Music Mafia [Concluded]

[Secura]

No I don't.

Alright, any reason why? Since Believer's already on my radar, is there any reason that you particularly suspect classical_hero?

Why would a mafia claim mafia?

It's been done several times before, myself included; it's hella risky, but then that's the Xanatos Gambit for you.

[Visor]

It's been done several times before, myself included; it's hella risky, but then that's the Xanatos Gambit for you.

I wouldn't consider it myself. I see no gain from doing it. Joking around, yeah, but not seriously. Xanatos Gambit?

Alright, any reason why?

Yeah. Lemme go through his posts.

Since Believer's already on my radar, is there any reason that you particularly suspect classical_hero?

Gotta go through to remind myself.

[Visor]

So much for Walk of Life for johnhughthom.

I got nothing.

Ok, we already got the idea that you're Lady Gaga. The real question is, would she be evil? Certainly she'd be in the DJ's favour, I imagine.

From the Lady Gaga lyrics Secura was spewing, a reasonable conclusion to make. The last statement seems reasonable as well.

Is Believer one of The Killers?

In response to Believer posting lyrics. Again, nothing bad here.

Vote:Secura, you've a lot of questions to answer. For one, who are you? You've been lying to us so far.

His hypothesis proven wrong, he believes that the he was lied to. Again, a reasonable conclusion to make in my mind.

Roger Daltrey, I presume?

I can't remember.

Why lie though Secura, why pretend to be something you're not?

I could easily say we could just Let It Be, but I can also confirm, I am not Paul McCartney.

Honestly, nothing strikes me as out of place.

I think what we've got here is a scum, who implied to be something else, but either her or her buddy accidentally popped the very person she was imitating. You did not explicitly say anything, but let's face it, quoting lyrics, very much seems to be suggesting who you are, a la soft claim. That is why I am voting you, as you lead us down the garden path. Tell us who you really are, and I'll consider lifting my vote.

Pushes Secura again. Still believes that lyrics were a soft claim. (I do believe you were leading us down a garden path Secura.)

Let's face it, if I had been quoting Johnny Cash lyrics, for example, obviously that would be the person you'd believe I am.

I'd probably have been throwing hints as to who I am, except for the fact I only know one song by him.

Pushes lyrics as a soft claim.

I just think Visorslash is wearing the crazy hat, and a sign saying "lynch me, lynch me", just so he can save someone else's skin.

Thinks Visor is scum, trying to save someone else. Was wrong, but not a bad conclusion.

Radiohead = Karma Police = Visorslash's role makes perfect sense.

Vote: Csargo, let's mix things up a bit.

Believes Visor's detective claim due to person. Votes the same person as Visor.

[Visor]

Honestly, he's done nothing to make me think he's scum. I think he's town.

[johnhughthom]

Maybe I should play like JHT and say absolutely nothing, I would last longer? Or I would lynched for not contributing?

There's a fine line between saying absolutely nothing and saying enough to survive. Are you good enough?

You're quite promising, but it's not like there's no room for improvement.

Pizza doesn't think so.

[Visor]

There's a fine line between saying absolutely nothing and saying enough to survive. Are you good enough?

Probably not. (Sorry for saying that though. I hear people saying that lurkers should be lynched, and you post just enough to stay alive. :P) Staying quiet isn't the way I am in something like this.

Pizza doesn't think so.

???

[TheLastDays]

Well Pizza claimed to be Mafia all the time during the Campground and, while he wasn't Mafia, none of the town knew this, still he wan't lynched so as Mafia he would've gotten by with it very well...

And it would have been a hell of a win if he were Mafia, I bet he still grudges that he wasn't ^^

So, it does work sometimes or it can work for your favour, even as Mafia

[Visor]

He joked around that he was mafia. (As did I). Or at least that is how I see it anyway.

ATPG votes himself a lot though.

[TheLastDays]

Exactly, he did what you did and got away with it, so if he had been Mafia it would have worked... it's a risky strategy of course but it can work obviously...

[Visor]

I took it too far. :P

Though claiming scum as a joke isn't too risky. Even if scum. I did it in atpg's game with diamond eye a couple of times.

[TheLastDays]

Well the thing is, I don't think it's ever worth doing as town... the chance the townies lynch you (and waste a lynch on you) just "to be safe" is too high.

[Secura]

robbiecon's playing a largely conservative game; he's posting short questions and statements to maintain the appearance of involvement and he's remaining non-confrontational by keeping his accusations to a minimum unless there's already prior reasoning for a bandwagon vote (Day Two), otherwise throwing his vote on pointless targets (Day Three).

It actually reminds me of what I call the 'consummate townie', as I noted in Pizza's Murder Manor III game when YLC largely stayed under everyone's radar by playing in this manner.

As for being led down the garden path, all I can say now is get over it; my detractors inferred something from my post and were wrong in doing so. I had no intentions to mislead and I'll be reiterating that when my role is revealed when I die or when the game ends.

[Chaotix]

Well the thing is, I don't think it's ever worth doing as town... the chance the townies lynch you (and waste a lynch on you) just "to be safe" is too high.

To be sure, nobody wants to be lynched as scum because they "jokingly" claimed to be scum in-thread.

But at the same time, you act too much like how a townie 'should' act, and people start to get suspicious of you for that- basically what Secura's case on robbiecon is right now.

Currently, no matter what my role is, I tend to say whatever I want in-thread regardless of possible town or mafia implications. If I act like I don't care about the outcome of the game, I find it helps to make me a bit more unreadable.

[TheLastDays]

Well but I do care what the outcome of the game is, regardless of me being Mafia or Town...

but as Andres demanded in ATPGs case in the Campground, most of the time people will lynch the guy claiming he's Mafia just because it would hurt too much if he was actually Mafia and the town lets him live...

[Diamondeye]

MOVING ON....

This. I'm glad lots of people are willing to teach Visorslash the game, but I would appreciate not cluttering the thread unless it's relevant for the game. Thank you

[Believer]

Damned if we did, damned if we didn't. A liar was as good as anything.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Damned if we did, damned if we didn't. A liar was as good as anything.

FoS: Believer

Kicking the man when he's down, dead, and townie. Totally unnecessary and uncharacteristic of you in particular.

[Visor]

And I wasn't lying. At least to my knowledge.

But you just drew a lot of suspiscion to yourself.

[Diamondeye]

Music Mafia
NIght three ends...

Chaotix was sitting alone, plinging his guitar, his coarse voice the only noise in the otherwise silent studio. He hardly noticed the unknown figure sneaking up on him. Before he knew it, it had struck him over the head with its weapon. He fell prone to the floor.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Chaotic was Eric Clapton!

He was of good popularity and of neutral favor to the DJ!

Players alive (11):
TheLastDays
Renata
Romanic
AskThePizzaGuy
Robbiecon
Csargo
Secura
Classical_Hero
Spl1tPersonality
Captain Blackadder
Believer


It is now day four!
This day will last until 10 PM CEST the day after tomorrow, because of the delayed writeup.
This means voting will close in roughly 43 hours!

[Captain Blackadder]

You don't like Eric Clapton?

[Romanic]

Neutral favor is generous for Eric Clapton in my opinion.

[johnhughthom]

You don't like Eric Clapton?

Don't you have to be over 45 to like him?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: Splitpersonality

[Captain Blackadder]

Don't you have to be over 45 to like him?

Don't have to be over 45 to appreciate quality look at that guitar playing

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OLK...eature=related

[Csargo]

Vote: Splitpersonality

I thought we had moved past this point.

[Splitpersonality]

Vote: Splitpersonality

Okay.

But why?

[B-Wing]

I love Cream, but Eric Clapton on his own = boring.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Okay.

But why?

Because you're guilty, that's why.

[johnhughthom]

I love Cream, but Eric Clapton on his own = boring.

Tears in Heaven is good, rather a high price to pay for the inspiration to write it though.

[Splitpersonality]

Really?

Okay.

Vote: Splitpersonality