Music Mafia [Concluded]

[Secura]

I may be new to the game, but I ain't too stupid to realise that I'm right here.

Day 2, hardly ever has strong choices. That's not naive, that's pretty close to fact.

I didn't say that you were stupid, treacle; you can find strong choices on Day One, it's all dependent on reading between the lines and understanding other players. I can recall a certain player who accurately identified three scummers by Night Two based upon their behaviour up to that point... and that was in a large game.

Let's face it, if I had been quoting Johnny Cash lyrics, for example, obviously that would be the person you'd believe I am.

This stance doesn't surprise me given your answers to my little questionnaire in Animus... never assume, especially in circumstances like this, because there's always an inevitable "told you so" waiting for you; I will be taking Believer and Split's lyric posting with a pinch of salt, rather than assuming they're Brandon Flowers, Roger Daltrey or whoever else.

Hopefully you'll follow that advice for Day Three.

[Visor]

I didn't say that you were stupid, treacle; you can find strong choices on Day One, it's all dependent on reading between the lines and understanding other players. I can recall a certain player who accurately identified three scummers by Night Two based upon their behaviour up to that point... and that was in a large game.

One game? How many games of mafia have happened like that? Not many, I would assume.

[Splitpersonality]

One game? How many games of mafia have happened like that? Not many, I would assume.

I believe what Secura is trying to say is that simply because at the start of games it is usually hard to nail scum it doesn't mean it's an excuse to make poor choices.

edit @Secura

Anytime

[Visor]

I believe what Secura is trying to say is that simply because at the start of games it is usually hard to nail scum it doesn't mean it's an excuse to make poor choices.

I'm saying that I don't believe we have any strong choices. Literally nothing has happened that could allow there to be.

I remember in a recent game, I nailed a scum who used P.I.S. They didn't believe me, tried to lynch me the next day, I survived, and only due to robbiecon revealing, did they finally believe me.

One example, but there's been other games where the mafia have been pinned down early based on their activities in the opening stages of the game; that one was merely fresh in the memory because it was a game I hosted and the last one that I actively read.

Same thing, see above. :D

@ Secura

The day ain't over yet, so I don't know why you're saying it's a foregone conlcusion.

But regardless, activity is good.

Unvote; Vote: Astain for lack of a choice.

[Secura]

I'm saying that I don't believe we have any strong choices. Literally nothing has happened that could allow there to be.

Well, that's slightly contradictory; there's at least three votes against me, which would suggest that we do have a strong choice for the lynch, no?

[Visor]

Only two now. You did set yourself up there. (Rather unlucky, but still.)

3 is not a strong choice when we have this many players.

@ Renata

Why?

[Splitpersonality]

Well, that's slightly contradictory; there's at least three votes against me, which would suggest that we do have a strong choice for the lynch, no?

Unless we're all just voting willy nilly

[Secura]

The day ain't over yet, so I don't know why you're saying it's a foregone conlcusion.

Even if you spared me from the lynch now, someone would only bring me up as a possible candidate at a later time, which is terrible when numbers dwindle and each lynch becomes more important; so, if there's any suspicion as to my role, then it's better to get rid of me now rather than leave me alive and have the hard choice come up later.

Of course, that's if the mafia leave me alive as lynchbait rather than outright kill me.

[Visor]

someone would only bring me up as a possible candidate at a later time

Everyone who is alive will no doubt, so that isn't really important.

On another note, what mistakes have I made that makes you think I'm town?

[Seon]

EVERYBODY VOTE VISORSLASH RIGHT NOW.

[Visor]

Unvote; Vote: Visorslash

[Visor]

Even if you spared me from the lynch now, someone would only bring me up as a possible candidate at a later time, which is terrible when numbers dwindle and each lynch becomes more important; so, if there's any suspicion as to my role, then it's better to get rid of me now rather than leave me alive and have the hard choice come up later.

Of course, that's if the mafia leave me alive as lynchbait rather than outright kill me.

I'm that someone. So... let's kill Secura. :P

Actually I'd like some pressure on Romanichine. So can you guys put some on him? I'm kinda dead.

[Secura]

I'm that someone. So... let's kill Secura.

I am really looking forward to saying "I told you so" once I'm dead/this game ends.

[Secura]

One game? How many games of mafia have happened like that? Not many, I would assume.

One example, but there's been other games where the mafia have been pinned down early based on their activities in the opening stages of the game; that one was merely fresh in the memory because it was a game I hosted and the last one that I actively read.

You asked for my opinion on who to lynch, and I gave it; I believe that they're valid choices, and hope that you'll consider them as such once my alignment and role has been revealed. :3

I believe what Secura is trying to say is that simply because at the start of games it is usually hard to nail scum it doesn't mean it's an excuse to make poor choices.

What I'm trying to say is that I've seen enough from robbiecon and Believer to suggest that they'd be strong choices for pressuring with votes in the next day phase, since this one is a forgone conclusion.