Org Mobile Site
vote:DiamondEye
@robbiecon, my vote for Jooray never counted anyway, plus this is the vote I really wanted to have happen, but I realised it was never going to happen, so it hopefully going to happen now.
@robbiecon, my vote for Jooray never counted anyway, plus this is the vote I really wanted to have happen, but I realised it was never going to happen, so it hopefully going to happen now.
Originally Posted by :
vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
Winston, are you only able to say "Snarf" and vote? Could anyone with greater knowledge on the Southpark universe elaborate on whether its possibly an IC compulsion, or whether it could be just a tactic to get by the game while saying little?vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
Originally Posted by :
Ah yes Robbie, I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills, made a chart, compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular, but I think I am still going to vote for Vote: Diamondeye. Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
If your reasoning is based on that early game situation with GE and vote switching, I don't know about you, but this is what I thought about that situation early game, just reiterating.Ah yes Robbie, I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills, made a chart, compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular, but I think I am still going to vote for Vote: Diamondeye. Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
Originally Posted by :
I think that it is likely that if DE was vote switching to save CB, he would have continued voting autolycus, rather than switch randomly to JHT. Unless he was trying to save auto then, but as he said, it would be rather weird if he voted his mafia partner just to switch out at the last moment.
IMO didn't feel to me like he was trying to pop in to save his scum buddy, especially now that CB was night killed and it would be rather silly to interact with autolycus like that in the early game. Unless you have a gut feeling you would care to elaborate on. I think its a cheap cop-out vote.I think that it is likely that if DE was vote switching to save CB, he would have continued voting autolycus, rather than switch randomly to JHT. Unless he was trying to save auto then, but as he said, it would be rather weird if he voted his mafia partner just to switch out at the last moment.
Vote: Seon
Originally Posted by :
If the second half of this day is anywhere near as quiet as the first, we're in big trouble. Come on folks, wake up and take positions. Please!
If the second half of this day is anywhere near as quiet as the first, we're in big trouble. Come on folks, wake up and take positions. Please!
Originally Posted by Death is yonder:
Winston, are you only able to say "Snarf" and vote?
No, I can Snarf normally. Just so long as I remember to Snarf Snarf. Winston, are you only able to say "Snarf" and vote?
Otherwise I'll Snarf.
Any reason for the vote on Seon, DiY? I'll give the thread a once over after I've had some sleep.
Well for starters, Seon seemed convinced of Diamondeye's guilt based on in thread analysis reasons.
IMO, with retrospective knowledge, CB was night killed, and hence innocent, and the only reason for DE to have been voting Autolycus if he was his mafia partner would be to distance both of them.
However, I don't think that if a mafia was trying to distance himself from his partner, he would change his vote last minute. I do believe that Diamondeye is at the very least a good player as mafia, and this last minute vote changing which did cause a lot of attention that would definitely be unwanted as a mafia (and avoided in the first place).
Additionally, Autolycus's behavior does not seem scummy, so I'm disinclined to think that DE is scum for those reasons (AKA popped in to save his partner)
All of these combined with Seon's stated reason implied as being "in thread analysis", makes me think its a cheap excuse to be voting DE, maybe hopping onto a free vote to get by the round and survive.
OTOH I could be wrong on some of these accounts, which is why I asked him to elaborate further if it was a gut feeling (like posts that tweaked his gut etc)
Quick summary because I need to go out for dinner and probably won't be back in time to answer anymore questions soon:
Seon says that it is through in thread analysis that he strongly believes DE to be guilty. My take on the matter is that the thread stuff doesn't seem to shout "DE is scum" that strongly as Seon claimed once you re-examine the logic behind the actions in retrospect. So I think that Seon's vote is an excuse to get by the round because the reasoning behind it is flawed.
I hope that will suffice, do feel free to inquire more should you see fit.
Originally Posted by :
I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills
I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills
Originally Posted by :
Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
From my perspective, the main thing that one would take a look at in relation to Diamondeye if specifically re-reading to analyze every player (which seon said he did) would be that of the last minute vote switch in the first round, concerning him, GE, as well as Autolycus.Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
IMO, with retrospective knowledge, CB was night killed, and hence innocent, and the only reason for DE to have been voting Autolycus if he was his mafia partner would be to distance both of them.
However, I don't think that if a mafia was trying to distance himself from his partner, he would change his vote last minute. I do believe that Diamondeye is at the very least a good player as mafia, and this last minute vote changing which did cause a lot of attention that would definitely be unwanted as a mafia (and avoided in the first place).
Additionally, Autolycus's behavior does not seem scummy, so I'm disinclined to think that DE is scum for those reasons (AKA popped in to save his partner)
All of these combined with Seon's stated reason implied as being "in thread analysis", makes me think its a cheap excuse to be voting DE, maybe hopping onto a free vote to get by the round and survive.
OTOH I could be wrong on some of these accounts, which is why I asked him to elaborate further if it was a gut feeling (like posts that tweaked his gut etc)
Quick summary because I need to go out for dinner and probably won't be back in time to answer anymore questions soon:
Seon says that it is through in thread analysis that he strongly believes DE to be guilty. My take on the matter is that the thread stuff doesn't seem to shout "DE is scum" that strongly as Seon claimed once you re-examine the logic behind the actions in retrospect. So I think that Seon's vote is an excuse to get by the round because the reasoning behind it is flawed.
I hope that will suffice, do feel free to inquire more should you see fit.
Umm... I never said that it was through in-thread analysis?
What part of "and came up with nothing in particular" do you not understand?
I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
What part of "and came up with nothing in particular" do you not understand?
I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
Google snarf, Diy.
Originally Posted by Seon:
if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
Statisstically speaking, it's a good bet (I mean, I am the player who is mofia most often), but it's going to hurt. You'll want to keep some ice handy.if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
Snarf. Vote:WHvote: Death is yonder
Snarf
Originally Posted by Seon:
I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
Another hard-to-deny argument:I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Originally Posted by Seon:
Umm... I never said that it was through in-thread analysis?
What part of "and came up with nothing in particular" do you not understand?
I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
When I looked at that post of yours, this seemed to be the phrasing:Umm... I never said that it was through in-thread analysis?
What part of "and came up with nothing in particular" do you not understand?
I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
Originally Posted by :
compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular
Rather than the whole paragraph.compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular
Apologies then
Originally Posted by :
I just want to know whether I can skip the commitment if noone'll be listening anyway.
If everyone who was dead just kept totally silent, and especially so in a small game, it would be pretty darn silent, and less fun too :/I just want to know whether I can skip the commitment if noone'll be listening anyway.
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO