Star Wars: Fall of the Order [Concluded]

[Renata]

LOL.

There I go taking the game all seriously and stuff, and a post like that comes along.

Carry on!

[Kagemusha]

The problem is that you didn't go after Andres until after Andres himself had started complaining that no one was accusing him. You essentially jumped on him just because he drew attention to himself in a humorous manner.



I thought it was obvious that my FOS of Andres was a joke. Andres was complaining of no one suspecting him of anything, so I FOSed him to make him feel better. It was an attempt at humor.

So because Andres is playing humorous game he is above suspicion? Maybe you should take a look at Daggers in the night and see how i played it? It could be that Andres is just messing around, but that does not make him a holy cow, who is above suspicion. I am trying to find mafia and i wont exclude anyone from that search as smart mafia player will use any trick in the book to win a game.
If you want to find mafia try put yourself in their shoes and think how they would react in certain situation. That is my bit of advice to you.

[Beskar]

Don't kill Andres, whatever you do!

[Frozen In Ice]

I find myself highly agreeable with Renata's argument against Vote: dcmort. At the same time I find it odd that Renata was so willing to drop her reasoning, especially considering it makes a lot of sense. For that I am suspicious of Renata. No fingers involved however; I don't find them very suspicious.

[ByzantineKnight]

Vote: Diana Abnoba

Just looking at her posts

[Renata]

Specifics plz.

[Chaotix]

Hrmm....

Are we dropping the Sigurd case so soon?

dcmort's post, as soon as I saw it (and I read the thread from the beginning of the day phase) struck me as very scummy. The case on Kagemusha seems kind of thin, but the subtleties of it may just be escaping me. While I wouldn't go so far as to vote for Andres, I do agree that we need to keep an eye on him and can't just give him a free pass because he's acting silly. I find one of the best ways to deflect serious attention is by acting silly.

So..

Unvote, Vote: dcmort

You may be able to change my mind.

[Beskar]

dcmort is definitely the better choice.

[slysnake]

Hrmm....

Are we dropping the Sigurd case so soon?

dcmort's post, as soon as I saw it (and I read the thread from the beginning of the day phase) struck me as very scummy. The case on Kagemusha seems kind of thin, but the subtleties of it may just be escaping me. While I wouldn't go so far as to vote for Andres, I do agree that we need to keep an eye on him and can't just give him a free pass because he's acting silly. I find one of the best ways to deflect serious attention is by acting silly.

So..

Unvote, Vote: dcmort

You may be able to change my mind.

I agree, the case against Sigurd was flawed from the start, so I vote: dcmort

[Renata]

I can't believe you got killed by an Initiate, Beskar. That's just sad, you know?

slysnake -- why was the case against Sigurd flawed? That *wasn't* what Chaotix implied, by the way. Rather the opposite.

[ByzantineKnight]

Specifics plz.

Bandwagoning mostly but inconsistent behavior as well

[Seon]

Dcmort should find a mortician soon.

[Seon]

Ah ****, I forgot to unvote, Vote dcmort.

[Csargo]

I said "attacks", not "kills". DIY brings up a good point, besides the fact that would make two seperate vigilantes at face value.

Ah, my bad then.

So no one wants to lynch Sigurd then?

Unvote, Vote:YLC

[Renata]

Bandwagoning mostly but inconsistent behavior as well

Specifics plz. :)

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I still wonder why Ignoramus was so concerned about the game being stopped that he posted a thread about it...enjoying being a Sith?

[robbiecon]

First of all can I say ATPG's bribe post was great. Secondly a joke:

"a man walks into a restaurant and orders a bowl of soup.
He says to the waiter 'taste the soup',
'What's wrong is is cold?',
'No just taste the soup' the man replies.
'What is there a fly in it?',
'No, just taste the soup',
'ok, where's the spoon?',
'A-ha, ...A-ha'"

Hope you get the reference, anyway,

vote:soup , even though the tide has turned towards dcmort, I think soup is a more likely candidate.

[Diamondeye]

Er, Diamondeye? I know I'm currently thinking you're a townie and all, but ...

You agree with TinCow's FOS of all those who are going after Andres, but think there's no reason to vote Kagemusha, who is ... going after Andres? Logic, please?

For me, in re Kagemusha, it is that his accusation post appears to ignore the critical difference between acting suspicious and "acting" suspicious. Andres is clearly doing the latter. When Kagemusha says that Andres "should know better", it appears that he's accusing him of the former.

Weird is not scummy. Not by default, anyway. The majority of the time, it's just weird. But heck if scumbags don't like to vote for it.

I agreed with the spirit of TinCow's post; I think it's wrong to jump Andres because of behaviour. That's what I was trying to communicate in quoting TinCow.
To me, Kagemusha doesn't look like scum, even if he did point a finger at Andres. I just think he was a misled townie.

Vote: Diana Abnoba

Just looking at her posts

Specifics plz.

This.

I still wonder why Ignoramus was so concerned about the game being stopped that he posted a thread about it...enjoying being a Sith?

Well spotted, and I wholeheartedly agree. If this game is so precarious to you, Ignoramus, why are we not hearing more from you?

Andres, the case against dcmort can briefly be summed up as...

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Sorry, the real case is of course...

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[robbiecon]

Closer analysis tells me that soup was replaced. Well I guess it's

Unvote; Vote: dcmort then

[wideyedwanderer]

Sorry I'm late.


Vote: robbiecon.

[Rebel Jeb]

Tincow is a sith. I scanned him last night, and found him to be so.

Vote: TinCow

I recommend that Andres, whom he seemed to defend, is one also. Somebody protect me tonight, and I'll scan him to check. If not, I'll be dead, and I'd recommend lynching him anyways.

Umm...yeah. Carry on sirs.

[Seon]

Meh, might as well. unvote, vote: TinCow

[ULC]

How much time do we have left? I haven't placed my vote yet and I need to, but I have no clue where the tally stands and the last thing I want to do is create a tie by accident.

[Beskar]

More votes for dcmort please.

[Rebel Jeb]

More votes for dcmort please.

Yeah, that's a great idea...For sure man....

No.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

yesss, vote tincow. I thought it was bizarre yesterday when he jumped to point out rebel jeb's detective hints.

[naut]

Well. It's a lot better than anything else so far.

unvote, vote: TinCow

FoS: Seon

[Rebel Jeb]

yesss, vote tincow. I thought it was bizarre yesterday when he jumped to point out rebel jeb's detective hints.

Which is why I scanned him. Hit the jackpot. I figured he was going to aim for me in a few nights anyways since he was sith and caught on to what I said, so I figured I'd come out anyways instead of risk dying with the knowledge.

If there are any protectors out there, please protect me tonight. Please please.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

They must have thought I had the town pr and that you were working with me. He was prodding to figure out the connection. Too bad for them they killed me last night instead of you

[Rebel Jeb]

They must have thought I had the town pr and that you were working with me. He was prodding to figure out the connection. Too bad for them they killed me last night instead of you

Silly Sith. :P