Netherworld III: Final Judgment [Concluded]

[Renata]

Perfect reasoning.

Vote: Woad&Fangs

LOL.

[Diamondeye]

I'm willing to believe that GE might be right, but I'm still going to Vote: God Emperor since it's our best lead. I'd be glad if made other use of this day than just bandwagon him, though, since one of the reasons it really is the best option is that it's "only day 2". If we just bandwagon GE, tomorrow we'll be none the wiser (probably), and even though it'll be Day 3, It'll feel like day 2, information wise. Let's not waste this day completely, please.

Also, great, only one death! Just blindly shouting out here, but Yaropolk looks like he was attacked by the mafia, but survived due to protection. He also looks like a normal townie. I would suggest that the shieldbearer from the writeup protects him again (if allowed), and that any exposed power-roles should claim to him. So, GE, in case you were lying about vanillaness, here's a chance to get off the hook without painting the world's largest bullseye on your rear-end.

[Zack]

Did anyone really believe someone would try to attack GE last night?

No, of course not. I was expecting the guy who attacked GE to attack someone else.

Also, great, only one death! Just blindly shouting out here, but Yaropolk looks like he was attacked by the mafia, but survived due to protection. He also looks like a normal townie. I would suggest that the shieldbearer from the writeup protects him again (if allowed), and that any exposed power-roles should claim to him. So, GE, in case you were lying about vanillaness, here's a chance to get off the hook without painting the world's largest bullseye on your rear-end.

There are more than just mafia and townies in this game, as khaan himself has said.

[Tratorix]

btw, where are all the killers? If the pearly lady is not one of the Mafia we saw only one Mafia kill today.

Atop a nearby roof, a woman shook her head. Her simple, tan robe fluttered slightly in the wind. “Truly, we were correct. Savages.” With that, she opened pearly wings, and jumped from her position.

He turned back to the stairs leading to the main level, only to startle upon seeing a woman dressed in a simple, tan, tunic, wings spread behind her.

She attacked Yaropolk.

[dcmort93]

Isn't it kinda surprising that the same person attacks two different people and both live? Could it be possible that there is some sort of mechanic in play that perhaps is preventing the killer from killing outside of a roleblock\protection attempt? Just something to think about

[Tratorix]

Who are you referring to? GE was attacked by a man with an axe, while Yaropolk was attacked by a woman with wings.

Edit: TLD, both of the killers are pretty obviously angels. They are most likely our mafia team. But don't worry, I understand it will take a few more nights of her killing indiscriminately for you to realize that.

[Riedquat]

Who are you referring to? GE was attacked by a man with an axe, while Yaropolk was attacked by a woman with wings.

Edit: TLD, both of the killers are pretty obviously angels. They are most likely our mafia team. But don't worry, I understand it will take a few more nights of her killing indiscriminately for you to realize that.

Sorry, isn't her who killed you after you killed Visorslash on night 1?

[TinCow]

Isn't it kinda surprising that the same person attacks two different people and both live? Could it be possible that there is some sort of mechanic in play that perhaps is preventing the killer from killing outside of a roleblock\protection attempt? Just something to think about

GE is the only person that survived without explanation. Yaropolk very clearly survived due to doctor protection.

[dcmort93]

Ok I had just been going off context when I posted that, sorry bout that

[TheLastDays]

You have to read my posts more carefully. I said if the pearly lady is not one of the Mafia we saw only one Mafia kill today.

I know she killed. We just can't be sure she's Mafia since she killed another killer on N1 as you well know

So if she's not Mafia, the only Mafia kill we saw tonight was the killing of B_Ray.

I just realised that there weren't any other kills N1, except the axe guy on G_E although he might be third party...

[Death is yonder]

Also, great, only one death! Just blindly shouting out here, but Yaropolk looks like he was attacked by the mafia, but survived due to protection. He also looks like a normal townie. I would suggest that the shieldbearer from the writeup protects him again (if allowed), and that any exposed power-roles should claim to him. So, GE, in case you were lying about vanillaness, here's a chance to get off the hook without painting the world's largest bullseye on your rear-end.

As might have been mentioned, claiming to attacked individuals may not be a great idea:

1. We don't know how much influence (or at least I don't recall it being said by 'khaan) the killers have on the writeup. I mean in Midgard III the town got confused by details released by the Jotun in write ups (EG: 'now there are two who remain' or something)
2. With third parties, being attacked isn't a clear pass ('looking human' ties in with point 3)
3. Who knows, maybe appearances in write ups are with cover roles (are they present?) when third party etc are attacked or conversely, mafia by third party

In any case, GE's responses thus far have not convinced me. There is a very clear attempt to try and deflect attention elsewhere, however subtle it may have been intended.

GE also still hasn't responded to:

1. The discrepancy as pointed out by Tincow in that:

a)

GE is the only person that survived without explanation. Yaropolk very clearly survived due to doctor protection.

b)

@ Tincow
I can not roleclaim, since I don't have a role

I did not defend myself because I am really not certain how much I wish to reveal at this stage. I need to think things a bit over.


Now for myself, I am sorry I am not still going to reveal much.. Well because I need to think it over a bit more, and I hope that can be accepted :) it's a bit difficult to decide what is good to reveal and what is not, but it will come. You can of course go forward to presure me into revealing all, but I would prefer that did not happen ^^

2. This unexplained yet significant issue with his claim (which corresponds to the fact that it seems like nobody protected him)

Pro-town roles do not survive night kills because it is not balanced.

All in all, a good lynch.

Vote: GE