Mafia X [Concluded]

[Populus Romanus]

About Johnny: So now you're a townie by not defending yourself against false accusations?

I was going to unvote and vote for Richie, but never got around to it. I wouldn't say Anne isn't scum, but other people are better lynches. Like Richie. What is this about him claiming he has a "special power?" Because this is a vanilla game, the only special power he could have is to murder people. He has to be lying.

[[MAFIA] Sonny]

I was going to unvote and vote for Richie, but never got around to it. I wouldn't say Anne isn't scum, but other people are better lynches. Like Richie. What is this about him claiming he has a "special power?" Because this is a vanilla game, the only special power he could have is to murder people. He has to be lying.

Course he's lyin. That's the whole point, if Richie's a townie. Toss out a pile of cow as been dressed up to look like apple pie, an see who comes in an laps it up. If Richie's a mafia, he don't expect to be believed, he expect the rest of us decide a scum won't do like that.

[[MAFIA] Fat Tony]

I operate with a "lynch all liars" mindset. And since when is making yourself look really scummy a townie tactic?

If Richie's a mafia, he don't expect to be believed, he expect the rest of us decide a scum won't do like that.

Gee, that sounds like a good reason to vote for him then. What he wrote did nothing to help the town. So either he's an extremely unhelpful, and lying, townie, or he's a mafioso planning on us thinking no mafioso would do that.


I'm surprised that not joining bandwagons is an issue now. I was generally trying to vote for people who weren't bandwagoned, so as to pressure other people to talk.

But I guess you're just fond of selecting a target and having everyone vote for them. Odd, too, how valiantly you leap to Richie's defense.


@Anne - it's not my fault I'm fat! It's a glandular disorder!

[[MAFIA] Anne]

Maybe your glandular disorder also makes you kill people.

Come talk to Anne about it. I promise I won't catch you in a butterfly net and give you to the men in the white coats. No, never.


I'll shoot you before that happens.

[Centurion1]

sigh i guess i just have to wait for the end of the game for you people to realize i am not scum.

[[MAFIA] Sonny]

For myself, chubs, I'm jus laughin you missed the part where I called YOU a liar.

[[MAFIA] Angelo]

Well I certainly think one of the Mafia is already dead which means we have 3 lynches left before the remaining scumbag wins so let's avoid rushing into things now...

[[MAFIA] Richie]

I operate with a "lynch all liars" mindset. And since when is making yourself look really scummy a townie tactic?

Mafia strategy in this game is simple.
They can either follow the influential players like a sheep or, they can control the discussion them selves.
They don't need to gamble. Mafias are... or should be extra careful of what they say. So if you find a scummy post, I would say they are more likely to be town just making a mistake.

For the town, not being able to do the usual play style analysis and not knowing who is guilty and who wasn't, only real strategy is talking a lot, analyzing kills and maybe spontaneous bandwagon.

If we don't have anyone good to vote for I suggest on leaving things on chance.
We ask one of the seemingly innocent player to random org the remaining players. And lynch who ever the random org chooses.
This way, our votes won't get purposefully manipulated by the mafia to lynch the innocent.

[[MAFIA] Angelo]

Mafia strategy in this game is simple.
They can either follow the influential players like a sheep or, they can control the discussion them selves.
They don't need to gamble. Mafias are... or should be extra careful of what they say. So if you find a scummy post, I would say they are more likely to be town just making a mistake.

For the town, not being able to do the usual play style analysis and not knowing who is guilty and who wasn't, only real strategy is talking a lot, analyzing kills and maybe spontaneous bandwagon.

If we don't have anyone good to vote for I suggest on leaving things on chance.
We ask one of the seemingly innocent player to random org the remaining players. And lynch who ever the random org chooses.
This way, our votes won't get purposefully manipulated by the mafia to lynch the innocent.

Might work... let's ask one of the night killed though. We can trust them more than any living player :P

no, seriously, I have my suspects, going to lay out the case later.

[Earthling]

There's some pretty simple cases, on top of what's been said before in many instances this is really enough. Luigi has been killing people at night who could show up and vote Luigi. Townies who are doing horribly and are already committed to not voting Luigi didn't get killed. Though the same could go a bit for Anne, maybe Angelo in explaining the kills, or for completeness' sake Sonny, though the latter looks really Innocent obviously. Everybody else is indistinguishably lurkery and unlikely to account for the nightkills, or even lower priority because they are clearly Innocent or not worth a lynch right now.

[White_eyes:D]

For the town, not being able to do the usual play style analysis and not knowing who is guilty and who wasn't, only real strategy is talking a lot, analyzing kills and maybe spontaneous bandwagon.

A real shame the only one that ever happened was on Connie, huh?

Talking a lot and no scummy posts by the "Extra careful" mafia is contradicting yourself....

Analyzing kills is pointless, because it comes up as a WIFOM argument. Your really just saying "Use your gut" which is not good enough for town.

Since your not going to lynch Anne, Angelo is a good pick...I don't like his Avatar, it looks arrogant.

[[MAFIA] Bertha]

Vote Angelo

Tell us who your suspects are.

[Romanic]

Can we lynch Bruno now?

My case is still the same, except that Bruno bothered to post these since I've made it:

You can find scum in different ways, my young Padawan.

GeneralHankerchief - Centurion1 (Connie) is not mentioned in the executed list.

A reply to my case. No defense at all, but it shows that he's following the game enough to realize that Centurion was missing from a list in the writeup.

Good rules.

Vote: Frank

Trying to lynch Frank, who was a possible WOG. Too easy, non committing, and he's still not making a case.

Vote: Anne

Trying to control the town?

Pfft, a vote for Anne, who's posting a lot, accusing her to "try to control the Town", which is a bad accusation. We need people looking for scum, stating who they suspects and why. It's not a mean to control the Town, it's a way to find our enemies. Something that Bruno isn't doing, he barely shows once in a while, to place a quick vote, with no reasoning backing it up.

11 posts total only. yet missing only two votes. That's more characteristic of lying low on purpose than a player who's uninterested by the game. And see the first post I've quote - He's following the game enough to spot a mistake in the tally.

Lynch Bruno

[[MAFIA] Angelo]

Vote Angelo

Tell us who your suspects are.

I will, Honey, don't you worry but you of all people should understand that I want to go eat breakfast first
Stand by