Well I'm back early so I can get back into the game!
Vote: Chaotix because of this post
It sounds like someone wants to make sure they know who will be protected and who will be safe to kill.
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Well I'm back early so I can get back into the game!
Vote: Chaotix because of this post
It sounds like someone wants to make sure they know who will be protected and who will be safe to kill.
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
@ God Emperor
Sasaki needs to explain his claim to be a VA killer (that killed Beskar) and a Dr./ protector role that has been protecting pever or himself. Was this just a joke? How can he have both of these abilities. Seems a little too overpowering a role to have from the start of a game. Or was he caught in a lie? Doesn't seem like him to claim any of this so early in a game, a little out of character for him. Or did he explain, and I missed something by scanning the thread?
Sultry Mafia Babe
Diana Abnoba- Goddess of the Hunt
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Vote: Sasaki
Because I still don't trust him.
"Possunt quia posse videntur." - Virgil - "They can because they think they can."
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Good reason to trust Sasaki: He claimed very early in the game (probably too early to just do a townie claim and still have fun) He probably made the kill because no one has counter claimed yet and if someone else made the kill, chances are they would have killed him last night (or at least attempted to kill him...) so Its most likely he is who he said he is
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Yeah, that is a good point.
Sultry Mafia Babe
Diana Abnoba- Goddess of the Hunt
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
fixedOriginally Posted by Diana Abnoba
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
On the most basic level, your logic is sound. However, when you consider this:
-pevergreen has won a duel and been attacked twice, and so far fended off every attacker on him.
-There are more than 60 living players and the chance of a killer hitting a protected one is likely less than 1 in 20.
It becomes incredibly unlikely that I would want someone protecting pevergreen to "waste" a protection and increase my kill chance. The fact is that pever is a full Jedi Knight and therefore significantly more powerful than all of the Jedi Initiates who have been killed (and EVERYONE who's been killed was an Initiate) and likely has an ability or two by now. The mafia will either look for other people to kill so that they can increase their kill rate, OR they will concentrate their efforts on pever to stop him from becoming even more powerful and harder to kill.
So while protecting pever might not be optimal, he is powerful and it's certainly a better deal to pick someone you know you want to stay alive than someone at random.
That said, it sounds like YOU are trying to make it look like you're making an intelligent vote while not actually looking for the guilty party.
Unvote, Vote: Byzantine Knight
Also, on Sasaki- He did not use an active ability last night at all. This means two things:
-He was not Sith last night, because we saw the only living Sith attack pevergreen and I'm going to assume a newly recruited Sith cannot act on the same night he is recruited.
EDIT: Mistake here. There WERE two kill attempts last night. I believe only the one on Zack was confirmed Sith, but I can't be sure. In any case Sasaki did not attempt either of those.
-He is also bluffing about his active protect ability that he used on himself. Difficult to make a call on his claimed vigilante ability.
So the case on Sasaki is no better than the case on anyone who was susceptible to recruitment last night. Take your votes off him.
Last edited by Chaotix; 10-31-2010 at 00:21.
Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer: The Gameroom
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
vote: soup
Seems to be trying too hard to appear town stating the obvious like the death of two townies last night being a bad thing.
Coming Soon to a Gameroom Near You
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
I don't seem to recall peever claiming Jedi Knight but I'll assume that its just a slip up and since you investigated Sasaki this previous night (i guess) then i'm gonna take that as a roleclaim detective...
Which if its true means you arent scummy but I'd just as soon believe the real detective is passing you info for you to post while staying anonymous to be safe from the mafia, which would also be a plus for your credability)
However it just kinda died as you finished your statement... If you could explain how I am "not looking for the guilty party" by making a "seemingly intelligent" case against someone instead of jumping on Sasaki's bandwagon.
but you are right, people, please unvote Sasaki, killing him wont help the town and there is no real case against him
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Challenge: Sasaki...oh wait wrong game
I mean Vote: Sasaki Tie anoyone?!
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Informational warfare, we hardly knew yeHe is also bluffing about his active protect ability that he used on himself.
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
LET'S LYNCH THIS GUY NOW
tally is approx:
13 sasaki
5 yaropolk
but he votes me and pretends like he is going for the tie...
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Askthepizzaguy is having internet connectivity issues and may not be able to do the writeup. Please stop posting at midnight and send in night actions if you would like to do so.
Days since the Apocalypse began
"We are living in space-age times but there's too many of us thinking with stone-age minds" | How to spot a Humanist
"Men of Quality do not fear Equality." | "Belief doesn't change facts. Facts, if you are reasonable, should change your beliefs."
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
I didn't realize it was that bad...
Unvote; Vote:Yaropolk To stop Sasaki from being lynched... no other reason
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Don't want to die by my lightsaber Sasaki? Suit yourself.
unvote
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
I may have my connection back, I had to rejigger the whatchamacallit and reconfigure the doohickey.
Could I have an accurate tally for this round, please?
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
I believe the correct tally is:
Current Leader:
Sasaki (9) - pevergreen, Sigurd, Ignoramus, Ironside, Kagemusha, slysnake, Death is yonder, Diana Abnoba, Belisarius II
Second Place:
Yaropolk (5) - Csargo, Sasaki, Beefy187, ByzantineKnight, Ibn-Khaldun
Third Place:
acompletely inoffensive name (3) - Romanic, Choxorn, Joooray
Joooray (3) - dcmort93, Khazaar, Rebel Jeb
Others
Soup (2) - Renata, Captain Blackadder
ByzantineKnight (2) - Diamondeye, Chaotix
Ignoramus (2) - Sprig, God Emperor
Chaotix (1) - Psychonaut
Diamondeye (1) - Cute Wolf
Yaseikhaan (1) - YLC
Jolt (1) - Jarema
peevergreen (1) - Raskolnikov
Sprig (1) - johnhughthom
Kagemusha (1) - Andres
Cecil XIX (1) - Seon
Ironside (1) - Chaotix
Last edited by ByzantineKnight; 10-31-2010 at 02:53. Reason: Incorrect Tally
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Why the daisy would you lynch Sasaki because he claims being a power role?
The reasoning seems to be that Sasaki would not claim as such if he was a townie, however I don't see why he would do such a thing as a Sith. The game is just starting, and he would know that keeping a pro-town cover. for the next 10 days, is pretty much impossible. We would expect him to vig/protect, but as a Sith he would be hard pressed to have an answer every time.
To me Sasaki is either telling the truth, or throwing out false information to mislead the Sith. Who cares if he's really what he claims? I still see it more likely that he's a tricky townie than a stupid Sith. Some of you are jumping to conclusions way too easily.
I'll stick my vote on candidate #2 because the case on Yaro makes some sense, at least.
unvote; vote: Yaropolk
Last edited by Romanic; 10-31-2010 at 02:44.
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
@BK: your tally is missing Ibn's vote on Yaro (post #512) and Ignoramus has 2 votes against him, which you listed, but didn't increment.
If I'm not mistaken, the current tally is Sasaki 9, Yaropolk 6.
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Sorry about that, i'm glad you checked! Fixed
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
You guys are making a mistake here...
Unvote: Vote: Yarolpolk
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
In an attempt to save Sasaki, Vote: Yaropolk
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
unvote, vote: Yaropolk
as promised.
If God is great, and if God is good, why can't he change the hearts of men?"
-Tom Waits, "The Road to Peace"
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Ouch... I mean... ouch. I dont think there's any role that would say something like that mafia or otherwise... maybe he's a joker?
Being better than the worst does not inherently make you good. But being better than the rest lets you brag.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
but he's a better lynch than someone who has already proven himself protown
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Hemm, no. Pizza isn't big on jokers, thankfully.
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
This vote makes no sense to me, unless you know something the rest of us don't.
Vote: Raskolnikov
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Just Vote: Yaropolk for now, you can go after Rask once Sasaki is safe...
RIP Tosa, I can't believe you are gone, but we will never forget you
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
Yaropolk's post after mine has sealed his fate.
Granted, he probably didn't read it, but still.
Unvote, Vote: Yaropolk
Letting Sasaki get lynched is stupid. I don't particularly think Yaropolk is mafia, but then I don't have enough information to really think anyone is mafia right now.
I'll be keeping an eye on ByzantineKnight, basically I felt you made a scummy post but I can hardly call you more guilty than anyone else here at this stage of the game.
Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer: The Gameroom
Re: Star Wars: Fall of the Order [in play]
To those who are not in the know about abilities, its a weird system, there are no defiend roles. You gain powers at random.
Unvote: Sasaki
How about you start working with me now.
I'm working up a list of those that I can trust.
And whoever said that last page is correct, I've not claimed anything. I'm just a poor little weak newbie jedi.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks