Quote Originally Posted by Romanic View Post
Uh, I'll have to re-read the Winston vs Beskar debate to get a better idea of things, but killing Winston tonight? I don't know... I thought that Autolycus gave us a good alternative.

He's fairly certain that Frozen in Ice is on the Samus team, based on stuff that he cannot discuss. It looks like a good lead to follow.

My pick for the Pizza kill would be Frozen in Ice, even if he has not answered the accusation. I trust that Autolycus wouldn't have posted this, phrasing it how he did, if his reasons weren't good enough.
I do feel this is a very important point. But I feel quite wary of pulling the trigger blindly on Frozen, even based on a dead townie hunch. Still, you're right, there's basically no reason I shouldn't act on that. I am only weighing my options.

I feel the Winston lead is more pressing, and I feel the Frozen lead should get a full vote, not just me shooting him.

Quote Originally Posted by TinCow View Post
Spare his life so that he can lynch Samus tomorrow.

Mafia fratricide FTW!
This still feels like a mafia bluff. Will consider, yet probably ignore.

If he's the last member of your team, he's not got long for this world regardless, because he's angrying up the blood of a bunch of other factions IMO.

Quote Originally Posted by Captain Blackadder View Post
Well as to whether he should die tonight rests on who the other target is going to be. I say don't kill him but have a very close look at both him and Beskar because if both of them are town I will eat my hat. One of them is scum possibly both of them.
Beskar is holding something back, but after talking with him, I don't believe he's mafia.


*new information*


And, I also know this: Winston is absolutely lying about something, or he's mafia, or both; or Beskar is.

Between the two of them, Winston has more to prove. If he comes up townie, Beskar has a LOT of explaining to do. And honestly, Winston does too, because he has been caught in a lie about something, or he would do his townie duty.

Beskar knows he's lying for reasons I won't go into. Winston bluffed, and was caught in the bluff.



I will be killing Winston Hughes tonight, for certain. If I die, Beskar must explain why I have done these actions. If Winston comes up townie, Beskar must be pressured, but not just him; I'd like to know from Winston why he was lying. It doesn't make sense.