Netherworld III: Final Judgment [Concluded]

**glyphz** · 08-01-2011, 22:11

If he doesn't reveal by night's end, then the first order of the day is to place votes on him, if he is still alive by then.

edit: issaikhaan, the final tally is showing error, though it does not change that Arjos has the highest count

Tally:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read:

**woad&fangs** · 08-01-2011, 23:23

Curse you Pizza! I have been outed once again as a god. I am Brittania, the godly embodiment of the Britons. When you are ripped apart by my historically inaccurate war-dogs during the night phase, you will rue the day you voted for me!

**Askthepizzaguy** · 08-01-2011, 23:29

You do realize that I am pizza, and therefore accustomed to being ripped apart and eaten?

Why don't you threaten me with freezer burn or something actually scary.

**Romanic** · 08-02-2011, 00:04

Eh, so it looks like the writeups will come before I come back from work most days. :(

I believe we should let God Emperor alone for a while. Typical situation where he's either a power role or a bad guy. If he's still alive in 2 days we can force a claim out of him.

Luckily (or not) the Scums should make our decision easier, as they're likely to kill GE soon, unless they feel gutsy enough to let a possible power role acting around.

You don't lynch a possible power role just because he's shown surviving a night attack anyway. It would help if GE didn't write this though:

"sorry I am not still going to reveal much.. Well because I need to think it over a bit more, and I hope that can be accepted :) it's a bit difficult to decide what is good to reveal and what is not, but it will come. You can of course go forward to presure me into revealing all, but I would prefer that did not happen ^^"

Standing right next to TinCow about finding this scummy. Would have been better left unsaid.

**B-Wing** · 08-02-2011, 00:31

I'm gonna need to buy a smartphone just to keep up with these games while I'm at work.

I'm currently focused on the God Emperor question. I understand his position of not wanting to reveal his role on Day 1, but at the same time, he's almost guaranteed to be a mafia target very soon, if not tonight. So it doesn't seem like there's anything to lose by revealing now before it's too late (unless, of course, he's scum). Having said that, if he is indeed a pro-town role, I could also see how it might be preferable to keep his role secret, so that the mafia do not know what role they have eliminated. Perhaps a private reveal to someone he trusts would be best?

**GeneralHankerchief** · 08-02-2011, 00:41

Originally Posted by B_Ray

Perhaps a private reveal to someone he trusts would be best?

How can he trust anyone? How can any of us trust anyone? It's only Night 2.

**thefluffyone93** · 08-02-2011, 01:00

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

How can he trust anyone? How can any of us trust anyone? It's only Night 2.

You can definitely trust Pizza.
Absolutely no way he is scum.
No siree.

**God Emperor** · 08-02-2011, 22:04

Because of this quote ^^ I really don't like the way it sounds.. I almost get the feeling that he just sits and mock us, because he can say just about anything, being a troll. I would have picked ironside if it wasn't because I was told that it is normal for ironside to lurk around behind the scenes

Originally Posted by Thefluffyone93

You can definitely trust Pizza.
Absolutely no way he is scum.
No siree.

**B-Wing** · 08-02-2011, 01:01

I trust you, GH.

Even though I voted for TLD, I think he would be an obvious choice for GE right now. If I was in his place and thought I was about to die, that's probably what I would do.

**TinCow** · 08-02-2011, 01:53

For those who think GE needs to be given more time, I think you need to re-read the game rules. I have bolded the relevant portions for your convenience:

Originally Posted by issaikhaan

There will be one main mafia faction, consisting of four players. Their goal will be the extermination of all town forces and all neutral roles which may have conflicting victory conditions. There will be a number of pro-town roles, including at least one doctor, one watcher, a mason group, and a couple 'variety' roles to compliment the 'normal' townies. Lastly, as always, there will be a couple independent roles. These may have their own victory conditions, or may be able to tie themselves to a group(town or mafia). Generally speaking, I reserve the craziest of my ideas for neutrals, since they tend to start alone and have the hardest challenge for winning, so the independent roles might be a cult or a dragon or a shark with laser beams or anything else my brain has spawned. The main thing to expect is a fair bit of chaos and ambiguity. I rarely give yes/no or black/white answers to questions. Many roles which will have hidden abilities. If they do, you will never be told them by me, but with some homework, you may be able to guess on your own what they are. Some roles may gain or lose powers based on game events. If your role changes in this manner, I will inform you. Lastly, its a guilty pleasure of mine to confuse players, particularly pro-town networks. Make sure to take care of who you trust.

Pro-town roles do not survive night kills because it is not balanced. GE is almost certainly an independent role. Independent roles are major liabilities and should be eliminated because they can never be trusted, particularly in the Netherworld series. If you leave him alive for later, you will probably never lynch him. There will always be someone else who's scummier or who you think is more worthy of a lynch at that particular moment. Before you know it, there will be 4 people left, and one will be GE. Lynch him now. You won't get a better lynch option for Day 2. In addition, if you don't lynch him he will remain lynch bait forever for these reasons, and will constantly be a distraction to the town. Get it over with.