Mafia X [Concluded]

[[MAFIA] Richie]

Well I guess Bobby is innocent.

I was close to voting Anne last round, and I was wavering on whether or not to this round (She makes a decent case for Angelo), until I saw Richie's post.

vote: Richie

Lying and voting for a replacement who's WoG bait? Death, says I!

I don't know what to make of this post. Lying maybe, but voting for WoG bait shouldn't be the reason to vote me..
Assuming mafia has their QT and was discussing how they should react to my post. His swift response looks like town who was looking for a easy target.

Vote Richie

Scummy hey trying to avoid the wog hey.

This is just copying Fat Tony. I thought this was very strange.
If the mafia are inactive in their QT then I think this is the response that they'll come up with.

How is this helpful to anybody in any way? I...you...what...gah...I just can't see why you would want to do this, other than to be an annoyance. Plan successful:Vote: Richie

Correct response. Anyone who isn't mafia should be frustrated.

For the love a God, Richie, when you set yourself up for bait like that, lease you can do is vote for the guy as took it. That bein Fat Tony. Too much scumminess today, knock it off alla you.

Correct response. You have my trust.



I have my suspicion on Anne. You remained calm and tossed my post away as a joke.
You stuck to your plan and went for Johnny. Fact that Johnny case got popular suggests support from your dead team mate.
I'll be watching you.

After that I think Bertha then Fat Tony is the least likely of the three.

[White_eyes:D]

I have my suspicion on Anne. You remained calm and tossed my post away as a joke.
You stuck to your plan and went for Johnny. Fact that Johnny case got popular suggests support from your dead team mate.
I'll be watching you.

Centurion1 does have steam(?)....and it's being used to deceive people now.(ACIN springs to mind)

That's why I NEVER talk privately in any chat or social media (even RL for that matter) about mafia games...other then "it's a fun game". Getting into who you might think is a suspect, when the other person is not confirmed as a dead townie is just asking for trouble.

If people are listening to lynched unconfirmed townies or friend's of them.....try not to follow there line of thinking.

Now that I think about it...the votes really picked up when Anne was nearly lynched.

[[MAFIA] Anne]

I have my suspicion on Anne. You remained calm and tossed my post away as a joke.
You stuck to your plan and went for Johnny. Fact that Johnny case got popular suggests support from your dead team mate.
I'll be watching you

Curiouser and curiouser. Who is my dead team mate, may I ask?

If anyone is listening to the lynchees, they took silly pills this morning.

[[MAFIA] Johnny]

Richie, you whine a lot about my lynch for a guy who voted for me.

[Earthling]

No Anne, it's just you. Why, part of your reasoning for voting Johnny was that although you might have thought he was a townie and not a top suspect, you didn't want him around voting in the future. How hypocritical is that? Well, you're doing so poorly if you are a townie that you need to die so you have no vote to use either, as you'll probably vote off another townie and directly help the scum if you get to live and keep voting. However Luigi does still need to die first and if we're sure we can get a third lynch we could go for someone else before you.

[[MAFIA] Anne]

No Anne, it's just you. Why, part of your reasoning for voting Johnny was that although you might have thought he was a townie and not a top suspect, you didn't want him around voting in the future. How hypocritical is that? Well, you're doing so poorly if you are a townie that you need to die so you have no vote to use either, as you'll probably vote off another townie and directly help the scum if you get to live and keep voting. However Luigi does still need to die first and if we're sure we can get a third lynch we could go for someone else before you.

Situations are not analogous. Johnny was voting for me on provably insane and false reasoning, and I smashed his weak and wrong case to little itty bitty bits, with great relish and a huge grin on my face. It was very satisfying, and he had no rebuttal whatsoever.

He was just an additional vote for the scum team at this point, and so, he needed to die, seeing as no one was voting for Angelo, who I was trying to make dead.

Besides, as I've noted, I can be hypocritical all I want, because I'm a townie. Should I be mafia, then my hypocrisy could be used against me. Try and keep up.

[White_eyes:D]

Yes Anne, we all know your going to win and that's that, no need to rub it in anymore then you already have.

However, Earthling is a little all over the place.....but he is a confirmed townie, so whatever.

[Earthling]

Anne, YOU are an additional vote for the scum team at this point. It's exactly the same reasoning you just said about Johnny, not counting that you kinda lied about Johnny's statement being false when it wasn't as pointed out before. You're doing such a terrible job as a townie, if you are one, and are adamant you're going to keep trying to lynch other players who are very likely to be town. So your vote is only going to help the scum, and instead of several of the past failed lynches it would have been much better if you died and other townies lived. Still Luigi could possibly be the last scum if we got lucky on one of the early lynches so just get that right tomorrow and we'd be going somewhere.

[[MAFIA] Richie]

Richie, you whine a lot about my lynch for a guy who voted for me.

Sorry. I was planning to stick to my original vote, but I was about to get lynched.
That time I didn't have Anne= scum theory

[[MAFIA] Anne]

Sorry. I was planning to stick to my original vote, but I was about to get lynched.
That time I didn't have Anne= scum theory

You're worse than scum. You're Khaan!

I'mma get you, Khaan. Tonight you die!

[seireikhaan]

You're worse than scum. You're Khaan!

I'mma get you, Khaan. Tonight you die!

Not sure how that works. Unless I've been secretly zombified into life again. Or I haxored someone's account with my supar awesome mod skillz. Preferably the first, I guess.

[White_eyes:D]

Curiouser and curiouser. Who is my dead team mate, may I ask?

Centurion1 (Connie) funny how you stealthily overlook this.

I looked into it and Connie can PM most of the still living players left. I know Anne(Pizzaguy) is going to win this, he convinced town to lynch a detective with a guilty result on him in the first day round of some other game I can't remember ATM, no sweat. The pressure isn't even on Anne and we are nearing the end game.

[[MAFIA] Johnny]

Centurion1 (Connie) funny how you stealthily overlook this.

I looked into it and Connie can PM most of the still living players left. I know Anne(Pizzaguy) is going to win this, he convinced town to lynch a detective with a guilty result on him in the first day round, no sweat. The pressure isn't even on Anne and we are nearing the end game.

Hold on, something doesn't quite sound right here. Ah yes, this is the problem.

a detective

From the game rules:

Roles: This section will be short.

Mafiosi: (2)
The bad guys. The storyline is that they have invaded the Frontroom and are threatening to kill everyone present in the village. Each mafioso gets one kill per night, unless there is only one left. If this is the case, then the remaining mafioso gets to kill two people per night. This means that there will always be two kills per night, no matter what, unless there are either no more townspeople to kill or no more mafiosi to make the kills, in which case the game is over.

The mafia have some say in how much/little they put in their kill descriptions. It is up to the town to figure out how much is their work and how much is mine.

Townies: (everyone else)
Are you a townie in this game? Don't fret, so is (mostly) everyone else. Unlike in some of the more role-heavy games though, the townies are absolutely integral to the success or the failure of the town in the game, since there are no power roles to do the heavy lifting. The townies will only be able to win this game if they come together and take some time out to seriously do some detective work. Besides, you have a standard to live up to: Out of the nine games mentioned above and the 18 mafiosi, only two have ever escaped the town's wrath.

Specifically this tidbit:

no power roles

As can clearly be seen, you are lying. There are no detectives in this game. That much is made clear by the rules. So I am now certain that you were mafia. And that makes me even more certain that Richie is mafia as well. Also, Anne is starting to appear not so guilty after all (since there are only two mafia).

[White_eyes:D]

Johnny]As can clearly be seen, you are lying. There are no detectives in this game. That much is made clear by the rules. So I am now certain that you were mafia. And that makes me even more certain that Richie is mafia as well. Also, Anne is starting to appear not so guilty after all (since there are only two mafia).

Killed:
Winston Hughes (Chickenman)
robbiecon (Giuseppe)
Visorslash (Maria)
johnhughthom (Christopher)
issaikhaan (Furio)
Death is yonder (Carlo)
Seon (Fingers)
ELITEOFKINGWARMAN88 (Big George)
Earthling (Nick)
Csargo (Mickey)
Ashurnasirpal II (Salvatore)
B_Ray (Paulie)
White_eyes:D (Ralph)
Ignoramus (Luciano)
Romanic (Bobby)
Secura/a completely inoffensive name (Pete)

I WAS KILLED by the MAFIA, unless I missed something, I don't think you can kill your mafia buddy or yourself.....and it was meant to show how good Anne is not how this game works.

You were lynched and mistaken sooo....

[[MAFIA] Anne]

As amusing as this is, what with all the fail involved, I'd like to restore some sanity.


Firstly, White_Eyes was referring to a game wherein Askthepizzaguy was scum, a detective had a result on him, and he turned it around on the detective by claiming first. It was absolutely brilliant, and it almost didn't work, but a certain Fan kept talking and certain others found it scummy that he was trying to argue his case.

• You see, the more someone talks, the scummier they are.
• And, the less someone talks, the scummier they are.
• And, if someone talks the same amount you do, this is also somehow scummy. It's almost like they're trying to blend in with the others. Oh how scummy. I believe one successful case of someone talking "not too much, not too little" got White_Eyes' partner lynched in one game, even after that person claimed detective falsely.

Of course, Pizza had to die first, because his talking and accusing people was scummy. Then they got around to lynching the scumbag.

Here's why it was scummy:

Because scummy means whatever you want it to mean. It's utterly meaningless. That's why people ask other people WHY someone is scummy. That's the only way this whole mafia business turns from randomly voting each other into something resembling something intelligent.

Of course I'm scummy. Now, as I've prodded you guys before countless times, tell me WHY I am scummy.

Or you can just suggest I'm "lying" because you disagree with me, and say I'm "terrible" at this game. I love that, I find it amusing as all heck.



White_eyes is townie. And as usual, as in almost every single game, he's wrong about me. I sit my butt on top of his scum button, so it's constantly depressed. Only when I get off of that button to go murder someone does he think I'm innocent.

Earthling is townie. And as usual, he's saying everyone is terrible and a liar and blaming everyone else for a failure that hasn't happened yet.

I am a townie. You'll find that out when I'm murdered, or at the end of the game.

[[MAFIA] Anne]

Also, I just realized Furio was Khaan.

My bad.

Who the heck is pulling off a Khaan impression?

That's gotta be Kagemusha.

[White_eyes:D]

White_eyes is townie. And as usual, as in almost every single game, he's wrong about me. I sit my butt on top of his scum button, so it's constantly depressed. Only when I get off of that button to go murder someone does he think I'm innocent.

I am a townie. You'll find that out when I'm murdered, or at the end of the game.

Somebody is forgetting "Shadow Fort".....You recall how bad you framed me??

If I ever had such a "horrible loss" it was there. I recall how you sent me a PM rubbing it in, and how you were acting in thread, that you were sorry you didn't see White_eyes:D as scum sooner.

What reason? I was on your team, legitimately, for the entire time you were paranoid about me.

There was no reason, just White_Eyes being White_Eyes. Just like in the Pirate ship mafia... you freaked yourself out and ran away from my group and contributed nothing after that, and I was correct in chalking that up to you being you. If you're not freaking out for no reason, you're mafia.

Funny, after the game you said I was the biggest thing holding you back from killing after you were recruited, due to my paranoia.

I still got you back in Pirate ship mafia by CR though.

And no ATPG....I was investigated and seen doing nothing during Night 4-5? I am not a traitor like you....*looks away in disgust*

Anybody who thinks they can fool everyone is a fool. Just like you can't be 100% certain someone is mafia.

I knew you were just a misguided townie in that game but you still betrayed town. If I am Ned Stark, your Jamie Lainnister Etc.

I like how you keep not denying or just ignoring the Connie/Anne connection, or how the kills have been VERY beneficial to you.(No random bandwagons)

[[MAFIA] Bugsy]

Why would town listen to lynched townies???(who could be mafia and providing false info on purpose)

If anyone is listening to the lynchees, they took silly pills this morning.

... Because at best one of us were scum? I'm not saying you should adhere to us like you do the murdered players, but at least as much as the others who are alive...

Hold on, something doesn't quite sound right here. Ah yes, this is the problem.From the game rules:Specifically this tidbit:As can clearly be seen, you are lying. There are no detectives in this game. That much is made clear by the rules. So I am now certain that you were mafia. And that makes me even more certain that Richie is mafia as well. Also, Anne is starting to appear not so guilty after all (since there are only two mafia).

Please, please read the posts you are replying to before conjuring up a whole lot nothing and nonsense.

[[MAFIA] Sonny]

Correct response. You have my trust.

That don't help no one, sayin who you trust.