V&V OOC/Signup Thread I

**_Tristan_** · 04-16-2011, 00:59

Ok, let us wind back to the previous save and forget I ever assaulted Milan... Lothar will just pack and go relieve the siege of Genoa...

Everybody's happy with this ?

**phonicsmonkey** · 04-16-2011, 01:03

Nope, we thought of something better. Much better - no replays, no need to re-write history.

Now I'm in Genoa with you and I'm declaring war. Look forward to the battle.

**Zim** · 04-16-2011, 01:07

Cecil did weigh in on Milan, even if some people disagreed. The ownership thing still confuses me though, and I don't even see how the sacking proceeds rule can be ignored...

Originally Posted by _Tristan_

Ok, let us wind back to the previous save and forget I ever assaulted Milan... Lothar will just pack and go relieve the siege of Genoa...

Everybody's happy with this ?

**Ignoramus** · 04-16-2011, 01:27

Hey guys, sorry for my relative inactivity of late. Uni's been quite busy, but I hope to keep on top of things from now on.

**Zim** · 04-16-2011, 01:32

No harm. I believe Merode is currently marching north towards Brandenburg.

Originally Posted by Ignoramus

Hey guys, sorry for my relative inactivity of late. Uni's been quite busy, but I hope to keep on top of things from now on.

**The Celtic Viking** · 04-16-2011, 01:46

Well, the Margrave requested that he should move to Prague, i.e. Bohemia, but it's possible that he never got the message (I might have missed sending the PM). In any case, the request is now obsolete, as I had planned that he should lead an army from there into Poland, which he now can't do, thank you very much mr Pope.

**_Tristan_** · 04-16-2011, 08:18

Originally Posted by phonicsmonkey

EDIT: here it is

The Prinz and his army enters the city of Genoa and declares war on Lothar Zirn, forcing him to fight for his life.

Not to be nitpicking, but I think this violates rule 7.1 : the declaration of war has to be made before taking the save... But nevermind...

**Zim** · 04-16-2011, 08:38

Good eye. I've been rereading the charter and am still amazed how easily I miss things on the earlier readings.

Although, using the same "does it make sense IC test" for the rules as has been used earlier this turn, there's no reason someone might not hide their hostilities until after entering a city and then start fighting in the streets to depose a rebel.

6.11, 6.12., now 7.1. It's been a rough turn for the Charter. Makes me wonder how active this thread and/or the Diet one would be if PK were still around. I recall he was quite passionate when it came to rules disputes.