeed a real, townie cop, then we have something for the trouble of his death.

A bit premature methinks, by at least one round, Beskar.

If he is mafia, great, but we would have lynched him anyway in a round or two. If not, I want those results.

[johnhughthom]

Yeah, great. Thanks Beskie.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'd like to note that we have about 10 hours remaining and only three voters.



I'd also like to note that some of you have been online and just aren't voting. That's a recipe for disappointment. Please do not disappoint.

[Pinman]

Sorry :)

Vote: Andres

[Andres]

Scrap that vote, John is a better choice.

Unvote; Vote: Johnhughthom

John claimed to me being a Universal Back-Up. When he said this, I confronted about him being a back-up of Khaan, however, he told me he only back-up'd abilities, not roles and that he was an investigator.

I was just rechecking the powers list when I noticed what it said.


Therefore, John is a back-up of 'Khaan, therefore, he is a mafia.

There is alternative scenario too. Johnhughthom was a mafia anyway, when 'khaan got killed and he was a mafia, there wasn't any changes. Therefore, when ArgTHIS died, he became a mafia with investigation.

There's also another point to consider: the rules don't say that mafia can't get certain roles. This means that the role of back-up can go to a mafioso. So, even if john is saying the truth, the fact that he got the detective role from Arpeg doesn't clear him at all. The back-up role is useful for mafia, so it's perfectly possible that the role went to a mafioso.

I also wonder why he would reveal his role in private?