[Council of Villains] A State of Corruption [Concluded]

[Romanic]

FoS: Yaraopolk

Pointless, and defending comment.

All we know about cover roles is that TC's looked exactly like his real role. Could be a one off, could not. Anything else is unknown.

Jill Valentine was mentioned in the writeup, so it's likely not a cover role, because those do not appear in writeups.

At least, I don't recall seeing a cover role being part of a writeup, correct me if I am wrong.

[pevergreen]

Jill Valentine was mentioned in the writeup, so it's likely not a cover role, because those do not appear in writeups.

At least, I don't recall seeing a cover role being part of a writeup, correct me if I am wrong.

You're wrong.

Koopa Troop. I, as Donkey Kong, attack Sasaki (Princess Peach). I am blocked from attacking her, by two guards. I am investigated publicly that night (Beefy was an investigator that had his results revealed publicly) and I showed up as my cover role, King Bob-omb.

As for this game, we've not seen anyone with a cover role show up, because no one thats died at night has had one.

[Romanic]

You're wrong.

Koopa Troop. I, as Donkey Kong, attack Sasaki (Princess Peach). I am blocked from attacking her, by two guards. I am investigated publicly that night (Beefy was an investigator that had his results revealed publicly) and I showed up as my cover role, King Bob-omb.

As for this game, we've not seen anyone with a cover role show up, because no one thats died at night has had one.

What I meant is that when someone is attacked at night, I don't recall seeing the writeup using the cover role name.

To be clearer, let's say that Beskar would have Jill Valentine as a cover role, but in fact would be Ugly Bad Guy.... I think the writeup would say:

Ugly Bad Guy was attacked (and survived).

and not...

Jill Valentine was attacked (and survived).

I don't recall seeing a writeup showing that the cover role was attacked.

When it comes to investigations (public or not), it's typical to have some players protected against them, and return a cover role instead of the true identity, so I don't consider your example to be good. I still believe that Jill Valentine cannot be a cover role, because she was attacked and the writeup said so.

[pevergreen]

I don't recall seeing a writeup showing that the cover role was attacked.

Point me to someone being attacked (and killed, since beskar is still alive) that has had a cover role, in this game.

[Double A]

Motep mentioned that (all?) mafia had the ability to kill one of their voter in the previous instances of "Council of Vilains".

1) Is this true?
2) Did every mafia player have this ability, or only a few (or only one)?
3) Could scum partners be killed if they were voting for the lynchee?

I'm too lazy to look for this myself. Particularly interested in answer #3.

Hey I found a post that was gobbeled up in the Pizza/Sasaki post parade!

In Koopa Troop, there wasn't a single character who killed people when they were lynched. I think. There was a joker, but nothing else like that.

[TinCow]

BlahbLahblAhblaHBlahbLahblAhblaHBlahbLahblAhblaH

Can't you people stop talking and just lynch someone? I think I can speak for both Dark Samus and Samus on this one...

I got a fever, and the only prescription...is more KILLLLLLLLL!!!!(*)




(*) Desire for murder does not apply to wonderful townies who love their mafia allies. We want to hug them instead.

[God Emperor]

If anyone have a tally at hand, could they post it ?