does naginata = ashigeru? from the smith armour/attack bonus point of view.

[al Roumi]

just to clear up the mystery, my naginata monks do not get the armour bonus that my sword samurai get, so the bonus is quite unit specific.

is there a list of smith bonuses from the various provinces that have them, including the units those bonuses are specific to?

Hmm. My monks DO get the weapon/attack bonus - the same as my Yari or Katana Samurai and Yari ashigaru.