The Half Monty [Concluded]

[Romanic]

Here's a list of robbie's posts, for reference, after the game started, and before he died. There's only 7 of them.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Post #1 - Day 1

Aruba, Jamaica, oo I wanna take ya,
to Bermuda, Bahama, come on pretty mama
Vote: Csargo, Montego, baby why don't we go
down to Kokomo,
get there fast
and then we'll take it slow
that's where we wanna go,
way down to Kokomo.

Post #2 - Day 2

You better think twice before attacking Marjorie Simpson (nee Bouvier). I'll have my pan, and whatever else I can lay my hands on at the ready.

Now, I don't think Zack is the person who attacked me last night, but it's clear from my poor Bart being brutally picked upon yesterday that someone is out to kill us Simpsons.

So I'm gonna have to go with Vote: thefluffyone93

Post #3 - Day 2

Well, might I just say that Grampa Simpson, Hans Moleman and Jasper Beardly could potentially be candidates for older people in this game, However, I am unaware if either Hans or Jasper were war vets. It is likely that Grampa Simpson is the only one of these three in this game, but one of the others could potentially be here, it really depends on askthepizzaguy's preferences.

Post #4 - Day 2

Ok, I know who you are now.

your ass is mine : quote from the Principal in Ferris Bueller's Day Off.

And Skinner is a Vietnam war vet.

Post #5 - Day 3

I have been reading the thread on my iPod, but writing isn't much fun on it.

Ok, well we have zack, who I firmly believe is being framed, and a dead obvious one at that. Slashandburn, well I do not see the sense in that either, where exactly did that come from? And fluffy is just a continuation from yesterday.

I'm thinking we should perhaps vote for Romanic, he's really taken control of the game, what with posting vote counts etc. Perhaps he's trying to emphasise who is currently being voted for, so that those who haven't voted yet just go for those with more votes. Also he voted for zack after Yaropolk, even stating that it seemed too easy a set up but going with it anyway.

I won't vote for Romanic at this venture, as it is merely speculation, but if I , Marge should be attacked again, I'd like if you could lynch him. Also he's one of those who hasn't really implied who he is, while many have hinted.

Post #6 - Day 4

Vote: classical_hero

I remain sure that Zack is innocent.

Post #7 - Day 5

It is possible that Willie is mafia, but I wouldn't be out and out convinced of it.

The random vote on Csargo was somewhat necessary given the lack of information, even though many people have seemed scummy at various times.

I'll vote: Captain Blackadder.

Post #8 - Day 5

3rd on the bandwagon, eh, Romanic?

Unvote; Vote: Romanic

We shall see what night brings.

Post #1 : His Day 1 vote, on Csargo. Resulting tally was (DE 2, Fluffy 2, GE 1, CB 1, robbie 1, Yaro 1, Renata 1, Csargo 1)
He didn't care about the tally leaders, or he might have voted for someone with a vote already. We know that DE & Fluffy were innocent. The vote on Csargo may as well be a distancing tactic, as much a vote on an innocent. I'm tempted to give some creds to Csargo, but not much.

Post #2 : His Day 2 vote, on Fluffy. Resulting tally was (Zack 3, Fluffy 3, Renata 1, slashandburn 1, Khazaar 1, GE 1)
It lookied like he was trying to help Zack, but we know that he was Chief Wiggum. I don't think there's anything else to get from this vote.

Post #3 : Two posts before Robbie made this one, Yaropolk voted Captain Blackadder, calling on a false claim because he was acting like an old man, when Csargo was already roleplaying an old man. Here's Yaro's post,

CB comes out early on and claims to be a war vet. Immediately Grandpa Simpson comes to mind.

Csargo repeatedly comes out with rambling old man stories. Grandpa also comes to mind here. Csargo comes back with this claim multiple times, and CB doesn't speak up after this. I think CB tried to do a false claim early on then bit his tongue.

Vote: Captain Blackadder

CB, if there is another war vet character, then speak up now.

So Robbie, in post #3, points out that there could be more than one old men in the game, mentioning two other possibilities. It looks like he's trying to help Captain Blackadder, trying to dissuade Yaro that CB is suspect for being an old man.

CB replied quickly after,

Now son that is no way to speak to a vet I know you can read my thoughts. Just remember, if I find out you are mafia, your ass is mine. Yes, you heard me. I think words I would never say. Don't just think of World War II there have being more wars.

Post #4 : After CB's last post, Robbie made post #4, stating that he recognized CB as Skinner. Protecting him again, and it worked, Yaro unvoted him soon after. CB looks bad here.

Post #5 : Interesting post, because robbie says a lot.

1) He's posting from his iPod (we should have picked on that one!!!! Only scums are posting from cells. )
2) He thinks Zack is obviously being framed (we know Zack was innocent).
3) He doesn't see any reason to vote for slashandburn (slashandburn, replaced by Diamondeye 2, is still alive).
4) Perhaps we should vote Romanic, for taking control of the game with vote counts. He's gunning for me with a bad argument.

It's interesting that he didn't vote though. This was late on Day 3, and the running tally was (Zack 3, slashandburn 3, Fluffy 2, Renata 1). His no-vote implies that he didn't care whether Zack or slashandburn (now DE2) would be lynched. If one of his partners was threatened, I think he would have voted, so this gives me a good feeling about Diamondeye.

Post #6 : His Day 4 vote, against classical_hero. It doesn't mean anything now, as everyone who received votes on that day is dead and innocent.

Post #7 : His Day 5 vote, for Captain Blackadder. Resulting tally was (pever 3, Csargo 1, CB 1)
Looks like robbie doesn't care about lynching pevergreen, or he would have voted Csargo (* unless they're both his partners, of course).

Post #8 : Day 5 vote, take two. He voted for me, for being 3rd on the God Emperor bandwagon. This vote ended up reversed because ATPG missed the deadline and cancelled votes that were made after. However I'm guessing that nobody knew it would be reversed, so his reaction means something.
The resulting tally was : GE 3, Csargo 1, pever 1, Fluffy 1, Romanic 1. If Robbie cared about GE being lynched, he would have voted Csargo/pever/Fluffy instead of me (who had no vote). GE looks good here.


tl;dr version (if you can't be bothered to read):

Good
Diamondeye looks good after post #5.
God Emperor looks good after post #8.
pevergreen looks good after post #7 (unless Csargo is also scum, meaning Csargo should be lynched before pever, to validate).
Dunno
Csargo looks marginally good, after post #1, but it good be a distancing tactic.
Yaropolk. No interaction with robbie, except that he voted for CB, and was convinced to unvote by CB & robbie.
Nightbringer had no interaction with robbie at all.
Bad
Captain Blackadder looks bad (post #3 & #4). Unclear after post #7.

vote: Captain Blackadder

I'm voting him, for the posts #3 & #4, because robbie helped him, and on the assumption that post #7 might have been a distancing tactic by robbie.

I think Csargo and Nightbringer are okay choices, and that we shouldn't lynch Yaropolk before CB.