Quote Originally Posted by Beskar View Post
Scrap that vote, John is a better choice.

Unvote; Vote: Johnhughthom

John claimed to me being a Universal Back-Up. When he said this, I confronted about him being a back-up of Khaan, however, he told me he only back-up'd abilities, not roles and that he was an investigator.

I was just rechecking the powers list when I noticed what it said.


Therefore, John is a back-up of 'Khaan, therefore, he is a mafia.

There is alternative scenario too. Johnhughthom was a mafia anyway, when 'khaan got killed and he was a mafia, there wasn't any changes. Therefore, when ArgTHIS died, he became a mafia with investigation.
There's also another point to consider: the rules don't say that mafia can't get certain roles. This means that the role of back-up can go to a mafioso. So, even if john is saying the truth, the fact that he got the detective role from Arpeg doesn't clear him at all. The back-up role is useful for mafia, so it's perfectly possible that the role went to a mafioso.

I also wonder why he would reveal his role in private?