Star Wars: Fall of the Order [Concluded]

[Beskar]

Why are you trying to lynch my Sith partner, Diana?

[Choxorn]

Because she must have known that you were a Sith, she would have counted on it, so she clearly cannot choose the wine in front of her.

[pevergreen]

for the sake of completeness!

Not buying it.

Because she must have known that you were a Sith, she would have counted on it, so she clearly cannot choose the wine in front of her.

inconceivable!

I'm happy to change my vote if you reveal to pever and he is satisfied.

She has sent me her name, and single power. Very easily a cover though, no one is cleared by simply revealing.

At this point, neither Diana nor Chaotix should be lynched.

Out of the current choices, WeW is the best, or Frozen. But no one aside from me seems to think he is anything.

[wideyedwanderer]

I do feel inclined to believe you WeW, but at the same time everything you are saying could be very artfully crafted scum.

The real kicker to me voting you is i really dont believe that either iggy or jooray are sith, the case against diana is the same as the one on you but weaker, and i dont even know what the supposed case on chaotix is. os basically i am voting for you because i have seen a case to be made for you being sith when there is no other candidate in my opinion.

You are voting for me because you have seen a case made for me? You are the one who made it. I find it strange that Diana puts up a much less reasonable defense, and you believe it. All she said was, "You guys don't know how to read me." I, on the other hand, have explained to you all of my actions. It could be true, that I am mafia and I have crafted a lie for myself. But wouldn't it have been much easier and safer to have simply been active and lurked since the beginning? Because that is what your mafia have done, and they are delighted that you are spending time on me. Or is it because you, Nightbringer, are mafia yourself?

I am such a convenient distraction right now, I find it highly likely that there is at least one mafia supporting the case against me.

Not buying it.

inconceivable!


She has sent me her name, and single power. Very easily a cover though, no one is cleared by simply revealing.

At this point, neither Diana nor Chaotix should be lynched.

Out of the current choices, WeW is the best, or Frozen. But no one aside from me seems to think he is anything.

Would you like me to send you my name and abilities?

[naut]

But no one aside from me seems to think he is anything.

Frozen is a decent choice, he's backed up a bit since I FoSed him a couple pages back, trying to retreat from the spotlight?

[Askthepizzaguy]

ArpeggiateTHIS2 replaces Link

[pevergreen]

Would you like me to send you my name and abilities?

Sure

Frozen is a decent choice, he's backed up a bit since I FoSed him a couple pages back, trying to retreat from the spotlight?

Yeah, I think something is off with ihm.

[Khazaar]

Vote: TinCow, he replaced Jolt who hasn´t voted in five turns in a row. I presume it´s because of the importance of the role, so I´m hoping that it´s a badguy...

[ArpeggiateTHIS]

Woo, back in!

Vote: Wideeyedwanderer

I'm thinking that WeW needs to reveal to pever, and only if pever is content with the information will I change my vote from him.

[Beefy187]

Frozen is a decent choice, he's backed up a bit since I FoSed him a couple pages back, trying to retreat from the spotlight?

If not Chaotix, Frozen is good for me as well.

[TinCow]

Seems the choice is either WEW or Chaotix now. As such, I will

Unvote; Vote: Chaotix

Furthermore, I think Joooray must be destroyed.

[pevergreen]

Didn't read my post or ignoring it TC.

[Double A]

vote: Joooray.

I'm fairly confident he's the "vig" who used Force lightning.

[autolycus]

Alright, Fearless Dead Leader, unvote, vote:Frozen In Ice

[Diamondeye]

Out of the current choices, WeW is the best

Hmm, no, you're thinking of Sasaki Kojiro.

[Renata]

Frozen is a decent choice, he's backed up a bit since I FoSed him a couple pages back, trying to retreat from the spotlight?

Link to that FOS?

[Renata]

Vote: TinCow, he replaced Jolt who hasn´t voted in five turns in a row. I presume it´s because of the importance of the role, so I´m hoping that it´s a badguy...

You mean as opposed to the half dozen other replacements we've had so far?

[TinCow]

Didn't read my post or ignoring it TC.

Neither. Your post is one of the reasons he still must die. You make it clear that he claims a faction other than Jedi. Third parties are not to be trusted.

[Yaropolk]

Would you like me to send you my name and abilities?

That's a good start. Better do it soon so pever can confirm and we can switch votes.

[Frozen In Ice]

Frozen is a decent choice, he's backed up a bit since I FoSed him a couple pages back, trying to retreat from the spotlight?

I've backed up since I was FOS'd? Is that why I have been posting the same amount and actually had that really long post yesterday? I've just been trying to help the town analyze what we know so far, while many of the people suspicious of me are doing only the reason "he's scummy" without doing any real analysis of their own.

[Nightbringer]

You are voting for me because you have seen a case made for me? You are the one who made it. I find it strange that Diana puts up a much less reasonable defense, and you believe it. All she said was, "You guys don't know how to read me." I, on the other hand, have explained to you all of my actions. It could be true, that I am mafia and I have crafted a lie for myself. But wouldn't it have been much easier and safer to have simply been active and lurked since the beginning? Because that is what your mafia have done, and they are delighted that you are spending time on me. Or is it because you, Nightbringer, are mafia yourself?

I am such a convenient distraction right now, I find it highly likely that there is at least one mafia supporting the case against me.

I'm sorry if I was unclear, it is not simply because there is a case against you (which I did indeed make, but more because there is no case against anyone else as far as I can see. I see your actions as indicative of being a sith, and no one else has convinced me that there is a more likely candidate, even though my conviction about your sithness is not strong.
It would not have been wiser to be active since the beginning because then there would have been many more rounds during which suspicion could have been drawn to you.
And you are accusing me? Isn't that what every scum starts doing when they are about to go?

How about this WeW, why dont you try to make a good case on someone, if you find something really good i might even switch my vote off of you, but until then all i can see in you is a sith trying to save himself

@everyone else
Even if WeW "role reveals" to pever that proves nothing, he could easily give pever his cover role. while i agree it is a good idea to do for the sake of pevers database it means nothing without scanning and cross checking over the next couple nights.

[pevergreen]

Nothing from him yet.

TC: Wrong, I'm saying nothing. But I want neither of them to be lynched today.

edit:

I've backed up since I was FOS'd? Is that why I have been posting the same amount and actually had that really long post yesterday? I've just been trying to help the town analyze what we know so far, while many of the people suspicious of me are doing only the reason "he's scummy" without doing any real analysis of their own.

Really? Because Pyscho had his own thing going, then a few days later I come in and say 'hey whatsup with him' and now like one or two people have agreed/blindly followed me.

Over defence. Scum.

[TinCow]

TC: Wrong, I'm saying nothing. But I want neither of them to be lynched today.

Your TIN has burnt through their blind-faith voting credits. Your group has killed multiple Jedi at night and has made erroneous detective-result accusations which led to lynchings of townies. Your credibility is shot. If you want to convince me that I should change my vote, you're going to have make an actual defense.

[Renata]

That's ... so distorted as to be highly suspicious, TinCow. It's clear there are deliberately misleading and/or confusing investigation results at play in this game. While not exactly surprising, that was always going to cost a townie or three to sort through. Pever's purple-lightsaber person killed Beskar (twice), no townies, IIRC. Joooray says he killed Stuck in Pi on his own initiative; that's also not pever's issue. So at most you can blame pever for ... dcmort? That's not "your group has killed multiple Jedi at night".

Basically, TinCow, you're completely full of it right here. That's not like you.

unvote, vote TinCow

[pevergreen]

What he can blame me for is the Sigurd thing, though Sigurd certainly didn't help with that.

I'm doing the best I can with what I'm given. For never knowing 100% what people are saying, many refusing to give me exact wording, just their interpretation etc.

No, TinCow I will not let you infiltrate the network, ala Netherworld...

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Vote:TinCow


Die!

[naut]

I've backed up since I was FOS'd? Is that why I have been posting the same amount and actually had that really long post yesterday? I've just been trying to help the town analyze what we know so far, while many of the people suspicious of me are doing only the reason "he's scummy" without doing any real analysis of their own.

I FoSed you for your post style, not your post length. You've eased the tone back, but there's still a forceful edge to it. And that, that tweaks my gut.

[Diamondeye]

Your TIN has burnt through their blind-faith voting credits. Your group has killed multiple Jedi at night and has made erroneous detective-result accusations which led to lynchings of townies. Your credibility is shot. If you want to convince me that I should change my vote, you're going to have make an actual defense.

That's ... so distorted as to be highly suspicious, TinCow. It's clear there are deliberately misleading and/or confusing investigation results at play in this game. While not exactly surprising, that was always going to cost a townie or three to sort through. Pever's purple-lightsaber person killed Beskar (twice), no townies, IIRC. Joooray says he killed Stuck in Pi on his own initiative; that's also not pever's issue. So at most you can blame pever for ... dcmort? That's not "your group has killed multiple Jedi at night".

Basically, TinCow, you're completely full of it right here. That's not like you.

unvote, vote TinCow

No, Renata, you're wrong. TinCow is making complete sense.
AoS: Renata

[TinCow]

That's ... so distorted as to be highly suspicious, TinCow.

...

Basically, TinCow, you're completely full of it right here. That's not like you.

If I stretched the facts at all, it was an expression of annoyance at pever's condescending post.

No, TinCow I will not let you infiltrate the network, ala Netherworld...

You misunderstand the point of my post. You need to stop expecting everyone to obey your orders as if they were gospel, which is what this came off as:

Didn't read my post or ignoring it TC.

You need to give arguments and evidence, not just 'vote for X, don't vote for Y'.

[Diamondeye]

I agree completely. I gave pever one chance, gave him another. Until now, no good things have come of it.
It'd be healthy if others grew a critical sense when it comes to what pever does and says and starts thinking for themselves.